Whom are we trying to kid? There's triple digit temperatures for days on end, the office air conditioning is broken and we want the boss to buy us ice cream. So it seemed natural for an "Escape I Scream for Ice Cream Tour."
The Signal's Features staff - Anne Marie Mills, Annemarie Donkin, Rachel Stern and myself - anointed ourselves as "ice cream connoisseurs" (like who isn't?) and headed out to sample every decadent frosty, frozen and frigid treat we could.
Is there a condition known as "too much ice cream?"
Collectively, we decided it was impossible to have too much ice cream.
Is there anything remotely like "bad" ice cream?
Our verdict? Not on this planet or any other.
However, we did our due diligence and ranked each store we visited on a variety of criteria including cleanliness, friendly fast service, fresh ice cream, price, flavors of ice cream and mix-ins and uniqueness.
We sampled different ice cream varieties and special creations at each store we visited.
Our tour took us to Baskin Robbins, Ben and Jerry's, Cold Stone Creamery, Dairy Queen, Dippin' Dots, Farrells Ice Cream Parlour, Golden Spoon Frozen Yogurt and Maggie Moos.
Honestly, we know that each of these stores caters to a different clientele and customers have different expectations of each (with the exception of Cold Stone and Maggie Moos, which are virtual clones). However, it was interesting to note that the judging crew truly enjoyed every product we sampled (with the exception of the daiquiri ice - who knew that rum and ice cream weren't a great match?)
After totaling our sticky ice cream-stained judging sheets it turns out that our "Best of the Best" was a three way tie with Maggie Moos, Baskin Robbins and Farrells toting up identical scores.
In truth, the totals were so close it might as well have been an eight-way tie.
Maggie Moos received top marks for quality of ice cream, lower marks for lack of indoor seating.
"This is really wonderful ice cream," said Annemarie Donkin. "For sheer quality it could easily be the best we've tasted."
Maggie Moos makes ice cream fresh, on site, four times a week in the summer.
We sampled the "S'mores Fun Than a Campfire" Escape treat (perfect for the Escape team) which included chocolate ice cream, marshmallows and Teddy Grahams.
Baskin Robbins earned top marks for the variety of ice cream and for not resting on its laurels.
"Baskin Robbins has kept up with the times," said Anne Marie Mills. "There is also that whole sense-memory experience. It is the ice cream of our childhoods. Baskin Robbins is king."
We tasted mint chocolate chip, jamoca and the ill-fated daiquiri ice (that was my choice.)
Donkin particularly liked the tiny pink tasting spoons.
"I kept three of the iconic, tiny, pink tasting spoons and tasted everything with it. Ice cream just tastes better on the tiny spoon," she said.
Farrell's was also a big hit with the tour.
"Oh, baby!" said Mills, who particularly was entranced by the flaming sugar cube atop our Mount Saint Helens (a river of hot fudge and hot caramel over scoops of vanilla, chocolate and strawberry ice cream with nuts, whipped cream and a cherry).
"In the world of championship ice cream eating Farrell's Ice Cream Parlour is truly an original," said Donkin. "Challenging people to each humongous amounts of ice cream and toppings became their claim to fame."
Farrell's, inside Mountasia Family Fun Center, is a special "destination" event. Perfect for birthdays and other special occasions.
I loved the decor, old-timey ice cream parlour with faux Tiffany lamps (I'd like a few of those for my house).
There were plenty of surprises on our ice cream tour, too.
Who knew that fat-free frozen yogurt could taste so good?
Golden Spoon Frozen Yogurt missed a top nod by a fraction of a point.
The selling point of Golden Spoon is not only how creamy, rich and great tasting our Heath Bar (with Heath Bar mix-ins) yogurt was, but that it was 99 percent fat-free and included healthful active yogurt cultures - Lacto Bulgaricus, Lacto Acidophilus, and Strepto Thermophilus.
There's nothing ladies like better than to indulge in a tasty treat and tell ourselves it's good for us.
In addition, the calorie count of Golden Spoon won't make you swoon.
A mini cup contains four ounces of frozen yogurt and 68 calories. Double that for a small cup, triple it for a large cup - a medium cup is somewhere in between.
At Golden Spoon is where we discovered that Donkin has a spoon fetish.
"The substantial gold spoons are cool, I kept mine," she said.
Donkin had high praise for the yogurt that was shared among the four tour members.
"I wanted more, it wasn't too sweet, I could have eaten it all," she said.
Mills agreed.
"Amazingly rich flavor for frozen yogurt," Mills said.
Dippin' Dots, which is super frozen ice cream, earned high marks for friendly service and its unique product.
"Ice cream you can chew is a nice change of pace," said Mills.
At Dairy Queen the tour tasted the Chocolate French Silk Blizzard and the Caramel Chip Cheesecake Blizzard.
The bits of real cheesecake and the caramel made this my favorite ice cream concoction sampled on the entire tour.
The chocolate was awesome, too. Very rich chocolate with that chocolate, chocolate taste you want when you want chocolate.
It was interesting that several of the tour members had never visited a Cold Stone Creamery - the gold standard of mix-ins and rich ice cream.
"Wow! Delicious, I wanted to try them all," said Donkin. "This was my first time at Cold Stone, smelled great walking in like chocolate cake, brownies, cream, yum!"
At Ben and Jerry's we tried a scoop of Oatmeal Cookie and indulged in a Turtle Soup sundae.
"Unique flavors and good mix-ins" said Rachel Stern. "Everything is very decadent."

