It doesn't matter what I say because California is going to vote for it anyway, but I just can't let this windmill go without tilting at it.
I'm talking about Proposition 90.
You might know Proposition 90 as the measure that stops the government from taking away your house so a big developer can build a Wal-Mart on your property.
At least, that's the hype.
Heck, if the Santa Clarita City Council wanted to condemn my house so a developer could come in and build - oh, let's say a Baathist Party rape room - I'd be upset, too.
When's the last time the city tried to do something like that to you?
Precisely. It hasn't.
If Proposition 90 were really about limiting the ability of cities such as Santa Clarita from using eminent domain for economic development purposes, I might be inclined to support it. I don't know. Go write a ballot measure that does only that, and I'll think about it.
Proposition 90 does many more things than that - dangerous things.
Proposition 90 will jeopardize the quality of life of every man, woman and child in Santa Clarita.
I'm not exaggerating. Under Proposition 90, neither the Santa Clarita City Council nor the Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors would be able to control growth in our valley - even if they wanted to.
Yes, it is true that Proposition 90 stops local governments from using the power of eminent domain to redevelop a place like Old Town Newhall. Under Proposition 90, you can forget about the city's plans to fix up our old downtown.
The reality is, cities rarely use eminent domain to do redevelopment. When cities want to redevelop property, more often than not, they buy the property outright from its owner without condemning it.
Guess what the proponents of Proposition 90 don't tell you about eminent domain?
When a city does decide to use eminent domain to take a piece of property, the city must pay fair-market value for it.
That is the law. (Actually, it's in the Constitution.) A city can't take your property and leave you holding the bag.
But enough about eminent domain. That's not the biggest and most problematic part of Proposition 90.
The worst part of Proposition 90 is the part that stops a city such as Santa Clarita from doing land-use planning.
Under Proposition 90, a city can't "downzone" property. Santa Clarita wouldn't be able to limit the number of homes in a development project without paying off the developer.
I'll give you an example.
Let's say a piece of property is zoned for multi-family residential use. Let's say that under the current zoning, as many as 18 apartment units could be jammed onto each acre of the property. (Note: In most cases, the "current zoning" was adopted 15 long years ago when the city didn't always know what it was doing.)
Now let's say the neighbors complain, the city planners think there should be fewer apartments per acre, or maybe the city wants one-third of the property to be parkland in exchange for allowing 18 units per acre on the rest.
That's the sort of thing that happens now. The city and the property owner work together to come up with a development plan the public can live with.
Proposition 90 changes all of that. Under Proposition 90, developers will no longer have any incentive to sit down with city planners and hash out an acceptable project.
Under Proposition 90, if the current zoning allows up to 18 apartment units per acre, the developer can build 18 units per acre. If the city wants to limit the developer to, say, 12 units per acre, the city would have to pay the developer the theoretical value of the other six apartment units that weren't approved.
No fooling. Under Proposition 90, the city of Santa Clarita and other cities across California would have to pay developers the market value of theoretical houses and apartment units that never would be allowed in real life.
And if the city didn't want to pay, the developer could sue - and collect.
Proposition 90 amounts to a carte blanche entitlement for developers, disguised as a property rights issue.
Now, what if the citizens of Santa Clarita wanted to band together and pass a slow-growth initiative? It's not far-fetched. Local activists tried it in 1992.
Well, under Proposition 90, if a voter-approved "growth cap" barred a developer from building all of the homes allowed under zoning laws, the developer could sue the city for damages.
Oh, and how would you folks in the Valencia Summit like to see a 12-story-tall hospital? Sound good? Then you'll want to vote "yes" on Proposition 90.
Under Proposition 90, cities can't introduce restrictions on building height - aka "private air space" - without compensating the property owner.
How much would the city have to pay to limit Henry Mayo to five stories - when the nearby Valencia Town Center is already six stories and plans are afoot right now for a 10-story hotel elsewhere in Valencia? Difficult to say. What's the value of theoretical hospital floors? The mind boggles.
And how about you folks in Hidden Valley who convinced the City Council to shut Valley Street so your kids would be safe from speeding cars? If the decision had been made today, the city would have to compensate the homeowners in Happy Valley for the theoretical impairment to their property values. (In a bizarre twist of logic, it would probably have to pay Hidden Valley homeowners, too.)
And don't forget, every time the city has to pay real money to a landowner for theoretical property impairment, those are our city tax dollars that could be spent on better things such as more parks and deputy sheriffs.
Under Proposition 90, California cities will have to put up with runaway growth - or go broke trying to stop it.
Here is the exact language of the initiative defining the areas where cities and counties would have to pay for theoretical "loss" of property value:
"Examples of substantial economic loss include, but are not limited to, the downzoning of private property, the elimination of any access to private property, and limitations on the use of private air space. 'Government action' shall mean any statute, charter provision, ordinance, resolution, law, rule or regulation."
If you're afraid Mayor Laurene Weste or Supervisor Mike Antonovich will take away your house and allow a private developer to build a rape room, vote yes on Proposition 90.
Otherwise, vote no.
Leon Worden is The Signal's senior editor. His column reflects his own views, and not necessarily those of The Signal.
