Should Henry Mayo Newhall Memorial Hospital be allowed to expand? Absolutely. The Valencia hospital has demonstrated a need for more acute care beds; the senior community has demonstrated a need for the retention of transitional care beds, and the community recently banded together to raise $12 million to expand the emergency room. It will probably need to be further expanded in the future.
Should the Planning Commission approve Henry Mayo's 25-year master plan, as proposed? That is a very different question, and the answer is no.
"Hospital expansion" is not synonymous with "master plan approval." The master plan would allow a private developer, G&L Realty, to "fill in" most of the hospital property with three- and four-story office buildings and parking structures. "Hospital expansion" is only a small part of what the master plan would allow.
The hospital doesn't need a 25-year development agreement (aka master plan) from the city to expand. It can expand just fine without one.
The more appropriate question is: Should the city approve the construction of a giant medical office complex in the middle of a residential neighborhood? That's what the proposed master plan would do, and the answer, based on the information available today, is no.
Tonight the Planning Commission will hear more testimony from the public about the pluses and minuses of the master plan. City staff is recommending that the commission receive the comments, close the public hearing tonight, approve the master plan - either as-is, or with less office space - and pass it along to the City Council for final approval.
The commission should not do so today. The intersection of McBean Parkway and Orchard Village Road is not the best place for what would be one of the biggest medical facilities in Los Angeles County. It's too far from the freeways, the surrounding roads are already jammed at rush hour, and you just can't put that much commercial building in a residential neighborhood.
Approving a 25-year master plan on the scale of what the hospital and G&L Realty are proposing would require a determination that there is no alternative. The city would need to determine that there is no available land in any more appropriate location where Henry Mayo could move or build a satellite facility; and that there is no chance that another hospital will move into the Santa Clarita Valley in a more accessible location over the next 25 years.
Neither determination can be made. There is land on the east side of our valley that would support medical services where our residents need it most, and there is more than a good chance that we will see a second and even larger hospital in our valley a lot sooner than 25 years from now.
The hospital administration would have you believe you're either with the hospital, or you're against it. That's sad, because it can only create enemies where they don't otherwise exist. The Signal has always been a strong supporter of our community hospital, but that doesn't mean we believe "anything goes."
If the hospital wants and needs to expand, it should come to the city for approval when it's ready to build a hospital building. If the first hospital building is needed in 2013, as has been reported, then the hospital should come to the city for approval around 2012.
And if an 80,000-square-foot medical office building is needed today, let G&L Realty come to the city with a proposal for one - and only one - at a time, anyway.
The hospital has not demonstrated it needs a 25-year development agreement to expand in Valencia. It cannot possibly argue that it knows how big it will need to be in 25 years in order to meet the needs of the community, because it cannot say it will be our only hospital. It has failed to show why it can't buy land in Canyon Country for a satellite facility. And it has not demonstrated how a residential neighborhood can withstand a five-fold increase in buildings.
Instead, we hear that unless we have a bigger hospital, we'll have nowhere to go in the next earthquake. Fine. We're all for "hospital expansion." Do it in 2013 when it's needed.
But don't let hospital administrators get away with telling you the hospital can't expand unless the master plan is approved, because it isn't true.
Hospital expansion good.
Master plan bad.
Rather than sending it along to the City Council for final approval, the Planning Commission should reject the master plan and invite G&L Realty and the hospital to submit individual building plans when they're ready to do so.
