ArchiveSCV
the-signal.com. The Santa Clarita Valley Signal. Back to the collection.

· the-signal.com, Wayback capture

Seize the Day!

Henry Mayo Master Plan: Who Benefits?

Henry Mayo Newhall Memorial Hospital's 25-year master plan for expansion is gargantuan. Let's put that on the table. The most vocal hospital cheerleaders can't credibly say it isn't. The master plan would allow the construction of three-, four- and maybe five-story buildings on almost every square inch of hospital property - a five-fold increase in building space, chiefly for private medical offices and parking - in the middle of a residential neighborhood.

So what? The hospital was there before the Valencia Summit was built. And the way our valley is growing, we need a bigger hospital, or we'll all die in some future disaster.

At least, those have been the arguments of the hospital insiders and their friends who are engaged in a coordinated letter-writing campaign to discredit NIMBYs in the Summit who foresee insurmountable problems if the master plan is approved.

I've got mixed feelings about NIMBYs. On the one hand, I can appreciate anyone with the guts to stand up for the sanctity of his neighborhood, his quality of life and yes, his property values. I have no patience for "NIMBYs without a clue" who don't investigate what's on the drawing board before they buy their house, but that's not the case here. When Summit residents say there was never any plan for a tall, wall-to-wall mega-medical complex in their backyards, they're right.

On the other hand, when you're dealing with an important facility that serves the entire community, such as a hospital, the needs of the community must come first. To borrow a line from "Star Trek II" - considering that Leonard Nimoy is on the cover of today's Opinion section - "The needs of the many outweigh the needs of the few, or the one."

But that begs the question. Does the community "need" the City Council to approve a 25-year master plan for Henry Mayo and its for-profit business partner?

I don't know. I have my doubts.

Or let's call them questions, not doubts. Even after I hosted a community forum last Monday night where hospital CEO Roger Seaver addressed 150 angry Valencia residents, I still have questions I believe must be asked and answered - on the record, in City Council chambers - before the Planning Commission and council sign off.

What is a master plan?

A master plan is a form of entitlement. Call it a "pre-approval" and you're not far off the mark. A master plan changes zoning restrictions so a landowner or developer can build something that wouldn't be allowed under current zoning.

Henry Mayo's master plan would specify what can (and can't) be built on the hospital campus over the next 25 years. (As far as "can't," the hospital wouldn't be able to build homes, for instance.) Rather than going through a full-blown public approval process for each separate building as it comes online, having a master plan streamlines the process. Individual building projects would be submitted to the city for a "plan check" to make sure they're consistent with the master plan.

That's why, if there are disputes over building heights, density, traffic flow, noise, air quality, whatever - those disputes must be settled now, during the master plan approval process. Once approved, those arguments become moot for 25 years, as long as the individual projects jibe with the restrictions imposed today.

How clear is your crystal ball? Can you anticipate traffic flow in the year 2031? If the council intends to approve a 25-year master plan, it had better be able to do so.

Does Henry Mayo need a master plan to expand?

No. Of course not. At least, not from a governmental standpoint. I don't know what the hospital's financial backers might be demanding, but governmentally, no. Like any other commercial developer, the hospital could come to the City Council for approval of each new building if and when it is needed, and go through the zoning changes and environmental approval processes each time.

With a master plan, it won't have to. With a master plan, the hospital property will be "entitled" for growth. The master plan is a "guarantee" that the hospital will be able to build according to the plan.

In California real estate, guarantees are few and far between. They're worth big, big bucks. Which leads to the next question...

What if the hospital sells?

The entitlement - the master plan - stays with the land, not the owner. As long as the new owner intends to run a medical facility, the new owner would be bound by its provisions - and would benefit from its guarantees.

Henry Mayo is and has always been an independent, nonprofit hospital run by a board of directors who come from the community. Within the last decade, the hospital not only teetered on but actually fell over the brink of bankruptcy. Buyout offers were received and rejected. Today, Seaver says the board has no desire to sell. Of course, if the board felt it were in the community's best interest to sell, it would be obliged to do so - as Seaver noted during Monday's forum.

With its land "entitled" through a master plan, Henry Mayo would be worth multiples of what it's worth today. What if a giant operator such as Tenet or Catholic Healthcare West made a bid that couldn't be refused? We'd no longer have a community hospital run by a community board. How long do you suppose Tenet or CHW would continue to operate a money-losing trauma center?

Think of The Newhall Land and Farming Co. It entitled the 21,000-home Newhall Ranch project; then it sold out to Florida-based Lennar Corp. Its executives walked away with millions. That's not a criticism. That's the American way.

What is the long-term outlook for hospitals in our valley?

Obviously, if you're going to allow Henry Mayo to expand its building capacity from 333,000 square feet of hospital and office space today to a whopping 1.75 million square feet over 25 years, including parking structures, you have to know how many users there will be and what alternatives they will have.

In 25 years, northern Los Angeles County will grow from 500,000 people today to 1.2 million. Much of the growth will happen along the Highway 14 corridor. We need a hospital out that way. There are no plans for one.

Much of the growth will occur along the Interstate 5 corridor. Surprise. Talks are underway for Providence to build a hospital west of I-5, somewhere between Magic Mountain and the Valencia Commerce Center (which is in Valencia, hence the name).

Consider the argument that Henry Mayo needs to expand so it can attract the best doctors. Is that just so it can compete with Providence? If that is the case - and I'm not saying I think it is, but if that is the case - is that a valid argument from a public policy perspective?

What is the relationship between G&L Realty and the hospital?

This is where I'm fuzzy. Seaver took over the hospital in mid-bankruptcy, and G&L bailed it out. G&L didn't take over the hospital operation, but it put up the capital.

In exchange for what? Medical office buildings, I guess. A promise to run a 25-year construction master plan up the flagpole, I guess.

This is key: The applicant for the master plan is not just Henry Mayo. Officially, technically, the applicant is "Mr. Roger Seaver, Henry Mayo Newhall Memorial Hospital/G&L Realty."

That means it is not just our little nonprofit hospital that is asking for a 25-year development agreement. This G&L Realty, a for-profit medical office developer, is asking for the agreement, too.

If I understand Seaver correctly, the hospital owns the land and G&L would own the buildings. G&L would rent the land from the hospital, and if the hospital needed space in G&L's buildings, it would rent back the space from G&L. Weird.

Remember when I said an entitlement, such as a master plan, stays with the land and not with the owner? Well, by the same token, the government (the City Council) can't take ownership into consideration on the front end, either. "Who owns what part of whom" isn't usually the government's business.

In this case, however, it is vital for Seaver and everyone else connected with the hospital to disclose any interests they might have in G&L and any other company that would benefit from this master plan. Why? So the community and the City Council have a clear understanding of what they're getting into.

While it calls for construction in three "phases," the master plan doesn't impose a timetable. Everything could be built the next day, or it could be spread out over 25 years, or it could be built never. G&L can and likely will build an 80,000-square-foot, for-profit medical office building almost immediately. I believe Seaver said the first hospital construction is expected to start in seven years.

Remember that this is not just about the hospital. It's about a for-profit medical office development company - G&L - that is seeking a 25-year stamp of approval from the government that would give it a competitive advantage in a cutthroat market, if you'll pardon the pun.

It certainly is not just about a bunch of NIMBYs.

Leon Worden is The Signal's senior editor. His column reflects his own views, and not necessarily those of The Signal.

← Back to 2006

About this record

How it was held, read and classified

Record details

Morris ID
Not a Morris ID. This record is keyed ts-ds:34446.
System
displaystory pages (?module=displaystory)
Reading copy
the-signal.com
Chosen by: only copy held. On this copy: words 1,561 (e-mail addresses counted as one token); reader comments 0 (counted, not reproduced here); images 0.
Extracted by
displaystory:2007_font_head
signal-extract/0.15 (2026-11-16)

Other copies

Held
None. The holding has this article from one host only.

How it was classified

Label
clearly-local
Judgment
A machine’s (recorded as machine), kept as one so it can be revisited.
Classifier
signal-localclass/0.7 (2026-11-12)
Local signals
  • byline:staff_marker [senior editor]
  • text:valley_names [7 distinct/27 mentions: Valencia, Newhall, Henry Mayo, Newhall Land, City Council, Magic Mountain]
National signals
none fired
Scores
local 6, national 0