In their report Wednesday night, a group of community members committed to watching over the Hart district's Measure V funds called the Hart board legally incompliant for not turning over all of its information - a fact district officials disputed vehemently.
Everyone agreed on one thing: The William S. Hart Union High School District was spending all $158 million of the Measure V money the way the law was written. Nothing was wrong with that.
There was, however, much contention between board members and the Citizens Oversight Committee members over an interpretation of particular performance audit done by Moss-Adams LLP and whether or not the district was disclosing all of its findings.
The discrepancy over the matter revolved around more than $14 million that the Oversight Committee said was not accounted for in the report - money that district officials and Moss-Adams partner Curtiss Matthews said was included, though difficult to find in the language.
"The truth of the matter is, the audit report was poorly written," district chief operations officer Rob Gapper said. "If they audited all of it, they should have said it."
Those words were not in the report.
Still, Gapper stands by the fact that the audit included an accounting of all of the money, though Oversight Committee reports said otherwise.
This particular audit was actually a supplemental one, examining 32 items beyond 30 that had been sampled before, including more than $26 million of Measure V money spent last year.
Of that money, $12 million was clearly accounted for. The other $14 million was hidden from plain view - included in the text from the point of view of the school board, district employees and Moss-Adams representatives. It was not included from the Oversight Committee's point of view.
"You really don't know what the heck you're doing," committee chairwoman Renee Sabol said to the school board, to applause from audience members.
The report read: "The (district) was not in full compliance with all the bond fund requirements. The performance audit did not properly identify all Measure V Bond program expenditures for fiscal year 2005. It is the committee's opinion that the primary reason for this deficiency is the inadequate financial accounting systems of the district."
The district had been made aware of accounting problems in the past, with conflicting reports from different accounting firms.
The district recently paid for an independent forensic audit last year - later found not to be a true forensic audit - that was done by Colbi Technologies Inc.
Lettie Boggs, leader of that audit, told the district that their funds were "commingled."
In her interpretation, developer fees are only to be spent in the neighborhoods collected. Furthermore, the district needed to sort out which funds were spent on new construction and modernization projects.
The district spent approximately six months trying to get its books in order, proving they had spent the money appropriately, Gapper said.
But on Wednesday night when Moss-Adams gave its report, it said the completely opposite thing: That it was not necessary for the district to straighten out its developer fees, nor had they "commingled" their funds at all.
"We just spent $30,000 on this un-forensic audit and you're in disagreement," board member Gloria Mercado-Fortine told Moss-Adams representatives.
Furthermore, the board and the Oversight Committee were at odds of what the committee's job actually was.
When Sabol spoke up, she believed the committee was authorized by law and expected by the community to look over all of the funds - not just bits and pieces like what they saw they were handed.
Board members did not agree, saying instead that the committee's job was to make sure that the money was being spent properly and that they should not consider anything else.
"I am fully convinced that we are in compliance," board member Dennis King said.
