One of our hot water heaters just died. Not too much of a surprise since it was 10 years old when we moved into our house 11 years ago. Fortunately, it was located outside when it corroded and leaked, but the other heater in our garage is also on borrowed time so now we have to replace both of them.
For the garage unit, the choice was easy. We bought another 50-gallon tank and our contractor, Alfonso Maldonado, hooked it up into the existing water and gas lines. The entire job came to about $750.
But the second tank outside only services two bathrooms. Since we only use the hot water in the morning and occasionally at night, why would we want to heat water all day and night?
So it made sense to consider a tankless unit that only heats the water when you use it.
Besides, they are energy efficient, comply with the National Energy Initiative and some larger units qualify for energy rebates. They are environmentally friendly because they don't use gas or electricity all the time. Also, wouldn't it be a good replacement for an old-fashioned tank with technology that goes back more than 100 years?
But, as our contractor began checking out the specs on our 45-year-old house, Maldonado began to have some doubts about the feasibility of installing the tankless unit. The problem was not just the extra cost, which can run nearly $1,500 to $2,000 for the unit itself - but add in the cost of retrofitting the house and the total can jump to $3,000 to $5,000. Would it really be worth the extra cost?
I went online to check out the numerous sites for state-of-the-art tankless units, but they only created more questions than answers. It was time to talk to the experts.
Graham Strayer, buyer and sales manager for Pyramid Pipe and Supply Co. in Canoga Park, said the choice is not simple when you consider the details. He lives in a condo in Canyon Country so he had little choice in water heating options. However, he thinks tankless units are terrific and sells about 400 to 500 per year with sales increasing about 10 percent a year as their popularity increases and prices come down - slightly.
"I am a huge fan of tankless units," Strayer said. "But they are not a good replacement choice for a tank when you already have the gas and water lines installed."
Strayer said about 50 percent of customers reject the tankless water heaters for replacement purposes when they consider the cost and retrofitting necessary.
"Tankless units are really only suitable for new construction and remodels, when you can design for the them by putting dedicated gas, electric and water lines in," he said. "Also, they need proper ventilation, so in Southern California, it is sometimes better to install them outside."
He said the number one reason for failure of the unit is improper installation.
"Don't go with a cheap or inexperienced installer," he said. "It needs a a minimum of 220 amps throughout house and a minimum of 3/4-inch to 1-inch gas lines."
They are not a good option for older houses.
He suggests installing a new and separate gas line directly from the meter because if you use the existing gas line that also services a stove, dryer and HVAC unit, it will compete for gas and lower the pressure. In the winter, if it is hooked up to the existing gas lines, it can compete with your forced air heater.
The reason is instead of a steady flow of gas to a pilot light, the tankless unit must heat up quickly and pulls an enormous amount of gas all at once.
"When you turn the unit on, it pulls about 185,000 to 199,000 BTUs an hour versus the 40,000 steady BTUs per hour for a 40 to 50 gallon hot water tank unit," he said. "You will never see the cost savings in water, electricity and gas to offset the initial cost of the unit. But once you turn the faucet on, you will never run out of hot water."
Tankless units qualify for energy rebates and comply with the National Energy Initiative because the units don't heat water continuously as hot water heaters do.
Strayer said that in addition to the extra cost of installation the other reason people are often unhappy is because they often expect faster water flow.
"They will be fine if you want to have three showers operating at the same time," he said. "But if you have a spa, a large, single bathtub or a new, state-of the art shower with five to six heads, it is not going to work. The water has to flow over the coils to heat as it comes out of the pipes and the water will be hot 24/7 as long as the unit is on - but the water pressure will not be the same as a tank."
The difference is tankless units flow at about 2 1/2 gallons per minute versus six gallons per minute for a tank.
Think of a coffee maker versus a tea kettle. The coffee maker heats the water as it flows through the unit but it takes time. A tea kettle heats all the water to a boil at once, but you can run out.
"I have a friend in Simi Valley who wants to install a tankless unit, but found out his gas meter was too small and he has to install a larger meter," Strayer said.
But commercial-size tankless units are great for businesses and restaurants who don't need high pressure but a continuos flow of constant hot water.
According to the catalog for commercial Rinnai tankless units, businesses can save up to 70 percent on water heating bills and because the units can be installed outside, they save precious space in a small restaurant.
Strayer said incorrect information is being generated about tankless systems.
"It sounds like you can just replace a tank unit with no changes to your present system," he said. "That is simply not true."
However, Strayer said there is a good alternative - the electric continuous pump.
"You can put a on a re-circulating pump, whether it is a tank or tankless unit. It is instant hot water, which is what most people want," he said.
To find out what a real user of a tankless systems thinks, I called friends, Ron Gorow and his wife, Judy Kerr, who replaced their tank unit with a tankless system last month in their home in Studio City. Maldonado, our contractor, retrofitted their gas, water and electrical system to place the unit outside of the house.
"It is just the same," Gorow said. "I don't notice any difference and the water is always hot."
He acknowledged it was several thousand dollars to install - but they like the fact that the thermometer is in the house and they can adjust the temperature whenever they want. They like the idea they can control when they heat water.
"We can turn it off when we go out of town," he said. "So we don't have heat water when we are not home."
