ArchiveSCV
the-signal.com. The Santa Clarita Valley Signal. Back to the collection.

· the-signal.com, Wayback capture

Must-See Westerns of All Time

"Yer beautiful in yer wrath! I shall keep you, and, in responding to my passions, yer hatred will kindle into love."

- John Wayne as Genghis Khan to Susan Hayward in the film, "The Conqueror" which, by the by, was partially filmed in the Santa Clarita Valley in 1955 at Vasquez Rocks.

Someone once said: "A genius is someone who can hit the bull's eye of a target no one else can see."

There have been many lists of the greatest Westerns of all time. They have been stretched to a supposedly inarguable best 100 by AFI to the best five by anyone with a web account.

What follows is a list of wonderfully must-see Westerns, many of whom don't get the same retread publicity of "The Searchers" or "Magnificent Seven." These are great Westerns. They always will be.

But what follows is dedicated to my nephew-like substance, Paul Garrett. Some on the list are funny. Some gritty. Some unique. Some eclectic. All of them are a must-see for the serious movie buff.

Years ago, I published my first novel, "Naked Came the Sasquatch." Hoping I won't be sued by Paul 10 years later, I confess I modeled one of the characters, Clifford Fenberg, after my nephewesque Paul Garrett.

Paul was this little cheese-faced boy, pale, with freckles and red-haired. I have never met any individual of any age, gender or species who would launch himself into the fray with such fearless frenzy.

I love my Paul, still. He is a grown man now and I've oft said I'm glad I was nice to him because now, the guy is 6-6 and weighs 250.

My Paulie has had a short setback and has picked up some small hitchhiker - I think it's potato famine - that requires him to visit men in white lab coats.

I hope he hasn't gone the cheap route and picked vets instead of actual doctors.

Anyway. Paulito called me the other day and we talked of things close to our heart. Like - how shall we delicately put it - his mother/my alleged sister Lisa's "leadership skills" how much we love her despite her wealth of management techniques. But, mostly, we talked of Westerns.

Part of the problem with Paul's generation is they missed the golden years of the American artform. In PG's existence, there have only been a few handful of oaters made. Some are most excellent, like Costner in "Free Range."

But there is nearly a century of great Westerns and Paul - and his age demographic - has some serious catching-up to do. Hopefully, my inspiration for Clifford the Cheese-Faced Boy will enjoy his well-deserved recuperation time and maybe catch a few of the following films. And long after that, on a lazy weekend or stolen two hours, he has some catching up to do.

Paul. Look at me. You will watch these. You will get better.

LONELY ARE THE BRAVE (1962) - This modern Western was Kirk Douglas' favorite picture and that's saying something. He plays Jack Burns, a cowboy born a century too late. Burns breaks into prison to spring a friend, only to find out his friend doesn't want out. Much of the film is about Douglas on horseback trying to escape a mechanized posse. This is a deeply allegorical movie about the ever-shrinking West with its simple values, open spaces and even different look on time being hounded by the ravages of a spreading technological world. One of the best Westerns ever made, period. Walter Mattheau was excellent in his underplayed, slightly annoyed Sheriff Morey Johnson, who secretly roots for Jack to escape. One of the best endings, ever.

TRACK OF THE CAT (1954) - You could fill a series of 12-Step meetings with Robert Mitchum's neurotic family in a claustrophobic snowbound Nevada ranch. Based on the William van Tillburg Clark novel and produced, by all people - John Wayne - Himself. Mitchum tries to keep his family together while hunting a mountain lion intent on breakfasting on them. Great scenery and great William Wellman script.

THE BIG SKY (1952) - Someone once wrote that a genius is someone who hits the bulls-eye of a target no one else can see. So it is with Howard Hawks' unique 1830's Western feature not cowboys, but trappers and Indians. This almost has a Long John Silver quality to it with two heroes, Dewey Martin and Kirk Douglas. This is an ultimate buddy film with great chemistry between the men and Elizabeth Threatt, the captured Indian princess (who was actually of Cherokee descent). Somehow, Hawks delivers a strikingly beautiful picture, done in black and white.

"THE STALKING MOON" (1968) - When I saw this on the big screen, there were people screaming at the end. Mind you, this is a Western, not a horror flick. Gregory Peck stars as Sam Varner, an army scout retiring to his farm in New Mexico. He reluctantly guides a captured white woman and her half-breed son. Salvaje, the psycho war chief, goes after them, leaving a trail of carnage. Quiet, understated and riveting, this is about as close at they come to a perfect movie.

"THE BRAVADOS" (1958) - It's no accident that Gregory Peck stars in five of our top unique Westerns of all time. Imagine that inner fire that earned him Best Actor as Atticus Finch in "To Kill A Mockingbird" and strap on a six-shooter. I remember yelling "No way!" at the surprise ending of "The Bravados," a powerful, almost Shakespearean tale of revenge and redemption.

"THE BIG COUNTRY" (1958) - Today, every once in a while, a George Clooney or Brad Pitt will appear from a villa to grace us with a movie. Gregory Peck was averaging a classic every six months. Note that 1958 was the same year he did "The Bravados." "The Big Country" is aptly named, what with Peck sharing the screen with Carroll Baker, Charlton Heston, Jean Simmons, Charles Bickford - and the unforgettable screen father-and-son tandem of Burl Ives and Chuck Connors. This would be Connors' best performance as a cowardly son to the neighboring land baron. You need a big screen to see "The Big Country."

"THE MOUNTAIN MEN" (1980) - I've always loved this as an escapist film and that, in part, is what Westerns are. We are transported to a pristine American wilderness through the adventures of two bawdy mountain men, played by Charlton Heston and Brian Keith. This is simply a serious, fun guy's flick. To prove it, a pair of thumb-sucking film reviewers of the day hated it. Of course, Siskel & Ebert were always a good barometer for me. If they liked it, it was probably a terrible French art film.

"THE GUNFIGHTER" (1950) - Nominated for an Oscar for best screenplay, here is another Gregory Peck adult Western. When we say "adult," we don't mean the sorry 21st century definition of pornography. This intelligent oater shows the life of Jimmy Ringo, famed gunslinger who only wants peace. Interestingly, life imitates art. Peck grew an authentic period mustache for the role. Fox Studios head Spyros P. Skouras was out of the country during production, came back mid-way and hated Peck's mustache, claiming it would "cost the studio millions!"

"RIDE LONESOME" (1959) - Randolph Scott is Ben Brigade (great name!) a bounty hunter who drags a stinky filthy murderer (James Best) to be hanged. Look for James Coburn in his first movie.

"THE ANGRY SPUR" (1953) - This is not your mildly confused, fumbling Jimmy Stewart from "The Philadelphia Story." Jim plays an almost psychotic bounty hunter, Howard Kemp, going after an even crazier outlaw, Robert Ryan. Absolutely breathless Technicolor scenery and absolutely breathless Janet Leigh, too. This was the third and arguably best collaboration between Stewart and director Anthony Mann. Their "Winchester 73" is a standard on all the top Westerns lists.

"ONE-EYED JACKS" (1961) - One of my favorite Western wackos is the unlikely Karl Malden. He was a sociopathic rapist in Steve McQueen's "Nevada Smith." He was even better as Dad Longworth, the outlaw who leaves his partner, Marlon Brando, to die after a bank robbery in Mexico. Brando directed and starred in this grand, gorgeous and captivating Western set along the wind-swept California coast. Brando's later largesse at the dinner table was evident on the set. He shot six times the normal amount of film and midway through production, the studio took the film from him and edited themselves.

"THE APPALOOSA" (1966) - Those around Marlon Brando on the set of this tale of mano-a-mano snitch that Brando had little interest in the film and was a pain to be around. Still. The end result is a dark classic about Brando riding a beautiful horse desired by bandit Chuy Medina, played by John Saxon. For one thing, you've got to catch this just to see famed Mexican character star, Emilio Fernandez, as Chuy's second-in-command.

"MY NAME IS NOBODY" (1974) - I dragged Paul's Uncle Willie to see this and 30 years later, we're still quoting scenes. Terrence Hill stars as the fastest - and filthiest - gunfighter in the West. There's the great opening scene of Terrence, asleep, being dragged slowly across the brush and even through a stream by his horse and an Indian version of a wagon. There's the famous slap scene in the barroom where Nobody demonstrates his speed. And then there's that great scene where Nobody shows three pistoleros how fast he is. Holding his saddle over his shoulder, he draws his gun, reholsters and grabs the saddle before it falls from his shoulders. Trivia: This was Henry Fonda's last and most favorite cowboy flicks. A spoof on both American and spaghetti Westerns, this also appears on many top lists as a classic.

"RANCHO DELUXE" (1975) - Funny. I was just visiting my friend Steve Arklin in Sand Canyon. He named his big spread after this film. Boy howdy this is an odd but wonderfully entertaining film. Jeff Bridges and Sam Waterston of "Law & Order" fame star as two Modern rustlers, part hippies/part cowboys. Wonderful all-star supporting cast. Look for former local rodeo star, actor Slim Pickens (the guy who rode the atom bomb down to Moscow in "Dr. Strangelove") as the range detective. You will smile and shake your head after this one.

"DEAD MAN" (1995) - Johnny Depp looking like Buster Keaton and the deadliest man in the West? With a score by Niel Young? And a great assist by Gary Farmer, as the Indian who confuses Depp's character of William Blake with the English poet. This may be the MOST eclectic Western ever made. It looks, rather darkly, at death, philosophy and the uncomfortable myths of the American frontier. Also, great cameos by Robert Mitchum, Lance Henrikson, and Iggy Pop. Yes. Iggy Pop in a Western.

"THE FIGHTING KENTUCKIAN" (1949) - This is the only movie where John Wayne teams up with his real-life good friend, Oliver Hardy. Yes. Oliver Hardy. At first, the rotund comedian didn't want to do the flick because he feared the public would think he and Stan Laurel had broken up. It was Stan who convinced him to do this fun circa 1818 Western. Lots of fisticuffs, action and comedy.

"CAT BALLOU" (1965) - Lee Marvin could easily be the 20th century's most versatile actor. He could play everything from psychotic hitman to thoughtful existentialist. He earned an Oscar for Best Actor as the twin brothers, Kid Shelleen and Tim Strawn. The controversial but versatile Jane Fonda plays the sweet title role of an orphan who seeks vengeance on the evil railroad. Even odder, you've got Nat King Cole singing throughout this oddball Western. It's worth the price for Marvin, who quipped at accepting his Academy Award: "Half of this probably belongs to a horse out there somewhere." More trivia? Kirk Douglas turned down the role.

"BIG HAND FOR A LITTLE LADY" (1966) - They just emptied the supporting actor barrel out to make this Western/caper film about poker. Stars Henry Fonda, Joanne Woodward and Jason Robards. This was originally to be a television movie, but the producers realized they had something bigger here. It's a must-see, especially in these days of the Texas Hold-em craze.

"THE SHEEPMAN" (1958) - Forget "Brokeback Mountain." This is the best sheepstern every filmed. Writers Will Bowers and James Grant also created one of the funniest and most innovative openings to a Western ever. Glenn Ford, who just died recently, plays a tough hero by the name of Jason Sweet in one of cinema's forgotten classics and one of the best satirical Westerns ever, taking on everything from cinema stereotypes to post modernist capitalism.

"WAY OUT WEST" (1937) - No offense, but there is something wrong with you on a cellular level if you don't like this hilarious Laurel & Hardy Western. I don't want to hear, "Humor is relative," or "I don't like slapstick." You need serious counseling or a kick in the britches because you take life too seriously if you don't laugh until you hurt.

"TUMBLEWEEDS" (1924) - Don't check the volume on the remote control. This is a silent movie and William S. Hart's final film and, with "Hell's Hinges" might be Hart's greatest. It is an epic and nostalgic look at the closing of the West. What makes this a must-see is that dozens of film historians and top stars, from John Wayne to Gary Cooper credit Hart for being the prototype of all Western stars who followed in his bootprints. If you look closely, you might even see where Clint Eastwood took his patented half-smirk, half-smile. And, bonus, he lived in Paul Garrett's mom's home town of Newhall...

Well. That about wraps it up, saddlepal Paul. You get through this temporary monkey business and I'll come up with another 21 for you...

John Boston is the 2006 winner of the Will Rogers Humanitarian Award. Besides winning Best Serious Column and Best Humorous Column from the National Newspaper Association this summer, he has earned 12 major national, regional and state awards in 2006 and 113 lifetime. His Western Civilization column appears Wednesdays-Saturdays and on Mondays on page A2. His Time Ranger history column runs Sunday in the Opinion Section of Your Mighty Signal.

Image not recovered00000483-constrain-160x200.jpeg
Image not recovered00000486-constrain-160x200.jpeg

← Back to 2006

About this record

How it was held, read and classified

Record details

Morris ID
Not a Morris ID. This record is keyed ts-ds:32992.
System
displaystory pages (?module=displaystory)
Reading copy
the-signal.com
Chosen by: latest capture. On this copy: words 2,380 (e-mail addresses counted as one token); reader comments 0 (counted, not reproduced here); images 2.
Extracted by
displaystory:print_view
signal-extract/0.15 (2026-11-16)

Other copies (1)

Host
the-signal.com
http://www.the-signal.com/?module=displaystory&story_id=32992&format=html
Captured14 November 2006, 17:26:54 UTC
CaptureThe archive does not serve this capture as a facsimile; the text is extracted from it.
SHA-25638f6103a9a33dc3fd2faa59706d8516f2af7a64e4d9728e55cc7bea22f905ffcSHA-256 of the bytes the archive holds, recorded at intake. A SHA-1 of the same bytes, taken at the same time, equals the Wayback Machine’s own digest for this capture: GZ5H24U4GJ2XRNZEYY4DT5FNG5HGJXXO.
Holds alone
images not on the chosen copy: 00000483-constrain-240x900.jpeg, 00000486-constrain-240x647.jpeg

How it was classified

Label
clearly-local
Judgment
A machine’s (recorded as machine), kept as one so it can be revisited.
Classifier
signal-localclass/0.7 (2026-11-12)
Local signals
  • text:valley_names [5 distinct/5 mentions: Santa Clarita, Newhall, Sand Canyon, Vasquez Rocks, William S. Hart]
  • byline:named_writer_no_wire_credit [Commentary by John Boston]
National signals
none fired
Scores
local 5, national 0