ArchiveSCV
the-signal.com. The Santa Clarita Valley Signal. Back to the collection.

· the-signal.com, Wayback capture

Are you teaching your child to hit?

Four-year-old Emily Garcia is an active, bubbly and talkative little girl. With a heart-melting smile, big, beautiful brown eyes and sweet disposition, the energetic pre-schooler rarely causes her mother a moment's grief.

What does happen when she misbehaves?

"I get a time-out, or sometimes a spanking," she answers matter-of-factly.

Does this answer raise eyebrows among 90's "modern" parents in today's society of staunch political correctness?

"Some people might think it's wrong, but I don't see anything wrong with spanking as long as it's not frequent," said Emily's mother, Sharon Garcia, a five-year resident of the Santa Clarita Valley.

"I agree that spanking shouldn't be the only way a parent gets their child's attention, but I don't think it's a terrible thing," Garcia continued.

A business development assistant, Garcia believes her parental techniques were heavily influenced by the way she was raised by her own parents.

"Everybody is influenced by their background," she said. "It worked for my parents and it works for me."

Spanking as Discipline

According to Penny A. Ritter, M.S.W., B.C.D, a licensed clinical social worker, spanking children as a means of discipline is not an ideal method of reinforcing positive behavior.

"There's no need to hit a child," said Ritter, who has offered counseling services for individuals, couples, children and adolescents through her Valencia-based private practice for 20 years. "(Spanking) draws attention to the discipline and away from the behavior the parent is trying to correct."

According to Dr. Loraine Stern, a pediatrician at Valencia Pediatric Associates in Santa Clarita, spanking as punishment for misbehavior only works temporarily.

"Spanking may stop the negative behavior, but it doesn't teach a child anything;" she said. "Using spanking to teach children how to behave is counter-productive."

Spanking is commonly a parent's reaction to anger or fear, such as when a child is caught lighting matches or running into the middle of the street, explained Ritter. Although understandable in such cases, she said this form of reactionary discipline can actually have negative repercussions.

"Children are going to model our behaviors and spanking just teaches them how to overpower somebody else with physical might," said Ritter. "Later, they may go out and bully their friends."

Ari Levy, Ph. D., a licensed psychologist and clinic director of the Santa Clarita Child and Family Development Center in Saugus, said spanking children "demonstrates a lack of parental creativity." He recommends child-rearing books, magazines, videos or classes as helpful resources for parents seeking alternatives to spanking.

"The bottom line is that parents use spanking when they don't know what else to do," said Levy. "If you're interested in being a good parent, find out what else you can do (and) why it will work better."

Levy said he believes spanking reflects incorrect expectations of children and stresses that parents have to keep in mind that children come into the world with one purpose: to get away with everything and anything they can. He said "acting out" is the only way children learn what's acceptable.

"That's where the job of the parent comes into play," said Levy. "Parents have to teach their child what they can and can't get away with."

Levy said this teaching process can be successfully accomplished through active parenting, without resorting to spanking.

For example, he said parents must firmly and regularly enforce "rules" and should never wait until they are angry to dole out punishments for misbehavior.

"What we cannot do is be couch potato parents. We have to intervene before we get angry," said Levy, noting that parents who typically wait until they are angry to discipline their child are more likely to resort to spanking as a punishment tactic.

Alternatives to Spanking

According to information provided by Levy, Ritter, Stern and the American Academy of Pediatrics, the following recommendations offer parents viable alternatives to spanking:

Make sure your child is aware of the "rules" they are expected to adhere to and of the consequences they will face if they don't (such as "time-outs" or taking away special privileges).

Don't threaten; if you clearly state the consequences of misbehavior, always follow through with them or you will risk diminishing your parental authority.

Be consistent with discipline; spontaneous or sporadic discipline is likely to lead to spontaneous behavior from children.

Clearly inform your child that if he/she "chooses" to misbehave, then he/she is "choosing" to face the promised consequences or punishments.

Avoid disciplining your child when you are angry.

Enforcing Alternatives

According to Ritter, effective and loving discipline begins with communication, noting that the use of an authoritative voice, direct eye contact and strong body language are efficient non-physical alternatives to spanking. Additionally, she said parents must regularly and continually enforce rules in a structured atmosphere.

"If kids have routine and structure, they learn what the limits are and what the parameters are that they have to adhere to," said Ritter. "I think discipline is about establishing what's important. It's part of the whole package of being a role model."

According to Levy, if a child is told 'no' nine times and the parent doesn't enforce discipline until the tenth time, the child will learn that the first nine times don't count. In this example, he said the child will learn that they only have to pay attention when mom or dad is angry or when there's a threat of getting spanked.

"You're also getting across the fact that words don't count," said Levy.

Levy, Ritter and Stern all stressed the importance of giving children positive attention for positive behavior. Levy said numerous studies have shown that regular rewards are more effective than frequent punishments.

"If you always follow through on reinforcing the positive, you'll have an easier time disciplining," said Levy. "Children should be rewarded for good behavior, although that doesn't mean a trip to Disneyland."

According to Levy, Ritter and Stern, parents can give rewards in the form of hugs, verbal praise, enthusiasm or excitement.

"Appropriate discipline really is age specific and developmental specific," said Ritter. "Each child is unique and parents may have to take different approaches with each of their children."

Garcia agrees that different disciplinary tactics will work for different children and different families.

"I believe parents should use whatever works for them," she said, noting that her daughter is aware that occasional spanking is a possible consequence of misbehavior. "Whether it's politically correct or not, I think most people would agree that there's nothing wrong with spanking a child on their bottom once in a while.

"And," she continued, "I think there's a big difference between abusing your kids and spanking them occasionally in order to enforce your personal beliefs and values."

← Back to 1998

About this record

How it was held, read and classified

Record details

Morris ID
Not a Morris ID. This record is keyed ts-df:/vitality/1198/111998a.html.
System
date-file pages (/desk/MMYY/MMDDYY.html)
Reading copy
the-signal.com
Chosen by: only copy held. On this copy: words 1,106 (e-mail addresses counted as one token); reader comments 0 (counted, not reproduced here); images 0.
Extracted by
datefile:SLUG_to_rule
signal-extract/0.15 (2026-11-16)

Other copies

Held
None. The holding has this article from one host only.

How it was classified

Label
clearly-local
Judgment
A machine’s (recorded as machine), kept as one so it can be revisited.
Classifier
signal-localclass/0.7 (2026-11-12)
Local signals
  • text:valley_names [3 distinct/6 mentions: Santa Clarita, Valencia, Saugus]
  • byline:named_writer_no_wire_credit [By MARIA L. TORRES]
National signals
none fired
Scores
local 4, national 0