Fourth in an occasional series.
Some people describe obscure facts and figures utilizing the term "inside baseball." Like strange baseball statistics, only a sliver of fans actually know and recite them; the rest scratch their heads. Still, their knowledge marks the true and deep baseball fan from the ordinary.
Similarly, in the SCV, acquaintance with the term "donut hole" sets one apart from the ordinary citizen with respect to real estate and land use, and the trifecta of real estate stories first published on June 23, 2006, in The Mighty Signal dealt specifically with the donut hole - the historic Bermite property.
The Bermite property sits in the approximate center of the city on roughly 1,000 acres behind the Saugus Speedway and the Santa Clarita Metrolink Station. Termed the "donut hole" because, from the air, it appears like the hole in the donut of the developed city of Santa Clarita and the greater Santa Clarita Valley, the property has stood fallow since 1987.
The Bermite Powder Co., and Halifax Powder Co. before it, manufactured explosives, flares and small munitions on the site from 1934 to 1987. The company and the property played an important role in the needs of the U.S. military during World War II, the Korean War and the Vietnam conflict. Naturally, the munitions plant needed a remote location to conduct its dangerous work, hence its location in the nether-regions of Los Angeles County in the 1930s. By 1987, one could not describe the area as "remote."
Unfortunately, the munitions and fireworks operations left more than 275 known contaminants behind, some of which percolated into the groundwater below the property. Also, reports exist of unexploded ordnance still left on the property. Thus, the site constitutes the classic environmentally distressed or "brownfield" property that must undergo cleanup prior to usage for other purposes.
Brownfield development requires the leverage of three critical elements: Purchasing the brownfield property for the right price, knowledge about the methods of proper cleanup and decontamination, and the capital to pay for it all. In 1989, the then-owner of Bermite, Whittaker Corp., asserted a plan to create approximately 2,900 homes on the site, dubbed Porta Bella.
Since 1989 the property, lacking a knowledgeable, well capitalized developer, slid from entity to entity until it ended under the jurisdiction of the Arizona federal bankruptcy court that recently concluded an auction of the property, approving a joint bid from SunCal Cos., a development company based in Irvine, and Cherokee Investment Partners, a brownfield cleanup company.
Before examining whether SunCal and Cherokee possess the elements to successfully remediate and develop the Bermite project, I must first put to rest the idea of remediation versus nonremediation.
Some might argue that the property should remain fallow, comprising the ultimate open space - a kind of forbidden zone right in the middle of the city. It is a misguided theory. Believing a clogged and overflowing toilet in the middle of one's house for decades did not impact the value of the overall home would constitute the closest analogy.
While one can argue the relative desirability between residential and commercial use, make no mistake: Cleaning and filling the donut hole would serve the best interests of the community and all of its citizens.
Obviously, Whittaker and the many successors amounted to the wrong company with the wrong elements to remediate and develop the property. The project languished for 19 years until the ultimate successor slid into bankruptcy, unable to pay the costs of remediation and development.
Are SunCal and Cherokee the right companies for the job?
In June 2003, Cherokee submitted a detailed plan for the Bermite remediation and development, including a detailed capitalization plan for the purchase and remediation of the property.
Cherokee brings to the project a long resume of other successful brownfield remediation projects, including respect evidenced by positive write-ups of Cherokee's efforts in brownfield professional journals. A far cry from the historical pedigree of Cemex! It appears Cherokee possesses the knowledge necessary for the completion of this project.
SunCal, a privately owned regional developer, developed the local communities of Tesoro del Valle abutting Valencia off of Copper Hill, and Phase 1 of NorthLake in Castaic.
SunCal shows an ability to raise capital from third-party sources and also develops in a responsible way, providing their communities with parks and recreational amenities and required elementary schools (one in Castaic and one in Tesoro).
A company equal in class to The Newhall Land and Farming Co. in residential and commercial development, SunCal can provide the capital muscle and development knowledge to pull off the rebirth of this fallow land.
And finally, the pair bought Bermite for the right price: just $64,000 per acre, an investment leveraged 16 times with proper remediation.
The Santa Clarita Valley should hope for the success of the project. The SCV will stand better for SunCal and Cherokee's success for generations to come.
This essay contains historical information abstracted from the SCV History archives at scvhistory.com. Tim Myers lives in Valencia. His column reflects his own views, and not necessarily those of The Signal.
