Congressman Howard "Buck" McKeon announced that he is supporting the use of alternative methods for measuring students' progress under the requirements of No Child Left Behind so that measurements would more accurately reflect progress.
As the ranking Republican on the House Education and Labor Committee, McKeon, R-Santa, listened to input from education experts at last week's committee hearing and said he supports implementing a change into NCLB's reauthorization, according to a news release.
First enacted in 2002, NCLB asks that states show that their students are making adequate yearly progress toward proficiency in math, reading and science. The goal is also to close academic achievement gaps among students of different socioeconomic groups and ensure that all students, regardless of background, reach grade level proficiency by 2014.
States currently track yearly progress by using a 'status model' that compares the performance of students in a specific grade against the performance of students of the same grade during the previous year.
But some are concerned about the reliability of the model and suggest using a 'growth model,' which compares the achievement of the same students over time.
"As NCLB has been implemented, it has become increasingly obvious that the way student achievement is measured currently does not begin to tell us whether the school is doing a good job or poor job teaching the students that come through its doors," Allan Olson, chief academic officer of Northwest Evaluation Association, said at the hearing.
As part of a pilot program, the state of Delaware has been using a growth model in addition to the existing status model to measure progress and has seen an improvement in the accuracy of measurements.
"Systems must focus on the performance of individual students and must provide schools with the appropriate incentives to address students' needs," said Valerie Woodruff, Delaware's secretary of education.
McKeon said that growth models can play an important role in the reauthorization of the bill.
"However, these growth models must be well-designed, they must be rigorous, and they must meet a number of criteria that are consistent and central to NCLB," he said.
Joan Lucid, assistant superintendent for instruction for the Saugus Union School District said that at McKeon's roundtable discussion in February, local educators brought up the problems with the current system for measuring student progress.
"When you measure student growth over time, you really determine how well your programs are working," Lucid said. "When you use a growth model, you actually are able to take a look at what individual students are doing over time and it allows you to then go back and target those individual students who aren't making quite the progress you want them to be making."
She said that changing methods of measurement is especially significant for special education students as well as English language learners because those children already start at a deficit.
"They're making growth year to year," she said. "But their growth may not be as quick as it will be for those children who come into school and already have the reading skills and have no disabilities. It's an entirely different group of children."
House Education and Labor subcommittees will hold a hearing on Thursday to discuss how NCLB affects students with disabilities.
