The search goes on.
If it were possible to take a pill, potion or powder to ensure your health, beauty and longevity, wouldn't you take it? This was the subject of a fun little film from years ago called "Death Becomes Her," which is unique in all cinema, I think, in that it included Meryl Streep doing a double-take in classic Yiddish Theater fashion. A nearly naked but extremely gorgeous and purported, nonagenarian Isabella Rossellini sells Meryl Streep a youth tonic, the other purchasers of which include a certain not-really-dead "King" (Who knew those tabloids were right?). After Streep quaffs the luminous substance, Rossellini tells her, "Now a warning" whereupon Streep gulps clumsily and shoots back "Now a warning?"
Without spoiling the plot for those who haven't yet seen it, the point of the movie was that life is fleeting, but we're better off for it, and aging is a natural process - blah, blah, blah.
On the other hand, civilization has, since time immemorial, searched for the Fountain of Youth, and exceedingly aged but perfectly healthy humans (or at least humanoids) have been a long-time staple of science fiction. Has science now caught up with fantasy? There are literally thousands of pills and potions that claim to restore health and vitality, making the old (or just middle aged) look and feel young again. The question is, are they useful tools, or just the latest version of snake oil?
Old, Healthy and Hungry
So far, the only way that science has demonstrated to truly increase lifespan - and health in those extra years - is by the use of the very low-calorie diet (about 800 calories per day, between one-half to one-fifth of the usual caloric intake of normal-weight Americans). According to Medical News Today (a Web site supported by Pfizer), in doctor-supervised controlled settings, where adequate amounts of nutrients are assured, these diets can increase your lifespan by a few years. (But you'll be hungry and miserable for those years.) Mice live longer if you restrict their caloric intake by 10 percent, according to the research. If you restrict their intake by 20 percent, they live even longer, and restrict them to 50 percent, they live longer still; but restrict their intake by 60 percent and they starve to death. So it's a trade-off. In the end, most people don't want to give up their favorite scrumptious foods forever.
Designer Supplements
Another promising avenue for life-extension is the substance resveratrol, derived from red wine. Experiments in animals have been successful, increasing lifespan in mice by 24 percent and in worms and flies by 54 percent. Biologist David Sinclair at Harvard is banking on the fact that it will work in humans, and has started a company, Sirtris Pharmaceuticals, on the strength of that research. Though there is zero evidence so far that it will work in humans (who admittedly differ in large degree from flies), it's one of the most popular supplements being sold at health food stores, and Sinclair puts his money where his mouth is: He takes it along with his whole family.
Homeopathy
Kim Wahl, of the Valencia Pharmacy Wellness Center, is an ardent proponent of alternative therapies, including supplements. Wahl, who lives in Sylmar but has been working at the Wellness Center since 1998, has practiced alternative therapies in her home for 20 years with her children, her husband and herself. She became interested in the subject after her daughter came down with a respiratory problem as a small child.
"My first-born daughter, Jessica, was an asthmatic," she said. "Mold was her trigger (that which brought on the asthma). She was really sick."
Wahl says she treated her "the Western way" for four years with no results. A co-worker suggested homeopathy (specifically a phosphorus preparation) and, according to Wahl, her daughter got better within four or five months.
"I matched her remedy to what her symptoms were," she said, using the homeopathic principle that "like cures like."
"Like cures like" is the philosophical underpinning of homeopathic theory. It means that a substance that will produce a disease-like reaction in a healthy person will cure the ailment in a sick one.
Wahl's formal training is through the National Center of Homeopathy's study group, which met in Pasadena for 12 years, and she has also taken a correspondence course with the British Institute of Homeopathy.
Skeptics
Dr. Lorraine Stern, of Valencia Pediatrics and the University of California at Los Angeles Medical School, is a skeptic, as are most M.D.s.
"There's just no scientific evidence for many of these things," she said.
Proponents and detractors explain this lack of evidence differently. Advocates of homeopathy and other alternative remedies say the reason they aren't proven in a way that Western scientists would accept is that the big drug companies won't put up the money for the experiments, After all, if cheaper remedies are available, they couldn't sell their expensive medicines. (Not surprising, of course, as drug companies are profit-driven entities.)
But government and university-based or private researchers have taken up the challenge, and the results have been mixed.
According to the University of California at Berkeley Wellness Letter, most studies of homeopathy have had negative results. One of the biggest problems with the studies undertaken by pro-homeopathy researchers is that few of them are well designed. A review in the prestigious British medical journal The Lancet concluded that of 110 placebo-controlled studies, the large well-designed trials almost always found that homeopathy worked no better than a placebo. What that means is that any benefit the subjects experience was due to the placebo effect.
And, The National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine (part of the National Institutes of Health) states that "the results of individual, controlled clinical trials of homeopathy have been contradictory ... systematic reviews have not found homeopathy to be a definitively proven treatment for any medical condition."
Indeed, according to the Wellness Letter, homeopathic solutions typically are diluted at least one million times: One molecule of "remedy" to more than one million, or even billion, water molecules. Scientifically, this means that most homeopathic remedies are effectively only water, or alcohol and water.
Acupuncture, Chiropractic, Vitamin Therapy
Another popular alternative therapy is acupuncture. While some insurance companies pay for it, and many more pay for chiropractic (including Medicare, up to 12 visits a year), the medical establishment remains skeptical of nearly all alternative therapies. Most will concede that a multivitamin a day "can't hurt," though they caution against taking more than the Recommended Daily Allowance. Most of the alternative-health-minded consume much more than that, at least of some nutrients. The medical wisdom with regard to that says this practice will gain you little more than "expensive urine," and many, including the Annals of Internal Medicine, cite the well-known Swedish study from the 1990's that found an (albeit slight) increase in heart disease in men taking high-dose vitamin E supplements. On the other hand, vitamin enthusiasts cite limitations of that study (which were acknowledged by medical sources too). Recently, the Council on Responsible Nutrition noted that a meta-analysis of 19 studies conducted by Johns Hopkins Medicine, that showed a slight increased mortality risk, was also flawed.
A Smorgasbord of Products
Wahl, like many in the alternative health movement, uses a varied selection of natural products, including grapefruit seed extract, which is claimed to have anti-viral, anti-bacterial and anti-fungal properties. She also uses (and the Valencia Pharmacy Wellness Center sells) flower essences, which are said to be able to help depression, among other things. Wahl even maintains that alternative remedies can help with disorders such as autism, which she claims can be a result of sensory overload in sensitive individuals.
Without putting too fine a point on it, Stern calls this "bunk." Nonetheless, adherents are totally convinced that their choices are health-promoting.
"My daughter is now 19 years old," said Wahl, "and she's never had an antibiotic or an over-the-counter medicine. She's totally holistic."
In addition to a multi-vitamin, Jessica Wahl, who lives at home with her parents in Sylmar, takes trace minerals and homeopathic and herbal remedies. The Wahls also use pro-biotics (capsules that contain the cultures in yogurt), digestive enzymes and raw, rather than pasteurized, foods.
"Part of what I do is education," said Kim Wahl. "The key is to have a tool in the house. There aren't a lot of people who are educated in these matters. People can take control of their health and change their lives."
Looking Ahead
What's the future for alternative medicine? According to a study by the National Center for Biological Information, part of the National Institutes of Health, in 1990 Americans made an estimated 425 million visits to providers of unconventional therapy, which includes acupuncturists and chiropractors as well as purveyors of herbs and other supplements. These visits exceed the number of visits to all United States primary care physicians at that time (388 million). In the early 1990's, the last time the government gathered such data, consumers spent approximately $10 billion on alternative therapies, an amount comparable to the $12.8 billion they had spent out of pocket annually for all U.S. hospitalizations. The figures are estimated to be much higher now.
Brave New World
In the more-distant future, scientists are predicting the widespread use of nano-engineered biological/robot hybrids to help with diverse kinds of health problems. For instance, blood-borne devices, built molecule by molecule, will be able to deliver precise amounts of various substances, like insulin or other hormones, where they're needed in the body. "Nano" means extremely small - a thousand-millionth of a unit to be exact - and these biological/machine devices, along with other advances like gene therapy, could allow Americans to regularly reach ages of 125 or more, say their advocates.
Ponce de Leon thought the Fountain of Youth was in Florida. It may well be, but de Leon never found it, and his quest ended in death by Indians. His dream, though, of a long disease-free life persists in labs from Washington D.C. and Cambridge, Massachusetts to home-town stores in the Santa Clarita Valley.
Valencia Pharmacy 23550 Lyons Ave. Suite. 111, Santa Clarita, CA 91321 (661) 255-7910 www.valenciapharmacy.com.
