Though the county district attorney's office found that a meeting at a restaurant attended by three Hart district board members violated the state's open meeting law, no further action is being taken and a school official said Wednesday more attention will be paid to detail in the future.
No disciplinary action is being taken because no evidence was found that the violation was intentional, according to Assistant Head Deputy Jennifer Lentz Snyder, who is in charge of all Brown Act issues that come to the district attorney's office.
"I looked at all the evidence we could gather on this case, and I found the presence of three members of the board at the IHOP to be a violation," Snyder said Wednesday.
"It does happen, and I think it happens for the most part out of ignorance of the law and its requirements, as opposed to any nefarious intention to violate the law."
According to a letter sent from District Attorney Steve Cooley to the William S. Hart Union High School District governing board Aug. 29, a group of community members including Karyn Malchus, set up a Feb. 13 meeting at the IHOP restaurant in Stevenson Ranch to discuss concerns related to overcrowding at West Ranch High School. Board members Dennis King and Paul Strickland were scheduled to participate.
King, Strickland, board member Gloria Mercado-Fortine and district Superintendent Jaime Castellanos attended the meeting. Because the three members who attended were a majority of the five board members, the gathering constituted a "meeting" according to the rules of the Brown Act and should have been widely publicized.
Castellanos said that even though the Hart district attorney had reviewed the case and determined that there was no violation, the district attorney's office found that a violation had occurred.
"They determined that since we had three board members present, that even though one did not participate, the fact that we had a third person in a public forum constituted a violation of the Brown Act," Castellanos said.
The fact that one of the three board members attended the meeting as an "observer" did not negate the presence of a quorum of the board at the IHOP meeting, Snyder said.
"Even if they're not there to have a meeting, if you're going to have a majority number of the board at a location discussing topics related to board business, the public needs to know about it," she said.
"If they're getting information, then that affects their decision-making and the public needs to be there. It's about transparency."
While notice of the IHOP meeting was provided informally by e-mail, phone and word-of-mouth, the Brown Act requires that meetings be "well-publicized" with public postings or other means of broad, public notification, according to the letter to the board.
"We therefore conclude that the attendance of a majority of the Board at the IHOP meeting constituted a violation of the Brown Act because the IHOP meeting, which was organized and sponsored by community members, was not a publicized meeting, within the letter and spirit of the Brown Act," the letter stated.
The Hart board has reviewed the findings of the District Attorney and will make sure that no more than two board members are present at meetings of this kind in the future, Castellanos said.
"We've learned our lesson and we'll move on from here and make sure that it doesn't happen again," he said.
