Let’s have some fun throwing out a bunch of “what ifs” regarding Foothill League football.
Can it really be possible that one of our beloved high school football teams could finish with only one loss, be tied for the league championship, and yet be the league’s third-place representative in the playoffs?
Yes.
Is it possible that Hart High School, the three-time defending CIF Southern Section Division III champions currently holding a 51-game league winning streak, could finish third in league despite a claim of the 2001 league title?
Yes.
Looming large in the last week of the season is the very real possibility there could be a three-way tie for first in the league. Hart currently holds the top spot with Valencia and Saugus right behind. This Friday, Hart plays Canyon, Saugus travels to Burbank and Valencia hosts Burroughs.
The closest of those games this Friday could be the Burroughs-Valencia game, meaning Burroughs might beat the 27 1/ 2-point spread against the team ranked 5th in the Division III poll.
So assuming Hell is still fairly warm, the final week of the season should see Hart at 4-0 , with Valencia and Saugus at 3-1 . In the final games of the season on Nov. 9, Valencia takes on Canyon while Saugus and Hart have their annual showdown.
Now here’s where it gets interesting.
It is safe to say Valencia should beat Canyon, taking the Vikings to 4-1 in league. Should Saugus beat Hart, thereby ending what would then be the Indians’ 52-game league winning streak, Saugus and Hart would also finish 4-1 .
What makes this scenario even more interesting is that, should that happen, each would have beaten one of the other two. In other words, Valencia beat Saugus, Hart beat Valencia and (hypothetically speaking) Saugus beat Hart.
That means a literal three-way tie for the League championship.
In order to determine the seedings for the CIF playoffs, the federation allows each league to resolve ties. All that matters to the big boys running the playoffs is league placings must arrive at the CIF’s office by 9 a.m. Saturday, Nov. 10.
For the Foothill League, ties in standings first go to head-to-head competition, followed by a coin flip. That means that, should this scenario work out, all three teams would have no advantage over any others in head-to-head matchups. It would have to be resolved by a coin toss.
It’s not as if this is unprecedented. Last year, the same potential for a three-way thrill was there to be worked out, but Hart took care of Saugus in week 10, not only taking their ninth consecutive Victory Bell, eliminating any potential three-way drama.
At that time it was brought up out of the public eye to have a coin toss before the final game of the season, so each team would know what was on the line. However, that did not happen.
And what about this coin toss?
Some even question why it is necessary. Why not go to a points for and points given up tiebreaker? What about a strength of preseason schedule, determined by a simple points system similar to that of the BCS rankings. The point being, let the standings be determined by the play on the field rather than on the floor of a back room
But, that’s not reality.
So we’re back to the coin toss. One suggestion would be to have three coins tossed at the same time, with the odd one out being the first loser (i.e. third place finisher). The two left standing would have a regular coin toss to determine the league champion.
Of course, Canyon, Burbank and Burroughs would have to lose this weekend in order to set up this scenario, followed by a Vikings thumping of the Cowboys in week 10 that would set up the Saugus/Hart game question.
And that’s what it really comes down to: can Saugus beat Hart? Can the psychological grip the Hart Indians hold over the rest of the league be snapped?
And can the SCV Chamber of Commerce beat The Mighty Signal in broomball?
Naw, but it is rather entertaining for some to consider.
David Caldwell’s column appears every Tuesday in The Signal. He can be reached at [email protected]
