The actions of the Hart school board leading up to the release of the construction audit results are considerable and should not be overlooked or overshadowed by the recently released audit findings.
As a member of the Hart board, I did not "conspicuously refrain from comment" after the presentation of the recently completed forensic audit. My mother always taught me to think before I spoke. I didn't always follow her suggestion, and too often I found I had spoken too soon. It took me years to understand why this was important. I wouldn't be surprised if Tim Whyte's mother and Betty Arenson's mother told them the same thing at some point in time in their lives, too.
I didn't speak because, like all who were present, I was hearing and seeing the results for the first time. The seriousness of the subject matter would suggest that I first understand what I was being told before offering commentary.
It was June 21 of this year when the superintendent and the school board were brought up to date with budget projections that exceeded what we had been told on Nov. 2, 2005. In November, the report to the superintendent and board represented that the three schools, Canyon, Saugus and Arroyo Seco, had a projected expense totaling $120 million and would be approximately $2 million dollars over budget - or about 2 percent. Each member of the board individually and as a group, in open session, requested that our superintendent develop short- and long-term cash forecasts to ensure that we could accurately evaluate our ability to fund expanding project needs such as performing arts centers, parking lot renovations and remaining planned construction for the three schools.
On June 21, the board was presented with an update to projected costs for the three schools. Instead of $2 million, the projection identified we would be over budget by $18 million. Changes had already been made in district staffing assignments by this date, and the board directed the superintendent to seek applicants for a new assistant superintendent of business services. On July 25, applicants for the position were interviewed, none of whom met the immediate or long-term needs of the district. The superintendent, on the recommendation of the board, chose to divide the responsibilities previously held by the assistant superintendent into two: director of operations and chief financial officer. These assignments were approved Oct. 4.
In our Sept. 21 and Oct. 4 meetings, the Hart District and the public heard a lengthy presentation on the projected funding sources and budget requirements for the projects at Canyon, Saugus and Arroyo Seco. It was at these two meetings that we learned our expected costs for the three campuses would reach approximately $141 million - $21 million more than what we thought to be accurate in June. This budget is consistent with the results of the audit released Oct. 18.
The results of the audit focused on more of the "why, how and when" budgets and funding were changing and what we, as a board or district, could or should have done to minimize the impact of expanding project scope, escalating construction costs or delays out of our direct control.
Of the $141 million, $23.6 million has been attributed to escalating construction costs and about $1 million in unforeseen conditions (usually things found underground or behind walls). Additionally, approximately $5.5 million has been identified as architect errors and omissions, and the district will seek reimbursement for these costs. The delays caused by the state agencies associated with geological issues had an impact of $3.5 million on the Canyon project alone.
Enough with the numbers for now. They are not what we expected, and they do not represent what we "knew" in November 2005.
As an elected member of a governing body, I cannot express an opinion for anyone other than myself, but I would suspect that if asked, the five elected school board members, along with the superintendent and his staff, will take ownership of the projects to ensure we have no surprises such as this in the future.
Yes, I am sorry we didn't achieve the same successes on these three projects as we have at West Ranch, Rancho Pico, Rio Norte and Golden Valley. The systems were the same, and there would be no reason to believe the results would be significantly different.
Yes, we will do a better job of project oversight, and yes, the communication from our construction manager and facilities operations to the board has already improved.
Yes, we will review every funding source and how it was spent to ensure that we comply with state guidelines. And yes, we will build Castaic High School and modernize the balance of the campuses.
I can understand why sometimes it may look like the district or the board are being silent. In fact, you have an experienced board that does the necessary research and review before it makes the serious decisions placed before it.
The Hart District is the largest employer in the city of Santa Clarita, with more than 2,000 employees, and has an operating budget greater than the city itself. The district has been engaged in a series of construction projects totaling almost $500 million in the last several years.
I invite any interested party to contact me with your concerns or questions on this or any other Hart District school board matter, as I invite all of you to attend any of our public meetings to experience the workings of a school board and the district they represent.
I think you'll find a committed board, a committed staff, and a district that excels. We take our elected positions very seriously. We are human. We can make mistakes. We will learn from them.
As an aside, the individuals who have most often offered opinion or commentary on the Hart District in this newspaper have never been to a school board meeting in my seven years on this board. They should be the first to attend. It may cause them to think before they speak.
Steven M. Sturgeon is a member of the governing board of the William S. Hart Union High School District. His column reflects his own views, and not necessarily those of The Signal.
