An anticipated Hart district construction audit was released Wednesday night, and presented without discussion or action from the board members, though the document revealed questionable business practices and management of funds.
Since July 19 - the day the forensic audit was ordered to be done by auditing firm Colbi Technologies Inc. - the William S. Hart Union High School District expected results to shed light on exactly how the construction costs at three local schools - Canyon and Saugus high schools and Arroyo Seco Junior High School - went tens of millions over budget.
What it showed was the following: The district relied heavily on one person - Rory Livingston, former assistant superintendent of business services - and he never gave the board all the numbers it needed to make informed decisions.
The audit stipulated that he authorized additional work without any interference from the board, and according to the report, it may be true that the board members never had "a conscientious awareness" that the numbers were changing.
Attempts by The Signal to reach Livingston this week were unsuccessful.
Furthermore, the district had been "co-mingling funds" by drawing from developer fees to fill in fiscal gaps - a violation of state laws that mandates that developer fees supplied to a district are only to be used in the neighboring schools from which they were taken.
It's possible that if the district is unable to prove that every dollar was spent correctly, the state could take its money back - which would mean disaster, school officials said.
"It's going to be a heck of a lot of work," district superintendent Jaime Castellanos said.
In his opinion, developer fees seemed "to be the piggy bank," and the district used it to fill the holes whenever a project needed more money.
The audit also showed the district muddied the projects by getting an essential distinction wrong.
The state considers new construction as any new building, whether it was built on a new site or on existing campus property.
However, the district did not budget its money with that in mind, the audit showed. Instead, new construction at Arroyo Seco Junior High and at both Canyon and Saugus high schools came out of the modernization budget.
This could prove to be the biggest problem at Saugus High - a school that remained fairly close to its original budget - because it built fewer new buildings than originally planned.
Deserving of fewer new construction funds, the budget at Saugus is nearly $5.4 million short of what was expected.
Both Canyon High and Arroyo Seco Junior High seem to be generally in line with state's mandates, though both ended up costing far more than the original budget, and seemingly more than the district can now afford.
To finish all three modernization projects, the district must deal with a significant shortfall, owing roughly $17.4 million at Arroyo Seco, $8.4 million at Canyon and $6.9 million at Saugus - putting the actual number at nearly $32.7 million more than what the district anticipated.
Each school's total cost may reach near the $50 million mark, far more than the going rate of building a new school, which reportedly in California averages only $22 million.
The auditor, the board and district personnel all seem to point to one person as being at fault for the inflated numbers: Livingston.
Information coming straight off of the audit reads: "The superintendent and board were inadequately informed and did not receive appropriate reporting about project status on an ongoing basis."
Livingston, who was supposed to have been bought out of his contract agreement with the district at a price of $234,000, was never paid, school officials said. He filed a legal claim for the money last month, but the district has refused to pay.
Castellanos answered guardedly when asked if he thought Livingston lied to him or the board members, or if Livingston sneaked change orders under their noses, preying on the fact they were uninformed.
"I'm not getting into the issue with Rory until the board has a chance to discuss," he said, and added that there is litigation at stake and he would not comment on the possibility of criminal or negligent work done by Livingston.
Some members of the public have opined that Livingston was a scapegoat, that it was the board turning a blind eye and not understanding what they were doing, leaving Livingston out of the picture and unable to answer for himself - something that board members and Castellanos hotly contest.
"(Construction) is not the expertise of the board members. They have to rely on the expertise of our staff," Castellanos said.
Board president Paul Strickland said the board repeatedly asked Livingston for information about how much the projects were costing and how much they were funded, but Livingston repeatedly refused to provide both sets of numbers at the same time.
Strickland also said no one but Livingston had access to the information, a statement confirmed by the $30,000 audit.
