An assertion by a former Hart district assistant superintendent that four new schools came in $17 million to $20 million over budget is being disputed by the district's director of facilities.
Director of Facilities Michael Otavka - who oversees new building construction for the William S. Hart Union High School District - said West Ranch and Golden Valley high schools, Rio Norte and Rancho Pico junior high schools are not over budget.
The original assertion came from former assistant superintendent for business, Rory Livingston, and was reported in a June 29 article regarding how modernization projects on two existing, older schools came in over budget by $18.6 million. After explaining how the lion's share of those costs were due to inflated construction costs over the past several years, Livingston mentioned that the four new schools also came in over budget between $17 million and $21 million.
Otavka said that three of the new schools - West Ranch and Golden Valley highs and Rancho Pico Junior High - were designed before the district applied for the states' financial hardship program. The state accepted the district's application in December 2000 for all three schools because it agreed that the severe overcrowding in the existing schools needed to be alleviated.
However, even though the state paid for 100 percent of the cost of each school, it is only for a bare bones school, which includes classrooms but no amenities, Otavka said.
So, because the district wanted Rancho Pico to have a gymnasium and the two high schools to be equipped with athletic fields, performing arts centers and other extras, the costs escalated.
"Rory Livingston was talking about being $2.5 (million) to $3 million over budget on West Ranch and Golden Valley because he was talking about the difference between the state (hardship) program and the additional dollars the district needs to budget to build the schools with the standard amenities," Otavka said.
Golden Valley High was budgeted at $79 million, which is tracking at about 0.6 percent under budget right now, Otavka said. It was completed in 2004, 1 1/2 years after construction started, he added.
There were problems, as there are with all buildings, including an electrical contractor who went bankrupt and caused delays, he said.
West Ranch High was budgeted at $77 million and is tracking at about 1 percent under budget, Otavka said.
"We believe those two high schools will be at about budget," Otavka said. "There are little bits and pieces doing final punch lists."
Rancho Pico cost $38 million, not including the gymnasium.
The district is building the gymnasium and is adding other amenities, which will be paid for by developers' fees and Measure V funds, which citizens voted for several years ago.
Part of the reason the new schools were on budget when the modernization at Arroyo Seco Junior High was over budget by $13.9 million is because Arroyo Seco was done in three phases and "we had some wild construction inflation," Otavka said.
Prior to construction inflation taking off, we were able to award bids. That was not the case with Arroyo Seco, Otavka said. There were other problems as well.
He could not explain why in November 2005 Arroyo Seco was believed to be $2.7 million over budget but came in so much higher.
Another modernization project at Canyon High had been projected in November to come in $237,771 over budget, but instead came in $4.7 million over budget seven months later.
Otavka's responsibilities are for new construction, not modernization projects.
