Amid acrimony and allegations of collusion between high-level city planning staff and a hospital consultant, City Council members indicated a plan to expand Henry Mayo Newhall Memorial Hospital may still need some serious revisions.
But the Tuesday night meeting's biggest bombshell may have been the revelation of multiple e-mails from February 2006 between high-level city planning officials overseeing the hospital's proposed master plan and Jeff Lambert, the city's former planning director and a consultant for Henry Mayo.
Councilman TimBen Boydston revealed the e-mails during the packed City Council meeting.
"It just seems like you're still working for him," Boydston said to Lisa Hardy, the city's planning director, and senior planner Fred Follstad, regarding correspondence with Lambert.
Boydston said he believes the e-mails show an effort to gain Henry Mayo favorable standing during a July 11, 2006, hearing, based on the anticipated absence or abstainment of two council members.
"July 11 is (City Council) hearing on the item," reads the e-mail released by Boydston. "(Then-Councilwoman) Marsha (McLean) is usually absent from this one. And if (Councilman) Bob (Kellar) doesn't vote, all they will need is two votes," reads the document.
"I see collusion in this regard with members of our planning department," Boydston said.
Hardy immediately denied any effort to acquire favorable scheduling for Henry Mayo and G & L Realty, the Beverly Hills-based developer that wants to build medical office buildings on the site. She said the tone of the message may have misled Boydston into perceiving an overly friendly relationship. She conceded that the correspondence was "not written in the most professional matter."
Henry Mayo's plan seeks an expansion from 332,992 to 660,355 square feet, an increase of nearly 330,000 square feet on the 30-acre campus.
Being sought is a trio of three-story medical office buildings at a combined 200,000 square feet and a five-story, 85-foot-high, 125,363-square-foot hospital building. Also being sought are four parking structures comprising several hundred thousand square feet.
Boydston and Councilwoman Lauren Weste suggested eliminating or scaling down proposed office buildings and parking structures, some of which would face McBean Parkway.
Kellar faulted Henry Mayo's board of directors for a perceived lack of previous planning.
"I think that had there been an effort in the past, land could have been" acquired for another facility in another portion of the Santa Clarita Valley, Kellar said, suggesting that Henry Mayo's board and city planners look into the possibility of opening a hospital at another site.
The council is expected to again take up Henry Mayo's master plan on June 26.
But much of the flurry at Tuesday night's meeting, which stretched into the early hours of Wednesday, was on the e-mails. Boydston's revelation prompted a burst of anger by Councilman Frank Ferry and a call for a recess by Weste.
City Manager Ken Pulskamp called the perceived scheduling fix for the hospital "a situation we wanted to avoid," as the plan could have been "possibly decided by as few as two (City Council) members."
"Any allegations of collusion are offensive and not accurate," Pulskamp said.
In a phone interview Wednesday, Hardy denied Boydston's claims.
"(Follstad) was acknowledging that, and making an observation, that a certain meeting would have a limited number of City Council members that would be making a decision on that item," Hardy said. "It is critical that we have the full City Council in attendance to be able to hear the issue."
Arnold Siegel, a law professor at Loyola Law School, said former high-level planning officials working with their former employees on behalf of private developers is not uncommon.
"If the perception is that the planning department is going to give this former director's clients less scrutiny or be preferential to him, that would be a problem," said Siegel, a former planning commissioner for the city of Pasadena. "But just because people know each other - this happens all the time."
"The one thing that I suppose we could be concerned about is that he has confidential information that he gained during his course of employment with the city that he could somehow use to the advantage of the developer," Siegel said.
Boydston said a member of the public asked him about the context of the e-mail exchange.
"People need to read the e-mail and make the decision for themselves," Boydston said on Wednesday.
Residents opposing the hospital expansion plan cited their dissatisfaction with the number and size of the office buildings proposed on the campus, as well as a lack of any timeline for constructing the proposed new hospital building.
"We have a timeline we can estimate, but the problem is that some are asking for a very specific timeline," hospital CEO Roger Seaver said on Wednesday. "But the problem is that in our industry, the uncertainty of planning, regulatory changes, financing and regulatory review doesn't allow" a specific timeline.
