Defense attorneys plan to appeal the convictions of Michael Lugo and Cynthia Brandon, the mother and son who were convicted last week of burglarizing a Canyon Country home in 2006, citing issues with the judge, jury and evidence involved in the case.
Brandon’s attorney, Ray Fountain, said that he intends to file a notice of intent to appeal when the pair are sentenced Feb. 29 in San Fernando Superior Court. Though the filing will not enumerate specific grounds for appeal, Fountain said that there are numerous weak areas in the case that attorneys could argue justify the reversal or nullification of the verdict.
Lugo, 30, was convicted Dec. 12 of two counts of burglary, one count of receipt of stolen property and one count of conspiracy. He was tried simultaneously with his mother, Brandon, 52, who was convicted of one count of burglary and one count each of receipt of stolen property and conspiracy.
The convictions were connected to an incident on Canvas Street on Oct. 18, 2006, during which Lugo was shot by homeowner Nadine Teter after he tried to enter her front door. Reportedly fearing he was trying to break into her house, she confronted him after he scaled a wall and entered her backyard, shooting him three times with a .38 caliber pistol.
After being wounded in the leg and abdomen, Lugo fled to the street, where his mother was waiting in a car filled with stolen property. The two sped off and flagged down Sheriff’s deputies in order to get help with Lugo’s injuries, but deputies quickly connected them to the incident at Teter’s house and arrested them on suspicion of burglary.
Lugo was charged with two counts of burglary after his fingerprints connected him to a break-in at another house in the area.
The central argument in the prosecution’s case, that Lugo was trying to break into Teter’s house at the time of the shooting, was disputed by the defense on the grounds that the screen door he opened was not actually locked.
Fountain said that according to a recent ruling by the state Supreme Court, a person is considered to have committed burglary if they pry or otherwise force open a locked screen door. Maintaining that Teter’s screen door was not in fact locked and that Lugo was able to easily open it, Fountain asked for a special instruction regarding the ruling to be given to the jury, thinking that it would lead to his client’s exoneration.
However, the jury voted to convict anyway, choosing to believe two other pieces of testimony.
“Photos introduced into evidence showed it was in perfect condition,” Fountain said, referring to his assertion that the door showed no evidence of having been forced or pried. “Despite this, the jury still decided that the door was in fact locked.”
Teter maintained that she locked the door, and a Sheriff’s deputy testified that if someone were to yank hard enough on a locked screen door, it could still be opened.
Michael Lugo’s older sister, who asked that her name not be used, told the Signal that she did not feel the facts and evidence supported the theory that Lugo was trying to break into Teter’s house.
“I do not believe he was trying to rob that lady,” she said. “The jury said they convicted him on the basis of the locked screen door, which was not technically locked. Michael opened an aluminum screen door and knocked. That is not a crime.”
Lugo’s sister said her brother was actually in the neighborhood that day to pick up money from a friend, which corresponds to what Lugo told Sheriff’s deputies at the time of his arrest.
However, deputies did not believe Lugo’s story, and testified that they believed he was actually casing the neighborhood, knocking on doors to find out which houses were empty so he could rob them.
Lugo’s sister further alleges that forensic evidence and her brother’s conduct at the time of the shooting points to the fact that he did not have malicious intent.
“Nadine said he was coming at her, but he stopped moving forward when he saw the gun,” she said. “He was 30 feet away from Nadine and she looked at him, he looked at her, and he raised his hands and said ‘Don’t shoot me.’”
She added that a forensic expert testified that if Lugo, who was unarmed, had been coming at Teter when he was shot, the bullet would have punctured his liver, colon, gall bladder, and spleen and come out the other side of his body.
What may be stronger grounds for appeal is the alleged bias of Judge Harvey Giss and some questionable actions of the jury, both of which Nancy Pogue, Lugo’s attorney, objected to, according to Lugo’s sister.
“During the trial, the judge would roll his eyes, nod his head and sigh when evidence was being presented for Michael and Cynthia’s defense,” she said. “He always seemed disdainful. How could that not have prejudiced the jury?”
She added that at one point Pogue asked to go on the record as saying that she felt the proceedings were unfair, and that she had never been in a courtroom that had felt so one-sided against the defense.
Pogue declined to comment, citing the fact that the case is ongoing and sentencing has not occurred yet.
Another concern was the alleged misconduct of one of the jurors. Lugo’s sister said that a spectator to the court proceedings was seen having lunch with one of the jurors during a break. This was brought to the court’s attention, and the man eventually identified himself as juror number four’s father.
Fearing that the man would have shared possibly prejudicial details of courtroom activity that transpired when jurors were not allowed to be present, Pogue asked for the jurors to be dismissed. However, Judge Giss ruled they could stay and that he did not feel it was not grounds for a mistrial.
Though Lugo’s sister does not dispute that there was enough evidence to convict her brother of the second burglary count related to the nearby house, she does not think there was enough evidence to convict either her mother or brother of burglarizing Teter’s house.
“I believe you have to pay for the crimes you commit, I am not disputing that,” she said. “But my brother and mother did not commit burglary in this case, yet they were convicted of it.
“My mother never left the car at any time during the incident, yet she was convicted of burglary,” she said. “I cannot understand that, because she was not trying to break into the house.”
Though 31 items of stolen property were found in Brandon’s vehicle, Lugo’s sister said that was the only connection her mother had to the items. Some of the items were determined to be from the other house that Lugo had burglarized, which led to his conviction on the second burglary count, but Lugo’s sister said that none of the items had her mother’s fingerprints on them.
Fountain said that under the law, a person does not have to actually break into a house to be convicted of burglary. Aiding or abetting a burglar is also considered to be a form of burglary.
“The getaway person is considered an aider and abettor, and the jury believed Brandon was the getaway driver with full knowledge of the burglary,” Fountain said.
Lugo’s sister feels the fact her mother and brother were tried together was prejudicial to her mother.
“They should have had separate trials,” she said. “Most of the case was about my brother. Maybe they were tarring my mother with the same brush.”
She is hopeful that an appeal or new trial will exonerate her family members, for whom she said the whole process had been extremely stressful.
“The judge seemed to have already made up his mind,” she said. “With a different judge and jury the outcome might have been different.”
