First of three parts.
Earlier this summer I enjoyed having a pizza lunch with three of my favorite Signal columnists. After discussing a number of topics that we are slow-cooking to serve Signal readers, I lapsed in my protocol as sort-of host and asked a question about the one unmentionable subject in America today.
"How about," I asked, "one of us write a column about the problems of an abortion-abundant society?"
This idea caused a moment of silence and did not lead to much more discussion on the subject. But a couple of the columnists gave the opinion that the subject of abortion should be reviewed exclusively by women legislators and jurists. The reason is that women have experience of both giving birth and having abortions. In contrast, men have often been an embarrassment in trying to lead the abortion debate, confirming what the American philosopher William James discovered: When a man has no experience with what he is upset with and can't relieve himself in legitimate competition, he often just turns nuts.
Sadly, as proven with "pro-life" killer Eric Rudolph and others, that seems to be a reliable assumption.
I disagree with the argument of a third columnist, who said the current silence on abortion is because we are sick of hearing about it. This observation reminded of a terrible event in the great British novel by Charlotte Bronte, "Jane Eyre." Jane's fiance, Rochester, has treated his first wife much as we treat abortion in this election year. For years, Rochester had kept his wife locked up in a third-story room, even as he prepared for a new marriage to keep up proper appearances.
In contrast, his proposed new wife, Jane Eyre - who was constantly clashing with the people and the fashions of her time - started to think about that faint screaming from the third story. Perhaps, Jane decided, someone should finally ask a few questions about what was happening in this locked-up Rochester household.
Like Lady Rochester, our 1 million abortions per year are locked up in a third floor, out of our sight and away from our discussion groups. Surely we must hesitate to talk or even think about this upsetting topic if even our nominees to the U.S. Supreme Court try to say they have never thought or talked about the issue of abortion until they were questioned by U.S. senators.
Several years ago I visited the Dachau concentration camp near Munich and discovered another instance of this closed-door approach.
Dachau was one of the earliest concentration camps, created long before World War II started, lying in a shallow plateau under the village of Dachau. The camp had some of the most attractive tree landscaping in southern Germany, with precious linden trees planted in close formation like a regiment on parade.
Later I found out that the present Dachau museum has preserved the camp's original landscaping. A docent explained that the close formation of camp trees was designed to drown out the cries coming from the killing masses of Jews. Moreover, while the people of Dachau had been successfully taught by German media that the Jews were not human material, the German establishment did everything it could to prevent any open debate about this widely-stated claim.
However, surely a good public program could only receive wider support from our society by seeing actual pictures and videos of the work being done behind these closed doors and gates, and talking about it in public forums. To put this question differently, if Rochester were treating Lady Rochester correctly, in spite of all the evidence of her screaming, surely he should invite us to take a real look at her.
Since I am a former cynical New Yorker, it is hard for me to accept the rhetoric of the so-called pro-choice argument while excusing it from real debate.
For example, in sections of New York City such as the South Bronx and Upper Manhattan, abortion is promoted heavily on tax-paid signs throughout the subways and subway stations. These are the same sections of New York where any kind of human life is granted less value, where street killings are higher and battered women's shelters in some form are within access of every neighborhood.
These are those hidden-away sections of New York City that suffer frightfully from a brutish outlook that a woman is only the property of a man. Similarly, this attitude gets passed onto the unborn child being assumed to be only the property of a woman.
Perhaps it is hard to imagine such an attitude here in preppy Santa Clarita. In our own city, I have shared only the happiness of fathers and mothers who celebrate the introduction of a distinct new person yet to be born, a child whose value transcends any prenatal bill.
In the other America, an unborn child is commonly represented on subway signs as only a growth and not a real person at all, but something subhuman that is not worth a dime.
I'll have more to say in my next two columns. As I should have told my Signal columnist friend, it is our settled silence on abortion today that is making all that noise you hear.
Chris Sharp lives in Saugus. His column reflects his own views, and not necessarily those of The Signal.
