ArchiveSCV
the-signal.com. The Santa Clarita Valley Signal. Back to the collection.

· the-signal.com, Wayback capture

Should I Stay, Should I Go Now?

With a new year comes hope; hope for a better life, for reaching goals, and possibly for starting fresh with your marriage or relationship. If life together as a couple mostly works for both of you, but certain issues get in the way of happiness and satisfaction, you may be a candidate for starting fresh—really diving into a plan for improvement; implementing some basic changes, polishing your communication and intimacy skills and making long over due changes.

Sometimes the new year, and a fresh approach, can go a long way to motivating change. Sometimes starting fresh is enough.

However, when love challenges us, and when our hopes and expectations for smooth sailing are dampened by unexpected storms, and it looks as if love is going down for the last time, our relationship can be a confusing, scary, frustrating, and maddening place to be.

Struggling with a decision to stay or move on takes courage to look at the hard stuff, and to ask the tough questions. Questions like "Am I with the right person?" and "If I am with the right person, how come love isn't working?" The answers aren't always easy to come by. Relationships are complicated, and it may take time to sort out the emotional craziness of what's happening between you and the person you once believed, without question, would be your partner for life.

Finding answers requires honesty. It requires truthful communication with your partner: really listening and really telling.

It's a time to reach deep down inside and find out what you are made of. A time when we question what's really important in life what our values are and how they have taken on new meaning in the context of the adult world of relationships, a time when we ask ourselves questions about character, commitment, and happiness.

It's a time when we may question our need to take care of others instead of our self or our need to take care of our self before others. It's a time filled with "what if's" and sometimes, "if only's. It's a time when we wish we could see into the future and find some certainty in our decisions.

In short, it's a time filled with self-doubt. At the same time, it's when we are most apt to look within, to grow and to take a step toward happiness. We struggle for truth and certainty, and all the while our heart is torn, stretched, tugged at, and maybe even broken.

In such a moment of emotional chaos, counseling may assist in establishing a safe and honest forum where the truth can be looked at without blame and attack. It can help couples to sort through their issues and to address others which may be hard to talk about.

If basic compatibility, love and willingness to work through the issues exists, then healthy changes can move the couple to a place where love can begin to work again.

If not, counseling can help the couple to communicate about their decision to leave the relationship. Sometimes, couples may not be able to identify what's in their heart until the process of sorting it out together takes place. In this way, counseling can be a process of finding clarity.

The following are three basics which many experts believe are necessary for the foundation of a successful relationship. It may provide some food for thought.

You and your partner are able to give each other the love you each need.

There are lots of things we can do independently in life: the pursuit of jobs/hobbies, enjoying children and friends, etc., but without the sense that our existence makes a big difference in someone else's life, without the sense that we are special and valued by someone else and that we are truly loved, emotional fulfillment is hard to come by.

If you aren't getting the love you need, relationship work can be done to uncover the reasons and to assess whether healing and new relationship skills will repair the situation. The reasons for feeling unloved may be varied—some can be remedied, others may not.

You and your partner are compatible; in most areas you get along.

Compatibility is not possible in all areas, but the more compatible you and your partner are in basic areas, the better your chance for success. Areas include personal interests and/or hobbies, health practices (use of drugs, cigarettes, diet, exercise, philosophical, educational and moral attitudes, social style, taste, spiritual and/or religious perspective, professional and/or financial goals, and style of expressing love and affection. If you don't feel compatible with your partner, he/she probably feels the same about you.

You and your partner are willing to grow in the same direction at about the same speed — you are both open to adapting, learning, changing and growing together.

Our willingness to challenge ourselves in life and grow together is important for the simple reason of sharing an emotional journey. If one is stuck and the other is moving, emotional intimacy and fulfillment are next to impossible to achieve. A commitment to staying connected spiritually can make up for many differences, e.g. one works, one is at home, different working or parenting styles, differences in professional or educational goals.

If you find that your relationship is solid in regards to the basics of compatibility, mutual personal growth, and are at least potentially able to meet each other's needs to feel loved, then less critical issues between you can be addressed and improved. Skills can be learned to enhance communication, express love, develop intimacy, and find common ground for enjoying each other.

If all of this sounds like a lot of work and you find yourself thinking "it may be easier to start over with someone you have no history with", in the long run a new history with the new mate will develop and if you haven't resolved what didn't work in the first relationship, you are likely to find yourself back where you started in the first place. Working through issues with your present partner can provide a more fulfilling and satisfying future and may represent a big step toward happiness.

On the other hand, certain high risk relationships are likely to struggle without resolve. In this case. emotional fulfillment may be hard to come by.

One or both partners are addicts, e.g., drug abuser, sex addict, child molester, womanizer, compulsive gambler, alcoholic, or any other self-destructive behavior. Relationship work cannot be successful until the addict addresses the addiction.

Violent relationships where a partner is being attacked either verbally, emotionally, or physically. This issue needs to be resolved first.

Relationships where one partner is already married.

One partner, or both, are very young. You are not able to be comfortable with yourself in the presence of your partner.

Your values and lifestyle preferences are radically different.

Deciding whether you are starting fresh or starting over is challenging at best. Sometimes, our impatience to find answers stands in the way of taking inventory together and allowing time to shed light on our uncertainties.

Starting fresh requires a readiness and willingness to look within, to respond to what exists in the moment not what was before, to really listen and try to understand, to be compassionate and passionate, forgiving, giving, accepting, admiring and loving, and above all, to discover why you should stay rather than why you should leave.

* * *

Barbara Beebe has a masters degree in Marriage, Family, and Child Counseling and practices in Santa Clarita as a registered MFCC intern working with couples and families. If you are interested in writing a guest column for Vitality, contact Jennifer Kuptz at 259-1234, ext. 236.

← Back to 1999

About this record

How it was held, read and classified

Record details

Morris ID
Not a Morris ID. This record is keyed ts-df:/vitality/beebe/010799.html.
System
other
Reading copy
the-signal.com
Chosen by: only copy held. On this copy: words 1,278 (e-mail addresses counted as one token); reader comments 0 (counted, not reproduced here); images 0.
Extracted by
datefile:SLUG_to_rule
signal-extract/0.15 (2026-11-16)

Other copies

Held
None. The holding has this article from one host only.

How it was classified

Label
clearly-local
Judgment
A machine’s (recorded as machine), kept as one so it can be revisited.
Classifier
signal-localclass/0.7 (2026-11-12)
Local signals
  • text:valley_names [1 distinct/1 mentions: Santa Clarita]
  • byline:named_writer_no_wire_credit [Commentary by BARBARA BEEBE]
National signals
none fired
Scores
local 3, national 0