Recently a reader wrote to The Signal with "astonishment" that I have submitted several commentaries about the out-of-control, over-budget spending by the William S. Hart Union High School District. The reader did not have any particular questions but certainly has a lot of misinformation that I can correct for her.
Information and numbers have not been simply pulled out of thin air. Any "facts" reported by me have been taken from articles printed in The Signal after its reporters spoke with Hart personnel. All such information can be easily obtained and verified by merely going to The Signal archives as of about mid-June, including the scenario of the $234,000 employment buyout of Rory Livingston.
There is some consternation about school projects being about 92 percent over budget and the math of a 2,000-percent overrun in a seven-month period at Canyon High. Again, Signal articles gave the numbers and I did the math. To clarify what has been written, I will quote what I wrote from one commentary that appeared on or about Aug. 28:
"The cost overruns at just the Arroyo Seco Junior High School construction have jumped from $22.4 million to $43 million. Irrespective of this 92-percent overrun, the project is not complete.
"Canyon High School reportedly suffered a cost overrun of $237,771 in November 2005; seven months later, that figure jumped by an additional $4,462,229, an overrun of nearly 2,000 percent - so far. ... Yet another massive 'cost overrun' at Canyon High; district officials recently got out in front of the blast and announced that the construction budget will now simply be an 'increased scope of work.' That walloping new scope will take the budget from $36.1 million to a mammoth $50 million cost. Right up front we have a gargantuan increase of 38.5 percent, and by the district heads' profile, we are not even at the doorstep of the historic and inevitable cost overruns yet. There is a lot of time as construction is estimated to take another 1 1/2 years."
I said what I meant and I meant what I said.
There was a topic raised by the reader that was of a surprise to me. She said district spokeswoman Pat Willett "has repeatedly tried to set up face-to-face meetings with Ms. Arenson so that her questions can be answered, but to no avail."
I do not know to what lengths Ms. Willett has gone to contact me, but I can absolutely, unequivocally tell you that I have never heard from any Pat Willett. However, now that the topic has arisen, such a meeting would be of question, because why meet just with me? The solution to all of the questions that have emerged is not that I simply go silent while no answers have been given publicly. Nor is it my responsibility to pick up the district's banner and write commentaries clearing up everything in the event questions were answered (to me).
I disagree with the reader that it is The Signal's responsibility to "facilitate" a meeting between a columnist and the school board. The better alternative is for the board to be open to sitting down at length with The Signal and respond to all of the questions that have been asked in recent months.
There are two issues at stake: the decision making and the massive amounts of cost overruns on projects that are far from completion, setting the stage for deficits that have lots of room to grow.
The reader makes a point that she has been to many school board meetings and has never heard the numbers that have been regurgitated from The Signal reporting. In that statement lies the problem.
From what I understand, the Measure V Oversight Committee was not hearing those numbers, either; at least, not when Rory Livingston, the former assistant superintendent of business for the Hart District, was still talking to them.
The aforementioned reader's final statement is, "Let's get all our facts straight." I could not agree more. If the well-intended reader comes up with different facts at this stage of the game, please let us know, and tell us the source. If the information is different from what has been given already, then let's find out why and how we got the first incorrect data.
Many basic questions remain. For instance, with the bankruptcy of at least one contractor on the Arroyo Seco Junior High project, and considering that we seemingly paid nearly a quarter of a million dollars for a surety bond - why are taxpayers paying extra to continue construction?
To preclude any questions on that subject, and since there is not space to recite the workings of a surety bond here, I will simply refer anyone who is interested to my commentary of Aug. 7 for those details.
It is bothersome when the messenger and message are faulted, versus the problems. The attitude of the recent letter is pretentious; a 92 percent cost overrun is defined as merely, "not a figure the community can celebrate." It would seem that the unabashed spending is not an issue; just that I write about it.
There is the platform for how public money gets wasted, and those who do not perform responsibly keep getting elected.
That is very troubling.
Betty Arenson lives in Valencia. Her column reflects her own views, and not necessarily those of The Signal.
