Mexican authorities arrested the suspect in the 2002 killing of Los Angeles County Sheriff's Deputy David March on Thursday, the U.S. embassy in Mexico City reported.
Agents of the Mexican Federal Investigation Agency apprehended Armando "Chato" Garcia, aka Jorge Arroyo Garcia, in the city of Tonala in western Jalisco state, according to an embassy statement.
A spokeswoman for the Mexico Attorney General's Office confirmed the arrest.
March, 33, of Saugus, was gunned down during what should have been a routine traffic stop in Irwindale on April 29, 2002. Garcia, a Mexican national, reportedly fled to his native Mexico within 24 hours after the slaying.
A host of government officials - from Rep. Howard "Buck" McKeon to Supervisor Michael D. Antonovich, Sheriff Lee Baca, District Attorney Steve Cooley and City Councilman Bob Kellar - pursued numerous avenues in the last four years to effect Garcia's arrest and extradition.
U.S. authorities will now have 60 days to file an extradition request, U.S. Ambassador Tony Garza said.
"The arrest today was the result of investigative persistence and close cooperative efforts between the United States Marshals Service and Mexico's Federal Investigative Agency," Garza said in a statement Thursday.
"Although the entire extradition process often takes more than six months to a year to complete, Arroyo Garcia is now off the streets and should remain in jail until he is returned to the United States," Garza said.
March's widow, Teri, was at a loss for words.
"For the first time in my life I am dumbfounded," she said. "I don't know what to say. At this point, I have had to put my faith in God, and God has just delivered."
Teri of Santa Clarita spent months and ultimately years lobbying to keep her husband's case on the front burner.
"I never stopped pushing the issue with all of the agencies because I knew it had to be reconciled," she said. "I'm anxious to see what closure might feel like."
Efforts in Washington stalled under a 2001 ruling by the Mexican Supreme Court that blocked the extradition of suspects who could face life in prison or the death penalty abroad. But the Mexican court partially backed down last year, ruling that suspects can be extradited if the maximum penalty is life - but not death.
Under California law, Garcia would face 25 years to life in prison - or the death penalty - if convicted of first-degree murder.
Los Angeles County District Attorney Steve Cooley could not be reached Thursday evening to say whether he would agree not to seek the death penalty.
"With the circumstances under which we were able to effect change under the law, we would be precluded from seeking the death penalty," said Kellar, who made the pursuit of justice in the March case a top priority during his 2004 mayoral term. "But on a personal level, I can tell you absolutely, you bet I would advocate for the death penalty for this guy. He killed a law enforcement officer ... but I don't believe that (the death penalty) is going to be in the cards."
In a statement, U.S. Rep. David Dreier, R-Glendora, said Garcia's arrest demonstrates the importance of maintaining an ongoing dialogue between the United States and Mexico.
"The capture of Armando Garcia is a victory for justice and, most important, for the March family," Dreier said. "Law enforcement on both sides of the border deserve tremendous credit for working together and staying on his trail for nearly four years."
