It looks like the back-in parking experiment in Newhall is over.
After an outcry from residents, businesses and city leaders, the Santa Clarita City Council may back out of the idea at its Sept. 25 meeting.
"For the most part people are saying they don't like it and they won't come down here,'' said Suzie Szabo, manager of the Old Town Newhall Association.
The back-in parking idea was part of the Downtown Newhall Specific Plan that the City Council adopted in December 2005. The back-in parking, which totals roughly 160 spaces, is on San Fernando Road between Lyons Avenue and Fifth Street. It began in mid-June.
Like any good controversial issue, there are pros and cons.
The positives: The trunk is near the sidewalk and easy to load; an open car door blocks kids from running into the street, and there's no backing into traffic when pulling out of a parking space. The negatives: It's confusing and frustrating especially if drivers are tailgating and don't allow enough space for the driver to park.
On Thursday afternoon, Angelica Segura backed her Ford F-150 pickup truck into one of the spaces.
"It's harder for some people," said Segura, 32. "You are holding up the traffic. More accidents could happen."
She supports changing the spots to accommodate front-in parking.
Moule & Polyzoides Architects and Urbanists, based in Pasadena, came up with the Downtown Newhall Specific Plan, which included the back-in parking idea.
Back-in parking exists in cities including Salt Lake City, Chicago, Tucson, Washington, D.C., Seattle and Pottstown, Penn., said Chris Price, an assistant city engineer who works on the Newhall plan.
Councilman TimBen Boydston suggested eliminating the back-in parking last month.
"I don't think it is keeping people away from downtown Newhall, but there is a great deal of confusion when they get there," Boydston said.
Boydston is also the executive and artistic director for the Canyon Theatre Guild, which has a theater in downtown Newhall.
"We have had hundreds of people tell us they don't like it," he said.
Keep the angled parking, Boydston says, but change it to head-in parking. That change would stop car exhaust from spewing onto sidewalks and into businesses.
"It's not working so let's just get rid of it," Boydston said. "The city made a mistake. Let's change it and move on."
Councilman Bob Kellar agrees.
Kellar said he has received more than 100 negative comments from citizens about the back-in parking.
"Why wait a year?" Kellar says. "The community has spoken clearly about this."
Szabo, of the Old Town Newhall Association, says the response has been great.
"It's kind of a constant little drumbeat that they don't like it," Szabo said. "If the majority of people don't like it and don't seem to get it, why continue with it?''
Mike Pool, a salesman at the Newhall Paint Store at 24401 San Fernando Road, has a front row seat to the back-in parking, which he describes as "entertaining."
"We think it is hilarious," Pool said. "We think it is the best thing that has happened to this town."
He says he witnesses lots of stop sign running and finger pointing. Horn honking is a norm. People just aren't paying attention, he says.
"It's a ticket rich environment if the police department wants to come down here," Pool said.
The smart thing would be to change the parking to head-in parking, he said.
"The back-in angle just doesn't cut it," Pool said.
If the City Council decides to do away with the back-in parking, the change to head-in parking could be made by early October, Price said.
Pamela Relitz, manager of the Work Boot Warehouse at 24275 San Fernando Rd., estimates she has more than 100 signatures on a petition she has on the store's counter. She says she plans to attend the council meeting to urge city leaders to eliminate the back-in parking, which is cutting into the store's bottom line.
"My numbers are down," Relitz said. "I'm losing $400 a day, if not more."
