A concerned parent has raised questions as to whether violence and bullying is escalating in the Sulphur Springs Union School District after her son suffered a broken arm during a confrontation with a classmate last week.
Both boys, fifth-graders at Fair Oaks Elementary School, engaged in a fight Wednesday afternoon before one grabbed the other by the arm and pushed him into a ledge, breaking the boy's arm in two places, according to his mother, whose name is being withheld to protect her son's identity.
"They're treating this like it's nothing. Like it's just boys being boys," she said. "The problem is very real, but they don't want to admit they have a problem."
District officials declined to comment on disciplinary action taken against the students, citing student confidentiality policies.
"Usually anyone involved in a fight is suspended. But no information would be shared with a parent regarding another student," said Marianne Hamor, categorical programs administrator for the district. "That isn't something that would be divulged. Kids know if a student had been suspended or not."
District policy stresses a zero-tolerance approach to serious offenses in accordance with state and federal law and makes the "removal of potentially dangerous students from the classroom a top priority and ensures the standardized treatment of all students," according to district documents.
The mother insists her son had been bullied by his classmate for months and was punched in the stomach by him in March. Though both students antagonized one another during the altercation last week, she believes more disciplinary action should be taken and is upset that they remain in the same classroom.
"My son keeps saying, 'I hate school. It's so stressful,'" she said. "It's hard for a kid whose been bullied. A change should start with a zero-tolerance policy that they actually enforce."
Official results of a California Healthy Kids Survey - given to students in the district earlier this school year - will be released later this month and reflect the students' total health habits, including their safety from bullying.
"We have a strong discipline policy at each school. I really don't see an increase in any kind of bullying," said Tom Garvey, director of personnel and pupil services. "Over the years we've had several different assemblies and programs related to safety at school, treating each other positively and being friends."
In 2004, the district's Healthy Kids Survey showed 48 percent of students had been hit or pushed, and 3 percent had brought a gun or a knife to school - though 54 percent of the children who participated in the survey said they felt safe at the school all of the time.
"I feel our schools are very safe," Garvey said, "and I feel children come to school happy and go home happy.
