Formal proceedings have begun in the case of a 10-year-old boy who reportedly confessed to starting the Buckweed Fire, which blackened more than 38,000 acres in the Santa Clarita Valley and burned down 21 homes.
Deputy District Attorney David Evans in Lancaster confirmed Wednesday that investigators with the Palmdale Sheriff’s Station had submitted a case to him regarding the boy.
Evans said he was prohibited by law from discussing the case further.
Steve Whitmore, a spokesman for the Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Department, said the case was turned over to sheriff’s detectives in Palmdale since they were the ones who responded to the initial report of a fire Oct. 21.
“(The boy) told us he was playing with matches and accidentally set the fire,” Whitmore said.
The boy and his mother, wife of a caretaker who works at Carousel Ranch, are no longer at the ranch, said Carousel Ranch Executive Director Denise Tomey. The caretaker still lives at the ranch.
“He’s the child of someone who lives here, the child of a tenant. The child is no longer living at the ranch,” Tomey said. “We asked the boy to leave.”
“There’s been a lot of misinformation,” she added. “Some people are saying he was a Carousel child, and that’s not true.”
The boy is believed to be with his mother, she said.
Carousel Ranch provides therapy for more than 90 handicapped children through specialized interaction with horses.
The fire began at 12:45 p.m. on Oct. 21, when the ranch was closed and only one volunteer staffer was inside the ranch building working at a computer, Tomey said.
The origin of the fire was about 30 feet outside the Carousel property, Tomey said.
The lone volunteer worker noticed the fire and phoned 911 immediately, she said, calling the blaze and the boy’s alleged involvement “a terrible situation.”
“He was never arrested,” Tomey said. “He was spoken to and put in the care of his parents. We, as a committee, asked that he not reside on the ranch.”
The Buckweed Fire forced the evacuation of homes in the Bouquet Canyon Road area on the afternoon of Oct. 21 and, later that evening, homes in the neighborhood of Whites Canyon Road were also evacuated.
Five people were injured in the blaze that kept hundreds of firefighters busy for three intense days, and for the remainder of the week mopping up. One of those hurt suffered second- and third-degree burns trying to protect his property.
Sandy Gibbons, spokeswoman for the Los Angeles County District Attorney’s office, said she received information from Evans late Wednesday afternoon.
“We are not going to make a decision on this case today,” Gibbons said.
Evans was asked to explain, in general terms, the legal process of young children implicated in serious crimes, such as arson.
“I have bad news for you. Everything that happens to a juvenile is pretty much confidential,” he said, prefacing his explanation.
“It’s not criminal, it’s a civil action,” he said about the usual process investigators follow with regards to juveniles suspected of committing crimes. “They file a petition to make that child a ward of the court.”
Ron Smalstig is a deputy District Attorney at Sylmar Juvenile Court. He handles about 4,000 cases a year involving children implicated in crimes.
“There is no minimum age a child can be charged,” he said, explaining the process. “If they are under 14 they have to prove they know right from wrong and that they knew at the time of the act that it was wrong.”
Smalstig said the youngest child he recalls being prosecuted was an 8-year-old implicated in a gang robbery.
“This kid was fairly sophisticated for an 8-year-old,” he said. “One of the big things we hear from a lot of kids is, ‘I know it’s wrong now.’”
In the case of the boy suspected of starting the Buckweed Fire, a district attorney wishing to proceed with a court case issues the child with a juvenile citation.
“It’s not like being arrested, it’s like a traffic ticket,” he said, describing it as a promise to appear in court on a set day.
Between the date the citation is issued and the day he appears in court, investigators and lawyers with the district attorney’s office normally meet to discuss the case.
“In that interim, they present their case to us and we assess legal sufficiency to see if there is sufficient evidence to believe the (accused) is legally responsible,” Smalstig said.
If the district attorney believes the child knows right from wrong, then he will normally file a juvenile petition against him.
