Toting signs that said "Save the TCU," and "TCU = TLC" and "If You Close, Senior Woes," Santa Clarita Valley seniors made their point loud and clear Monday against the proposed closure of the transitional care unit at Henry Mayo Newhall Memorial Hospital. Led by Dr. Gene Dorio and Robin Clough, director of Recreation and Volunteers at the Santa Clarita Senior Center, the seniors have been protesting in various ways since last spring, when word of the intended closure at the end of 2007 became known.
"It's a vital component of hospital," said Barbara Stearns Cochran, an active senior who has served on the ad hoc Committee To Stop the Closure of the Transitional Care Unit.
Dorio called the effort "totally grassroots," noting that the seniors needed a vehicle to get their voice heard.
Andy Bogdan, director of Planning, Marketing and Public Relations at the hospital contended that the hospital needs more acute care beds, and that seniors as well as the rest of the community will benefit from the changes. Bogdan passed out literature citing the hospital's position on the closure of the TCU to demonstrators.
"We're trying to put our resources to the highest and best use," she said. "TCU is being phased out of health care - Kaiser doesn't offer it, and many, if not most states don't even have the designation."
She continued by noting that only 34 percent of Los Angeles County hospitals had a TCU in 2004, and that in the two years previous to that, use of TCU's decreased by 28 percent in Los Angeles County. Her explanations, however, fell on deaf ears within the senior community and those committed to this fight.
Dorio commented that while many patients can get better without transitional care, it takes them longer to recover and they don't rehabilitate as quickly without the support of a TCU.
"Without it," she said, "I don't know how I would have made it," said Netty Grossman of Valencia. Grossman spent several days in the TCU some months ago and thinks it's imperative that the facility stay open.
Grossman and others fear that if the TCU closes, local seniors who need that level of care will have to go to facilities in the San Fernando Valley, and making it impossible for family members who don't drive to visit them.
Another reason the seniors are militating against the TCU closure, Grossman said, is that some people find the idea of going to a convalescent home depressing and scary; they fear that it's kind of "the end of the line."
"It is so sad to me that this group doesn't understand that it's important to unclog the emergency room," said Bogdan. "We will be able to help more seniors under the new plan."
Dorio and the hospital disagree on some of the facts of the case, including the reasons why the E.R. is so backed up.
"This community will resolve this issue in a good way," said Mayor Laurene Weste who has plans to hold a community meeting in the near future to enable both parties to come to a resolution.
