The Hart board has hired an accounting firm to "put all the cards on the table" and will begin investigating as early as next Friday why modernization projects at three local schools went so far over budget, the board said Wednesday in a special meeting.
"We just want to have full disclosure. We don't want to hide anything," said board member Gloria Mercado-Fortine.
Colbi Technologies Inc. was chosen to audit the budgets of the modernization construction costs at Arroyo Seco Junior High School, and Saugus and Canyon high schools. It was selected among two other companies because of its strong experience with school sites, said Jamie Castellanos, superintendent of the William S. Hart Union High School District.
Company chair Lettie Boggs, who will lead the audit, was formerly the assistant superintendent of facilities and operations at Anaheim City School district.
"She knows schools inside and out," Castellanos said. "She'll be looking at each of the three modernizations and look at every expenditure from the beginning of the project to see where costs escalated and why. She's done this many times before."
Boggs is charging $150 per hour for her services and $90 an hour for work performed by her associates. Based on information from Boggs, it is typically $10,000 to audit each project, so the entire audit of the modernizations should not exceed $30,000, Castellanos said.
"I tend to think that (Colbi Technologies) won't be spending as much time at Saugus - that one is right on budget," Castellanos said.
The focus will be on Canyon High and Arroyo Seco, both of which are now costing drastically more than expected. In November 2005, it was reported to the board that construction at Arroyo Seco would be $2.7 million over budget, but by June was projected to be $13.9 million over budget.
Canyon High was estimated to be only $237,771 over budget in November, but that number jumped to $4.7 million over the original plan estimations in June, according to a report presented to the board by Rory Livingston, former assistant superintendent for the district.
At Arroyo Seco, the costs were dramatically increased for a number of reasons that "have compounded upon one another," according to the June report. Such factors in the increase included deficient quality of existing plans, mandating $5 million in change orders and the fact that a company contracted to build a modular building went bankrupt, causing delays and adding costs.
Livingston's report also stated that Canyon High experienced an 18-month delay after questions were raised about the geological integrity of the site. There were another $500,000 in gymnasium upgrades that were not in the original plans. Further, school personnel demanded additional work on the scope of the project, requiring expensive change orders.
It is expected that Colbi Technologies will interview everyone involved in the modernization projects, including people at C.W. Driver, the construction company that has done the work at the schools, and the progress will be reported back to the board members in weekly updates, Castellanos said.
Since Livingston's report in June, the board has been given two updates on the construction progress of the schools, but they had not been enough to pinpoint where costs were specifically coming from, said board member Patricia Hanrion.
"To tell the truth, it's very difficult to quantify exactly what was allocated, where it came from and why. I don't think that anyone could anticipate that costs would double and triple," Hanrion said. "We want to be honest with the public because it's their money."
