The process is sound, and it will yield positive results for the citizens of Santa Clarita - as long as the City Council sticks to it.
We're referring, of course, to the process that the council set up - by unanimous vote - to fill out the remaining year and four months of Cameron Smyth's term.
To avert any appearance (or fact) of undue influence, the council gave City Manager Ken Pulskamp the "blind" authority to form a 16-person panel of leaders from Santa Clarita's nonprofit, business and education communities to interview the applicants for Smyth's seat and choose the top five. By "blind," we mean that nobody on the council knew who Pulskamp would select.
Pulskamp did his job admirably and fairly. He selected 16 people with diverse backgrounds and interests who interviewed the applicants and ranked them in order of the panelists' own interpretation of their abilities.
Applicants were asked to state their intent either to act as a "caretaker" and retire after the completion of Smyth's term, or to seek re-election. Only two applicants checked the "caretaker" box, and as odds would have it, neither made the panelists' final cut.
Instead, the panel recommended five people who would likely seek re-election, if appointed to the council now: Bob Spierer, Bill Kennedy, Laurie Ender, Bill Bolde and Maria Gutzeit.
The finalists are as diverse as the panel itself. One is from law enforcement, one is a business leader, one is a parks commissioner, one is an educator and one is a water board member and environmental advocate.
Any of the five would make a fine addition to the City Council.
Selecting one would be difficult, and last Wednesday, the four sitting council members couldn't do it. They tabled the issue and decided to take it up again on Tuesday - right after Marsha McLean is expected to get three votes for mayor (Frank Ferry's, Laurene Weste's and her own).
McLean's first act as mayor should be to complete the process and move the council toward a selection from one of the top five applicants.
Apparently, however, she has no plans to do so.
On Wednesday, McLean decided she wanted to abandon the process - a process that she herself voted for - and interview retired Mayor Carl Boyer for the position.
It seems McLean was upset because her friend on the Planning Commission, Diane Trautman, didn't make it into the final five. So rather than accept the fact that other applicants ranked higher, McLean put on the mantle of the sore loser and push for Boyer. Why? Well, Boyer was one of the two applicants who said he wouldn't seek re-election, opening the door for Trautman to run in 2008 without the need to defeat an incumbent.
If McLean feels she owes her council seat to Diane Trautman, this is not the way to pay her back.
And if McLean is going to flip-flop every time she doesn't get her way - voting to support a process, then turning her back on it when the result isn't to her liking - then she is not being a good public servant.
If it is indicative of how she will behave as mayor, she should not be mayor.
It isn't even appropriate for a council member. We've been down that road with council members in the past, and the voters have rightly turned them out.
It is not too late. McLean should walk into Tuesday night's meeting with a renewed conviction to serve the people of Santa Clarita first, and pay off her political debts last.
She should help, rather than hinder, the council as it makes a most difficult decision. She should guide it to consensus on one of the five people who are best suited to fill Smyth's seat, as judged by a broad-based panel that represents the nonprofit, business and educational leadership of this community.
To do otherwise is insulting not only to her fellow council members who, with her, made the decision to go with this process, but to the city staff members who carried it out, to the 16 people who gave their time to the city and made the best, fairest and most sincere decisions they could.
It would also be a disservice to the citizens of this city who would be robbed of the opportunity to be served by one of the five best qualified people for the job.
In fact, Wednesday night's meeting made it clear that two of the five, in particular, would make wonderful additions to the City Council.
Bob Spierer, the former commander of the SCV Sheriff's Station, is a proven leader. In fact, he was such a leader that he was promoted to high positions within the department prior to retirement.
Maria Gutzeit has proven her leadership mettle, as well. She was elected to the Newhall County Water Board during the agency's darkest hours and restored it to its original upright position. True, it would be a shame to lose her from the water board and have to go through those political shenanigans all over again - but that would not be a justifiable reason for the City Council to stifle her public service career.
Santa Clarita would be lucky to have either one on the City Council. And unless McLean can get her act together really fast, we really should have both.
