ArchiveSCV
the-signal.com. The Santa Clarita Valley Signal. Back to the collection.

· the-signal.com, Wayback capture

Discovering the Reasons to Re-elect the Governator

History will remember the California 2003 recall election. Many graduate students in political science and history will choose the event for long theses and dissertations. Sometimes, temporal proximity to a cataclysmic events makes us forget their importance in the zeitgeist of the 21st Century.

To recap, Gray Davis, an uncharismatic second-term governor, besieged by a perfect storm of power shortages, fiscal problems and a certain malaise and public bewilderment, fell victim to a grassroots recall petition drive pushed over the top by the funding of a Republican car-alarm magnate.

In addition to Davis' substantial problems, his own party engaged in activities tantamount to the crew of the Titanic punching more holes into the hull after the iceberg strike. They advanced the weak argument that the special election cost too much money, and a rebellious Legislature forced Davis to sign a bill authorizing California drivers' licenses for undocumented aliens.

Few people focus on the astounding nature of the newcomer's victory, garnering a clear majority in effectively a four-way race.

Since the election, the Governator has endured his ups and downs, including the embarrassing special election where he picked a fight with those most potent political forces: nurses, police officers and firefighters.

I write this essay today to remind voters of the astounding reform the Governator put together quickly after his election: California workers' compensation reform.

We quickly forget those dark days, and sometimes the ordinary voter believes special interests grossly exaggerate their situations (they do), but no exaggeration existed in late 2003.

The workers' compensation tax on payrolls --I define a "tax" in the following way: something calculated by applying a percentage to something else for which one receives no direct benefit and must pay to comply with the law - stood at an all-time high. Insurance companies willing to underwrite California workers' compensation risks stood at an all-time low. Tragically, a system existed that provided extremely small benefits to the disabled worker, with the lion's share of money going to a bloated community of workers' compensation applicant health providers, utilizing the last blank check to provide exaggerated health care.

Many spoke of fraud. I do not believe fraud existed in the system to any significant extent. I do believe injured workers, encouraged by applicant attorneys and health care providers, exaggerated their injuries to further bleed the system.

Every business had its own particular horror story, but the result was the same: Increasing rates sucked income away from businesses, impairing their ability to invest for the future and growth and also sucking dry state corporate income tax revenues.

Imagine a construction business with a $10 million payroll. In 2003, that business would pay $1.7 million in workers' compensation insurance premiums under the flawed system. Fast-forward to 2006, two and one-half years following the Governator's bold reforms. That same business would now pay $700,000 in insurance premiums, freeing up $1 million of additional income to generate state income tax receipts of $90,000 and also generate $600,000 after the payment of both federal and state income taxes. The business could then lever this additional capital by a conservative factor of five, investing approximately $5 million in equipment, generating $400,000 in sales taxes for state, county and local coffers.

But the velocity does not stop there. The business needs additional personnel to man the equipment, and the state collects income taxes on the income these personnel generate, and sales tax on their taxable purchases. This $1 million savings recreates itself every year with the opportunities for further tax receipts and investments. Now multiply this single business by 3,000 to 4,000 similarly sized businesses in California and the tens of thousands of smaller businesses with proportional savings, and one can easily understand California job growth and growth in tax receipts since the Governator took office.

Anyone who believes these events could occur without the celebrity power and people's mandate of the Governator deceive themselves. During the 1990s, while one workers' compensation insurance carrier after another went into insolvency due to the high cost of claims outstripping premiums, the Legislature enacted a series of benefit increases and easing of controls regarding treatment.

During Gray Davis' catastrophic final year, the Legislature enacted milquetoast reforms designed to accomplish nothing. The Governator identified workers' compensation reform, made it his top priority, and within a whirlwind period enacted sensible comprehensive reform undreamed of in the heretofore business-hostile or indifferent California Legislative environment.

Did the Governator make any mistakes during his three-year tenure? Of course he did. No politician can claim perfection. But this first accomplishment looms so large that I cannot imagine anyone who cares about employment, growth in tax receipts to provide better services, and the well-being of all the citizens of California, not supporting the Governator for reelection.

Tim Myers lives in Valencia. His column reflects his own views, and not necessarily those of The Signal.

← Back to 2006

About this record

How it was held, read and classified

Record details

Morris ID
Not a Morris ID. This record is keyed ts-ds:32882.
System
displaystory pages (?module=displaystory)
Reading copy
the-signal.com
Chosen by: latest capture. On this copy: words 808 (e-mail addresses counted as one token); reader comments 0 (counted, not reproduced here); images 0.
Extracted by
displaystory:print_view
signal-extract/0.15 (2026-11-16)

Other copies (1)

Host
the-signal.com
http://www.the-signal.com/?module=displaystory&story_id=32882&format=html
Captured14 November 2006, 18:31:50 UTC
CaptureThe archive does not serve this capture as a facsimile; the text is extracted from it.
SHA-2566f51aa33a60619fa76f8b077289a0343a4e284a0623b07d1a546e3288c955a03SHA-256 of the bytes the archive holds, recorded at intake. A SHA-1 of the same bytes, taken at the same time, equals the Wayback Machine’s own digest for this capture: EKHW6BPJV5CCRAZHC2BZPXD7Z764HXCV.
Holds alone
nothing measured beyond the chosen copy

How it was classified

Label
clearly-local
Judgment
A machine’s (recorded as machine), kept as one so it can be revisited.
Classifier
signal-localclass/0.7 (2026-11-12)
Local signals
  • text:valley_names [1 distinct/1 mentions: Valencia]
  • byline:named_writer_no_wire_credit [Commentary by Tim Myers]
National signals
none fired
Scores
local 3, national 0