War is not the answer. Give peace a chance. The other night, Carrie and I saw a trailer for an upcoming movie about John Lennon's anti-war protests. Old-timers remember brother Lennon's unabashed in-our-face anti-war stance. The sleep-in with Yoko Ono. The anti-war songs. The demonstrations. John Lennon was so blunt - and so influential that the State Department attempted deporting him. Lennon remained resolute through it all: "War is not the answer." "Give peace a chance."
Yeah, I know, Lennon was just a rich rock star, and what would a musician who'd traveled all over the world know about people and things, anyhow?
But Lennon did get it right. War isn't the answer. War's tragic expense hasn't bought us anything but hell on Earth. It certainly has not bought us peace, and it can't buy us love.
A Rebel of substantially greater gravitas looked around the world of his time and also concluded that peace is the right answer:
"You shall love your neighbor as yourself."
A few thousand years earlier, you heard it even more clearly:
"Thou shalt not kill."
So simple, even fundamentalists should understand. "Thou shalt not kill."
This week hasn't been particularly rewarding for the followers of Jesus Christ or The God of Abraham and Moses - or for fans of John Lennon.
Allegedly, some Hezbollah operatives thought it would be a particularly smart move to steal across the Israeli border and shoot up some soldiers, kidnapping a couple more for use as bargaining chips in a prisoner exchange. Not the kind of actions that build trusting neighbors.
After taking flack for a week and a half over a similar Palestinian-engineered kidnapping, Israel's leaders were in no mood for cool heads and measured responses. They took the bait, let 'er rip, and have been unloading their arsenal on the Lebanese civilian population and infrastructure ever since - initially, to punish the apparent perpetrators of a small-time border raid and kidnapping.
Early on, Israel bombed Lebanon's new airport. I was heartbroken when I saw photos of the attack.
Lebanon has just emerged from protracted civil war and upheaval which had turned a once wonderful country into the violent playground of the Middle East. Stability finally arrived a decade ago, and the multicultural peoples of Lebanon have busied themselves rebuilding their fair country. Their spanking-new airport is a symbol of the peaceful progress they've achieved. But that's gone now.
Israel's military has gone into an uncontrolled frenzy of killing and destruction. Highways, bridges, offices, ports, power plants, refineries - in just a few days, Israel has pounded Lebanon back two decades and has murdered hundreds of civilians who had no part in the border raid.
For its part, Hezbollah apparently started the conflict, and once Israeli bombs rained into Lebanon, Hezbollah responded by raining their own shells on hapless Israeli civilians - who, like their counterparts in Lebanon, were previously content just to go to work each day and enjoy the occasional latte or cup of tea with friends during breaks. But that's gone now.
However it started, it has become war. Leaders from both sides beat their chests like gorillas, attempting to rally their minions and instill dread and fear in opposing civilian hearts.
Hezbollah's Sheik Nasrallah: "The Zionist entity is ignorant of what we have on all levels." "We are proud that we are not penetrated by Israeli intelligence, and we have been building up our forces on all levels in secret, waiting for the day when Israel would penetrate Lebanon."
Israeli Defense Minister Amir Peretz: "We must continue with wide-reaching actions and great power while imposing continuous pressure without hesitation." "At the end of this conflict, we must bring Hezbollah to a point where it would not be possible for the organization to return to the international border and the line of fire."
George Bush, setting the regional tone a couple of years back: "Bring it on."
Despite hundreds of civilians already murdered, all of this warfare has achieved only a handful of military casualties, on both sides. An innocent public again takes the brunt of reckless war.
Says Yemen Srour, a 60-year-old Lebanese housewife, "Why are we killing each other? Why are we creating these victims?" "I don't think there is a point to this."
But what does Mrs. Srour know? She's just a grandma who just lost her home and a couple of nice kids from down the street.
Interestingly, the first Lebanese casualties were Canadian citizens.
War is as inaccurate as it is needless.
Whatever goodwill was generated by the recent Lebanese peace has again turned to hatred. Lebanese citizens, Christian and Islamic, must be pretty damned furious. An ill-conceived Hezbollah border raid triggers an entire country being thrown back to ruins.
Not unlike it, George Bush glibly elects to take out Saddam Hussein and his cronies. The result: The death of some 50,000 Iraqi civilians at U.S. hands and a once-modern Iraq thrown back to the Stone Age.
War is not the answer. All of the Middle East is further estranged from the U.S. and Israel. Islamic states are even more convinced to emulate North Korea's weapons programs to inoculate themselves from Western attacks.
Human losses skyrocket when war is the easy answer our impatient leaders choose. Ordinary people, civilian and soldier alike, pay the high price of trigger-happy governmental violence. In war, everyone loses - except munitions companies.
The stock market crashed 500 points last week. But Lockheed Martin and General Dynamics surged.
For the merchants of death, war gets the factories humming. If you assemble artillery shells for a job, congrats; you'll be getting overtime pay. For the rest of us workers of the world, the wages of war are just more death and suffering.
Whatever the right answer eventually turns out to be, one thing looks sure: War isn't it.
"War is not the answer." "Give peace a chance."
Gary Horton lives in Valencia. His column reflects his own views, and not necessarily those of The Signal.
