The company proposing to install 23,000 homes near Interstate 5 atop the Grapevine says its development project will help fill a need for housing in an area that is experiencing rapid job and population growth.
But some Santa Clarita and Frazier Park residents believe the planned new town of Centennial will encounter many of the same obstacles that have delayed The Newhall Land and Farming Co.'s proposal to place 21,600 homes west of the I-5 in the Santa Clarita Valley.
This week Centennial Founders LLC, a joint venture company of landowner Tejon Ranch Co. and three home builders, asked the Los Angeles County Regional Planning Commission to consider changing the county's General Plan to accommodate its planned community of homes, businesses and public facilities.
Finding enough water for the residents the project would bring to the county's northern border over the next 25 years is high on the list of concerns to current residents, just as it is with Newhall Land's proposed Newhall Ranch development.
"Clearly, a lot of the questions will come out through the Environmental Impact Report process," said Greg Medeiros, Centennial Founders' vice president of community development.
He said the company is aware of the importance of water availability, and that the company is taking a multi-pronged approach to the issue.
Medeiros said recycled water and surface water will be sources, as will state water from the nearby California Aqueduct.
"We plan on banking water on site," he said. "It appears the basin has a surplus capacity that can be used on our site."
Several environmental organizations and Ventura County sued Newhall Land over Newhall Ranch, claiming there wasn't enough water to serve the estimated 70,000 people expected to move there, should the project be approved by the Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors. That approval has hit a series of delays because a state Supreme Court ruling said the environmental documents the project's water supplier, the Castaic Lake Water Agency, used was flawed.
CLWA won't serve Centennial, agency spokeswoman Mary Lou Cotton said.
Instead, the Antelope Valley-East Kern Water Agency would be the project's water supplier, should an adequate supply be proven, an agency official said.
Acknowledging the snags other developments have encountered, AVEK General Manager Russ Fuller said the agency isn't making any determinations about the water issue.
"We have not taken on the responsibility of providing water to whatever project comes along," Fuller said. "We don't make any claims for reliability."
Fuller said the onus falls on the state to prove there is enough water.
Lynne Plambeck, president of the Santa Clarita Organization for Planning the Environment, isn't so convinced.
"This project has the same issues as Newhall (Ranch) does," Plambeck said. "They are destroying prime agricultural land for urban sprawl."
The 270,000-acre Tejon Ranch has been home to cattle ranching since 1843.
Plambeck said Newhall Land's failure to adequately identify water sources should serve as a perfect reminder to Centennial.
"The leap-frog development isn't helping the water issue," she said.
Newhall Land spokeswoman Marlee Lauffer wouldn't comment on the Centennial project, but said Newhall Ranch is almost ready to move forward.
"As far as water is concerned, we have clearly identified where our water is coming from," Lauffer said.
The Centennial area is also known as a release station for the endangered and federally-protected California Condors, and that worries some environmentalists.
"They're introducing sprawl where it shouldn't be," said Mary Lockhart, conservation chair of the Kern Kaweah Sierra Club chapter.
Lockhart said Centennial is in the middle of the condor flying area.
"The idea isn't just to stop everything," Lockhart said. "All we ask is for (the project) to be done in an environmentally-sensitive way."
Several species of the once-believed extinct San Fernando Valley Spineflower were found on the Newhall Ranch site. The California Department of Fish and Game obtained a search warrant to look for evidence of destruction of the flower.
That investigation is still underway.
Lockhart said some of the same environmental issues that surface in the Newhall Ranch fight concern her.
"We need to stay on top of this," she said.
Medeiros said all ecological impacts will be brought to light in the environmental report, which isn't expected to be completed for several months.
He added since the area was grazed by cattle for more than 150 years, most of the vegetation isn't home to endangered species.
"It's void of biological significance," Medeiros said.
Centennial's 23,000 homes, apartments and condominiums will be on 6,000 acres, with the remaining 5,700 reserved as permanent open space. Medeiros said since the over size of the project is confined to several thousand acres, it's impact on surrounding habitat is minimal.
Not everyone is convinced, yet.
"This is the most critical time in this community in the past 50 years," said Lloyd Wiens, who moved from Glendale to Frazier Park 23 years ago because of its rustic and pastoral environment.
Wiens said the town formed a property owners association to serve as an information conduit concerning Centennial and other development and infrastructure projects.
"The most important thing we can do for Frazier Park is organize and plan our part of the community," he said.
Wiens didn't say he was strictly opposed to Centennial, just worried about its impact on Frazier Park, Gorman and the region's other small towns.
"We'd like to keep our rural atmosphere," he said. "If this development is going to impact our rural lifestyle, we need to be compensated."
Asked if he believed the new project would destroy Frazier Park, Wiens said, "It all depends on what the local community does here. Will it take the bull by the horns and rein in its own destiny?"
Ruth Ralph, who's late husband's family owned the town of Gorman and has lived in the area for 52 years, likes the project.
"I think it will be good for the town," she said.
Like Newhall Ranch, some of the residents are worried about traffic on the already crowded Interstate 5-Grapevine corridor.
Ten-year Frazier Park resident Jim Halfhill said the project's car traffic will devastate the region.
"It's a very chaotic situation," Halfhill said. "Most of the people that move up here want to get out of that environment. This is a community that has been here for 100 years and now has to face a developer."
Halfhill said he has been fighting the project for 4 years.
"We always knew they were going to develop. But the question was how far were they going to take it," he said.
Tejon company attorney Dennis Mullens dismissed rumors the company planned on installing an additional 100,000 homes in the Kern County portion of the ranch.
Mullens called the rumor, "a figment of their imaginations."
Instead, he said the company has looked at developing a few acres in Kern, but hasn't developed any plans. Mullens said one of the ideas is to build a resort area on Lake Tejon.
"It's just not true," he said.
