Second of three parts.
When Roe v. Wade emerged to define the status of abortion in 1973, Richard Nixon had just been re-elected president in the kind of landslide victory reserved for the most loved presidents in American history.
Strangely, even at the outset of Roe v. Wade, things were not how they were later represented.
Associate justice Harry Blackmun wrote the Supreme Court majority opinion for Roe v. Wade. However, the real champion of the case law was leonine Chief Justice Warren Burger.
Since being appointed by Nixon to replace Chief Justice Earl Warren, Burger looked like a core conservative Republican, and he surely talked like one. No matter what he did, he was the darling of the conservative right. However, at that time, practically anyone who came after Earl Warren's Brown v. Board of Education revolution would have become the extreme right's sweetheart.
When Roe v. Wade was first presented to the Supreme Court in 1971 by a group of small-town Texans, Burger used everything in his chief-justice leverage to keep the case alive and well. Everyone else on the high court but Blackmun wanted a dismissal and an ending of the flawed lawsuit. Instead, Burger got the suit sent to the cleaners and ordered it sent back in a year for re-argument.
It actually took more than a year, but in that time, every serious pro-abortion group was creating a makeover for Jane Roe in a more popular and mainstream style. When the suit was finally reviewed again in 1973, Roe's lawyers dropped the suspicious image they had originally created of Roe as a rape victim. Instead Roe was totally done over to become America's average woman who desired not to abort a baby, but a part of her own body.
There was so little in this preponderance of flimflam about who Jane Roe really was - her true name was Norma McCorvey - that she finally decided not to go ahead with her planned abortion and instead gave birth to a daughter. Following several disappointing experiences with her pro-choice lawyers, McCorvey is now among the most vocal anti-abortion activists in the nation.
Back in 1973, after Burger twisted enough arms to win a 7-2 high court victory for the Roe attorney team, the two lonely dissenting justices struck back with two of the most seething and lingering dissents in Supreme Court history.
One objection came from a new appointee named William Rehnquist, writing in brilliant legal language. The other dissent came from football all-American Byron "Whizzer" White, the former deputy attorney general under Robert Kennedy.
JFK had named White to the high court mainly to run interference for the abused American underdog during a time of civil-rights upheaval. Now he had a new underdog to champion.
White reinforced the junior justice's legalistic outrage in layman's terms. "The upshot is that the people and the legislatures of the 50 states are constitutionally disentitled to weigh the relative importance of the continued existence and development of the fetus, on the one hand, against a spectrum of possible impacts on the mother, on the other hand," White wrote.
Thus, more than 30 years ago, the liberal White and the conservative Rehnquist used words that gave birth to the National Right to Life movement.
Some half-dozen years later, an animal-rights group named People for the Ethical Treatment for Animals was created to win legal rights for kangaroo rats and various other rodents and human-eating predators, such as the cougars in California's hiking parks.
We can only wonder: How does PETA hit so many home runs, while the right-to-life movement has not yet, to my knowledge, protected even one human fetus against the Roe v. Wade blanket solution to unwanted children?
Perhaps if Justice White were alive today, he might have been good enough to remind us that no mortal court can be used as a proving ground for metaphysical claims such as "abortion is murder." Yet this is the theme that National Right to Life has had as its emblem for the past 30 years. Surely, we have seen those signs on bumpers, even in relatively sophisticated Santa Clarita, that indict an entire population of American women who have had abortions as "murderers."
Clearly, the extremists in National Right to Life are comfortable chasing out all of the sane people and having the movement to themselves. They have never saved any babies this way and they never will, but they are still throwing names at women like drunken "good old boys" at a tailgate party.
In contrast, there is surely a lot of madness in PETA; I am sure you have heard about their crazy stuff. But when approaching courts, PETA files suits that have a method to their madness.
Most importantly, PETA uses words they can prove. For example, they can prove that a kangaroo rat had been killed by a farmer's hoe. PETA is never going to make the mistake of saying in public that the farmer "murdered" the tiny rat.
For anyone who wants to go beyond the depressing comparison of the batting averages between PETA and National Right to Life, I am writing a third column that will plead for a change in our American culture toward becoming pro-life rather than pro-abortion.
To a great extent, my views on the subject have been gleaned from my e-mail conversations with thoughtful people who think as highly of women as they appreciate the unborn child. I promise to try to use a pleasant template by taking you to Italy, a nation whose very art loves women and loves children.
Chris Sharp lives in Saugus. His column reflects his own views, and not necessarily those of The Signal.
