ArchiveSCV
the-signal.com. The Santa Clarita Valley Signal. Back to the collection.

· the-signal.com, Wayback capture

Why do we punish the ones we love?

If true love means a deep and profound caring for another person. If love means respect, intimacy, sharing, partnership, and possibly a desire to spend lives, even in some cases eternity, together. If love means finding that very special person with whom we assign our adoration, passion, and tenderness. If love is powerful enough to evoke feelings of ecstasy and forever-afters. If all of this, and more, represents our concept of true love, then how come when the object of our desires falls from the grace of our expectations, we punish?

Why do we seem to reserve a more stern, or even cruel, method of punishment for our lover than we would dole out to an enemy?

Perhaps the answer to this question lies in the spirit of human nature itself. Or, perhaps punishment is something we observed being applied during our childhood. True, as children we often learn the most insidious of behaviors from adults who are in charge of teaching us how to become "good people." Typically, such teaching is out of awareness and neither party is conscious of the lesson, that will influence the interaction of future relationships, at the time of learning. Or maybe, punishment is something that we come up with all by ourselves when our hurt and disappointment provokes an unconscious need to strike back, to pay back, to teach our loved one a lesson to never hurt us again or else...

Whatever the origin, or motivation, punishment of a loved one may manifest in several forms, some readily recognizable by even the most casual observer, and some more subtle which may go undetected for some time even by the punisher him/herself. If you believe you may have experienced punishing behaviors, either as enforcer or recipient, review the following and see which ones, if any, seem familiar.

Emotional Cut-off. Withholding of your love, verbal caring, time, emotional presence—cutting your own feelings of love off. "Because of your imperfection, I will no longer love you..." A severe punishment which, in effect, deprives the relationship of nurture.

Silence. Cutting off communication, and often eye contact, refusing to participate in a verbal connection. This punishment discounts your lover's presence in your life. Designed to make your partner feel devalued, invisible, impotent, shut-out.

Sexual Cut-off. Refusing love-making as an indirect, or direct, message that your partner has displeased you and is not worthy of being loved.

Doling out of consequences. Purposeful enforcement of arbitrary consequences, for partner's infringements (judged by punisher), as if loved-one is a child, and punisher is the parent. This behavior indicates that the consequence-giver assumes he/she is superior in judgment and assessment, and has taken on the parentified role of teaching his/her inferior mate.

Leaving partner out of the loop. Another punitive behavior which signals that the "offending" partner is not worthy of being included in daily decision-making, plans, or other arrangements. Deprives partner of input. Invalidates partner's presence. No longer confiding in partner. Withholding the sharing of personal events, thoughts, feelings, dreams, goals desires. Withdrawing of vulnerability which results in loss of closeness and understanding.

Choosing to get needs met (companionship, conversation, sharing of joys and fears, possibly even sexual needs) by others instead of partner. This might take the form of getting needs met by family members, friends, co-workers, affairs, or work itself.

Withdrawing respect for partner's opinion. Sends message "You have wronged me so I no longer value your opinion."

Withdrawing affectionate expression of caring — hand-holding, cuddling, smiling, admiring gazes, a touch, verbal caresses, etc.

Verbal put-downs, sarcasm, making fun of partner. These can be indirect messages of anger and ineffective communication.

Blaming partner for relationship difficulties and for punisher's own lack of caring.

Typically, "punishments" are designed to give the "offending" partner the message that he/she has committed a serious offense and therefore needs to pay. The underlying implication is that the offender is somehow bad and unworthy of love.

Once administered, the "enforcer" may not be clear about how much punishment he/she intends to apply. If the loved one is confused and hurt by the punishment, the enforcer may be encouraged believing that the punishment has been effective.

If the initial response of the punished partner is one of vulnerability, the enforcer may be spurred on to additional punishment. If a little bit got such a heartfelt response, more may just keep the loved one "where he/she needs to be," vulnerable, confused, and even squirming. In this way, punishing becomes a dysfunctional way of dealing with disappointment.

Punishment may continue to be administered, out of awareness, until the punished partner is no longer willing to be treated as the offender. He/she may come to recognize that love has become unloving. At this point, feeling overwhelmed by the sense of being wronged by the one he/she loves, the punished may disengage his/her own affection, and love is at risk of fatality.

The problem with punishing the one we love, is that we pay the price in the long run. Often, out of consciousness, punishing behaviors are administered out of frustration and a lack of skill in getting needs met in a nurturing way.

Learning how to communicate with our partner about our most vulnerable of needs, wishes, and desires in a direct manner is a first step toward healthy interaction. Keeping the issues out on the table so that both parties can work on them is critical. When issues go underground, and fail to be shared, resolution is next to impossible.

Without both parties input and desire to find solutions, there is little chance that issues can be aired, and that love can receive the healthy nurturance it needs to grow and flourish. When punishing behaviors become an integral part of how the couple relates, professional counseling may assist in identifying what's going on, and guiding the development of healthier ways of relating.

Unlike punishment which fosters ill-feelings and resentment, learning about each other in an emotionally nurturing relationship fosters love and strengthens the bond of trust and caring.

* * *

Barbara Beebe holds a masters degree in Marriage, Family and Child Counseling and works with couples and families in her private practice in Santa Clarita. If you would like to write a guest column for Vitality, contact Jennifer Kuptz at 259-1234, ext. 236.

← Back to 1998

About this record

How it was held, read and classified

Record details

Morris ID
Not a Morris ID. This record is keyed ts-df:/vitality/beebe/120398.html.
System
other
Reading copy
the-signal.com
Chosen by: only copy held. On this copy: words 1,046 (e-mail addresses counted as one token); reader comments 0 (counted, not reproduced here); images 0.
Extracted by
datefile:SLUG_to_rule
signal-extract/0.15 (2026-11-16)

Other copies

Held
None. The holding has this article from one host only.

How it was classified

Label
clearly-local
Judgment
A machine’s (recorded as machine), kept as one so it can be revisited.
Classifier
signal-localclass/0.7 (2026-11-12)
Local signals
  • text:valley_names [1 distinct/1 mentions: Santa Clarita]
  • byline:named_writer_no_wire_credit [Commentary by BARBARA BEEBE]
National signals
none fired
Scores
local 3, national 0