ArchiveSCV
the-signal.com. The Santa Clarita Valley Signal. Back to the collection.

· oldsite.the-signal.com, Wayback capture

An Open Letter to the City Council

I want to congratulate the entire City Council, City Manager Ken Pulskamp and all the city staff for the recent developments in the fight against the Cemex mega-mine.

Only by standing shoulder-to-shoulder and keeping their noses to the grindstone were the members of the City Council and staff able to convince Sens. Dianne Feinstein and Barbara Boxer to join the battle, which begins anew in 2007 when Rep. Buck McKeon reintroduces his bill to limit mining in Soledad Canyon.

While the bill would not completely stop the mine, it would authorize the federal government to take back the land in Soledad Canyon where Cemex wants to mine and give Cemex mining rights somewhere else. The federal government would then re-lease the mineral rights in Soledad Canyon to the highest bidder - but with the caveat that mining will be limited to "historic" levels.

In 1990, when the Bureau of Land Management leased the mining rights to Cemex's predecessor, Transit Mixed Concrete, it did so with the intent of allowing the company to mine roughly 10 times more sand and gravel than had been produced annually for the past several decades, in exchange for $28 million in royalties.

Under McKeon's legislation, mining would be limited to 300,000 tons per year, which the city has deemed acceptable. Moreover, the city would be in the loop the next time around. Hopefully, the city will be in a position to negotiate for tonnage fees from the new winning bidder, and the residents of eastern Canyon Country would be able to breathe - and drive - easier than under the original Cemex plan.

We wouldn't be here today, holding out hope for a resolution to the problem of Cemex if not for years of hard, dedicated and unified work by the City Council. The mega-mine would be in and producing.

I say "unified" because all five City Council members have worked tirelessly to block the mining plan. While we owe special thanks to Mayor Laurene Weste and Councilman Bob Kellar - who comprise the subcommittee against the mine and have spearheaded the efforts with countless hours of work, phone calls and trips - it is the entire City Council working as a team that will have won the battle in the end.

When I see how things can be accomplished when you work together, it gives me great sadness to reflect on the horror of watching last Wednesday's special meeting of the City Council. Mayor Pro Tem Marsha McLean divided the council, divided the city and derailed the system.

The entire Council directed City Manager Ken Pulskamp to come up with a fair, impartial, non-political system to recommend five top applicants to fill the seat vacated by Cameron Smyth, who is now in Sacramento representing us in the state Assembly.

Pulskamp set up a panel of 16 community members to interview the 15 applicants. Panelists were instructed to rank their top five individual choices, and the cumulative totals of the panel would determine the applicants' ranking.

The Council was to interview and select one applicant out of the top five. If it could not, it would consider the next five applicants. If it still could not reach consensus, the council could then try to find someone else or call for a special election.

This is not what happened. After all five applicants underwent a grueling questioning process, McLean refused to vote. She announced that she would rather interview her own picks, who did not make the top five. She wanted to interview Diane Trautman, "her" planning commissioner, and former Mayor Carl Boyer who, along with Canyon Theatre Guild Artistic Director TimBen Boydston pledged to be "placeholders" and not seek election in 2008.

McLean mentioned TimBen - who received the same ranking from the panel - and then curiously overlooked him, saying she wanted the Council to interview only Boyer.

Marsha, this process was agreed upon by each council member, including you. By voting to go with this process, you decided that no individual council member would be able to stack the deck and get his or her personal favorite appointed to the position.

That was the a sound decision. Don't change your mind now. If you want to be mayor, act like a leader. Unify.

You were right when you voted to go with the panel process. It was an impartial way to enable the best applicants to rise to the top. Panelists, selected by Pulskamp, represented a cross-section of this community. And yes, as I've mentioned, I was one of them. As such, I can tell you each panelist worked hard to make an intelligent, informed, unbiased decision.

Just as there were Democrats and Republicans on the panel, there were Democrats and Republicans among the five finalists for Council. The five finalists come from very different walks of life and have different views. What they seem to share is a love for Santa Clarita and a desire to serve this city.

Under the process you chose, the council is to try to decide on one of the five finalists. Then and only then - if you can't reach consensus on one outstanding applicant - would you interview Nos. 6 through 10 and try to pick one of those.

The process was designed exactly to prevent you from doing what you appear to be doing - trying to hand-pick Smyth's successor.

If you want to be a leader, unify. Don't divide. Lead the Council to consensus. Follow the process you approved. Pick one of the top five tonight. Then, if you can't bring your colleagues to consensus, interview the next five applicants - all of them.

After watching the questioning of all five top applicants at last week's special council meeting, I have narrowed my recommendations to two: Bob Spierer, the former commander of the SCV Sheriff's Station who rose to even higher positions of authority within the Sheriff's Department prior to retirement; and Maria Gutzeit, the president of the Newhall County Water Board who brought the agency back from the brink of insanity and ruin.

They are two very different applicants with very different backgrounds. Either would make a great leader of our city.

Marsha, tonight you become mayor. Unify the Council. Unify the city. Do the right thing.

Richard Budman is the publisher of The Signal.

← Back to 2006

About this record

How it was held, read and classified

Record details

Morris ID
Not a Morris ID. This record is keyed ts-ds:35009.
System
displaystory pages (?module=displaystory)
Reading copy
oldsite.the-signal.com
Chosen by: latest capture. On this copy: words 1,053 (e-mail addresses counted as one token); reader comments 0 (counted, not reproduced here); images 0.
Extracted by
displaystory:print_view
signal-extract/0.15 (2026-11-16)

Other copies (3)

Host
the-signal.com
http://www.the-signal.com/?module=displaystory&story_id=35009&format=html
Captured14 October 2007, 14:43:06 UTC
CaptureThe archive does not serve this capture as a facsimile; the text is extracted from it.
SHA-256db0d5ee2263e9bee97cc3cce271d2d5869db310d4573afbc25264bf981584fa9SHA-256 of the bytes the archive holds, recorded at intake. A SHA-1 of the same bytes, taken at the same time, equals the Wayback Machine’s own digest for this capture: RQK4RAQL3GNN7FIPBUQE6XYMCDFADIRR.
Holds alone
nothing measured beyond the chosen copy
Host
the-signal.com
http://www.the-signal.com/?module=displaystory&story_id=35009&format=print
Captured7 November 2007, 08:34:25 UTC
CaptureThe archive does not serve this capture as a facsimile; the text is extracted from it.
SHA-256bd1349f1d7769a0b1fdaaea4ae3622c3bf8a36e29b5863fbece98139b44fc0d9SHA-256 of the bytes the archive holds, recorded at intake. A SHA-1 of the same bytes, taken at the same time, equals the Wayback Machine’s own digest for this capture: 5Y2X6RGMLFAVK2LX4YKNIRJAITI2IBBE.
Holds alone
nothing measured beyond the chosen copy
Host
oldsite.the-signal.com
http://oldsite.the-signal.com/?module=displaystory&story_id=35009&format=html
Captured30 October 2012, 11:14:11 UTC
CaptureThe archive does not serve this capture as a facsimile; the text is extracted from it.
SHA-256f0bf1316fcb50f3b49d39bc9b51ccca0fa498da7149da2a1c1cc3ab0c9dfd2b3SHA-256 of the bytes the archive holds, recorded at intake. A SHA-1 of the same bytes, taken at the same time, equals the Wayback Machine’s own digest for this capture: 6AZEOF7NJ4PCCA443FCV75YJNBJTCTCA.
Holds alone
nothing measured beyond the chosen copy

How it was classified

Label
clearly-local
Judgment
A machine’s (recorded as machine), kept as one so it can be revisited.
Classifier
signal-localclass/0.7 (2026-11-12)
Local signals
  • text:valley_names [9 distinct/22 mentions: Santa Clarita, SCV, Newhall, Canyon Country, City Council, SCV Sheriff, Newhall County Water, Cemex]
  • byline:named_writer_no_wire_credit [Commentary by Richard Budman]
  • text:valley_elected_official “Cameron Smyth”, “Smyth”, “McKeon”
National signals
  • text:national_politics_vocab_light [2 hits]
Scores
local 6, national 1