Every day I read The Mighty Signal, and every day I read every single piece of local opinion and all of the letters to the editor. On the days I see my name in the text of a letter, I sit up and take notice, getting ready to savor the opinion of another person at least partially inspired by an essay. Many people wonder and ask me about my reactions to these responses.
The late Roberta Gillis, a muckraking columnist on the local level, claimed never to read the letters criticizing her essays, though she seemed quite conversant with their details. Pauline Harte believed each criticism amounted to a personal attack against home, hearth and country.
Personally, I revel in each response, and I revel particularly in those that disagree.
A local man once marveled at the number of people I know in the community, especially after living here a rather short time. I credit it mostly to those who disagree. I met many elected officials and community activists over the years solely because they needed to contact me and "straighten me out" concerning a half- or fully baked idea articulated in a Sunday essay.
For this reason alone, I met Steve Tannehill of the Newhall Elementary District School Board, Teresa Todd of the Sulphur Springs School Board, Rick Patterson of the Facilities Foundation, Dennis King of the Hart District School Board and countless others. The deepest relationships arose from disagreements and not from mutual admiration.
I recall with pride the essay that garnered the most responses in the Letters section, including letters from national readers exposed to the essay on The Signal's Web site. A thoughtful essay against Proposition 21, the California Defense of Marriage initiative, related my struggles with the issue and a chance to seek a "third way." Conservatives wrote they appreciated the honest struggle, and some stated the highest praise for an essay: It made them think of the issue in a different way for the first time. Gay activists wrote many letters and Web postings stating I stood very close to their point of view and just needed to move over a step.
I admit that I draft some essays to elicit a particular response. If one were to guess that I design my constant references to Newhall High School to get a certain response, one would be guessing correctly. I receive a rise out of the template letter from the distraught Newhall High School parent wondering how The Signal can "allow" such an ignorant writer to continue with these insults and inaccuracies. When the responses end, my references might end. Not likely!
Even when I do not anticipate a particular response, the responses generally do not surprise. I pride myself on self-awareness and an attempt to understand the other side of arguments I advance. But for the first time ever, the responses I received with respect to an essay shocked even me.
Two weeks ago I wrote an essay concerning the financial distress of the Senior Center. I'll repeat that last line. I wrote an essay concerning the financial distress - not a factual white paper. The essay expressed an opinion concerning the rise of the financial distress and a refocusing of management oversight to find a solution. The essay actually complimented the Senior Center on its mission, since effective delivery of services created growing demand. Oh, the response!
The first came from a telephone call from someone close to the current board of directors of the Senior Center. The caller felt I personally insulted one board member in particular; then the conversation moved into unexpected directions while I listened attentively. Assertions included general community hostility to seniors, an uncaring county supervisor, people associating with the Senior Center for votes but performing no real work, a for-profit organization's wine "festival" conspiratorially scheduled during the same weekend of the Senior Center's wine "auction." My personal favorite: Car dealers don't give money to seniors because seniors don't buy cars.
A subsequent response included a lengthy letter from Brad Berens, the Senior Center's director. After a lucid argument concerning efforts and contingencies, Berens then shocked by accusing me of conspiring with the United Way and-or Henry Mayo Newhall Memorial Hospital to discredit the Senior Center.
But the shock did not end there. I received calls from actual seniors, and I now began to fear a senior rally on my doorstep. But never assume anything. I received a call of support from a former employee of the Senior Center who could not go on the record due to pending litigation. Also, seniors requested my address to send, through the mail, written allegations of financial and management impropriety at the Senior Center.
How does this end? Only time will tell. But I will never again be shocked by a reaction to an essay.
Tim Myers lives in Valencia. His column reflects his own views, and not necessarily those of The Signal.
