This editorial appeared in the print edition on Sunday, July 30.
It has been a newsy summer for the William S. Hart Union High School District — a triple-header of bad news, if you will.
First was the Hart district’s decision to settle a lawsuit alleging institutional racism at Valencia High School. The district and its insurance company agreed to pay approximately $50,000 to each of five students and $400,000 to the students’ attorneys to make the lawsuit go away.
The decision sends some bad messages. One is that the district was guilty — for why else would it settle? Evidently the district didn’t feel it had a strong enough case to convince a jury. Federal law prohibits the filing of frivolous lawsuits; the district could have gone after the litigants if it was totally in the clear. The other message is that if you’ve got an ax to grind, sue the district and it will pay.
Neither conclusion is necessarily true. As with most settlements, there was no admission of guilt, and there’s no guarantee that the district will settle to avoid a protracted trial in the future.
But those are the messages, and now, the district cannot prove otherwise.
The second and bigger bit of bad news is the cost overrun associated with the modernization of Arroyo Seco Junior High School.
As Tim Myers details in his opinion column today, the overruns might well be explainable and even understandable. But they are not acceptable. An embarrassed school board said goodbye to its staff member in charge of construction projects, giving him a handsome severance package because it woke up from its slumber just a little too late. Not until it had passed the golden-handshake point with its facilities chief did the board realize it needed to start watching the money.
Now the board has ordered an independent audit to see what went wrong — but don’t expect it to recover any of the “extra” money that slipped through its fingers.
What is really peculiar about the overruns is that by all rights, the Hart district should be sitting pretty. In 2000, when the district was bursting at the seams with 17,000 students in classrooms designed for 10,200, the district pleaded “hardship” to the state. Under the rules for hardship funding, the district had to show it had tried and failed to raise bond money at the local ballot box. It met the requirement with a bond measure that failed. But then, in November 2001, local voters passed Measure V, a $158 million school construction bond act — right after the state hardship money came through.
So, with your state tax dollars, you paid for the construction of Golden Valley and West Ranch high schools and Rancho Pico Junior High, and with your local Measure V dollars, you’re paying for the add-ons, such as a gymnasium at Rancho Pico and athletic fields and performing arts centers at the new high schools.
If this were a “normal” school district and heads were rolling over cost overruns, the buck wouldn’t stop with the assistant superintendent for facilities; the superintendent’s neck would be on the chopping block. But this isn’t a normal district.
The Hart district has essentially bifurcated its managerial responsibilities in such a way that the superintendent, Jaime Castellanos, is primarily responsible for instruction. School construction is handled in part by district staff and in part by a related but separate entity called the Santa Clarita Valley Facilities Foundation.
Which brings us to bad news item No. 3.
In a normal school district — such as our valley’s elementary districts — the school district obtains land and with a combination of local, state and developer money, builds a school.
In the Hart district, at least lately, the Facilities Foundation acts as the developer, buying land and selling it to the district for a school, but then buying “extra” land and building things that aren’t related to schools, such as the new housing tract next to Golden Valley High.
In theory, the foundation is supposed to pump the profits back into the school district. It’s a nice theory, but is it happening? Somewhere along the way, the foundation’s attorneys — or was it the school district’s attorneys? — decided that the five nonelected members of the foundation board must comply with the state’s open-meeting laws. Nonetheless, the particular development deals remain sub-rosa. Because the books aren’t open, there is no way for the public to know who may be benefiting, or to what degree.
And when we say “books,” we don’t mean the balance sheets. When we’ve called for an audit in the past, the foundation has presented a form filled out by a local accountancy firm showing that the assets and liabilities pencil out. That doesn’t cut it.
Earlier this month, foundation board member Teresa Todd became a “former” board member under curious circumstances.
It seems that Todd, a public relations specialist with an MBA, and Bob Lee — the former Hart district superintendent who retired a year ago to concentrate on Facilities Foundation work — had reached an agreement with foundation board President Rick Patterson and Treasurer Gary Condie to resign from the foundation board and go to work for the foundation as paid consultants.
In a closed meeting, the foundation board decided to hire Lee. Now it would be paying him, under an open-ended contract, to perform work that he had previously done “for free.”
Then came consideration of Todd’s contract for public relations services, which she had previously performed “for free.” It was denied. According to Todd, a foundation board member wondered aloud why the foundation should be paying for something it had always gotten gratis.
As you might imagine, Todd is alleging discrimination. To bolster her claim, Todd asserts that every contract the foundation has put to bid has gone to a friend of one or two of the foundation board members — and never to a woman-owned business.
That sort of thing is less likely to happen in a “normal” school district that handles its own school construction activities because there are all sorts of state laws that come into play. Hart isn’t normal.
The foundation needs to open its books — and not just show its balance sheet. While the outside auditor is looking into the modernization overruns, the school board should instruct it to examine every contract the Facilities Foundation has signed for the theoretical benefit of the district, and determine whether the foundation has followed the same antidiscrimination and other laws that would apply to the Hart district if it were doing the job itself.
Because if it’s true that all contracts have gone to friends, the foundation board members never will be able to prove they haven’t been receiving kickbacks — just as the Hart district gave up its right to prove in a court of law that it wasn’t guilty of racism.
