On The Signal’s Web site this week, I was interested to see a reader poll which hit very close to home. The poll asked readers to identify what they believe to be the biggest issue facing California public schools. I read over the options, and the only response I could wholeheartedly muster was “other.” I believe that the struggles the schools face are much more serious than indicated by the options available in the poll, and I don’t believe I am alone in my thinking.
The available options were: high college tuition, low spending per pupil, high dropout rates, lack of alternative education or vocational programs, liberal sex-ed policies, “teaching to the test” and my personal selection, “other.” The fact is, teaching children is difficult and complicated. There is no single school policy that will fix the problems. But as a mother of four, and a citizen and taxpayer deeply concerned with the future of our nation, I urge parents to sit up and take notice. The poll’s answer options don’t reflect the real issues at all.
The first option, high college tuition, is a concern for the students and their parents, not the schools. The schools don’t pay for it! I’m not sure why The Signal included that option.
Low spending per pupil? You’ve got to be kidding me. Published reports indicate that per-pupil spending in 2003-2004 in California ranged from $4,806 to $34,279, and Gov. Schwarzenegger’s goal for 2007 was $11,000 per pupil. This amounts to $330,000 in spending for one class of 30 for one year. I’m sure the teacher isn’t getting much of that — I have many friends who are dedicated public school teachers, and none of them drives a Mercedes. I teach my own children, and I spend about $2,000 total for all four of my children for curriculum and extra classes. If you add in a family computer, that might be $4,000, or $1,000 per pupil, and frankly, it can be done for much less, especially with all of the free lessons available on the Internet. How do you explain away the rest of that money? Published reports also indicate that schools that spend more money per pupil do not necessarily increase their graduation rates. More money is not the answer.
With the third option, “high dropout rates,” The Signal gives a glimpse of the problem, but dropout rates are only a symptom of the deadly disease. Analyzing the dropout rate is merely performing a post-mortem on a cadaver that died many years before.
A lack of alternative education programs is certainly an issue, but providing them won’t fix all the schools, and mapping the unique talents of each individual into a few vocational programs is difficult. Sex-ed policies that teach the facts but leave out the deeper issues of building relationships, real intimacy and the rewards of a lifetime of faithfulness are bothersome indeed.
Spending inordinate amounts of classroom time in order to artificially boost scores on an arbitrary test is definitely not improving education, especially when edu-crats change tests every few years so that true progress cannot really be measured over time. These, again, are symptoms, but attempting a diagnosis for a patient with so many symptoms of illness is difficult, isn’t it?
I submit that spiritual and ethical bankruptcy in the home is the disease, and the schools are merely reaping what parents have sown. When parents released responsibility for the raising of their children to the schools, to the television and to the Internet, we began the decline into a society prone to apathy and pleasure-seeking.
What difference will it make if schools are well-funded when parents don’t even interact with their children? According to my friends who teach, many children in the schools today are simply non-verbal — they don’t know how to carry on a conversation, ask questions or explain their feelings because the parents simply do not speak with them.
Textbooks are increasingly filled with errors because the textbook industry is a guaranteed cash cow for publishers, and parents are too busy working to finance their lifestyle to hold anyone accountable.
Teachers are the victims as well, entering into a profession which demands more and pays less than any other I know of. How can they implement loving discipline in a classroom when there is none at home? How can they teach “Just Say No” to drugs and alcohol effectively when such substances are abused regularly at home? How can teachers expect respect when parents model rudeness? How can children learn the satisfaction of delayed gratification when parents refuse to sacrifice their expensive lifestyle so that kids don’t have to be home alone at the end of their day? How can teachers educate the children in matters of character when morality is not a priority in the home? How can parents expect good behavior from a child when their own heart is in darkness?
Parents, do you want to improve your child’s school? Admit that you’ve messed up, then make some sacrifices, quit chasing the money train, throw out the substances and the porn, turn off the TV and the Internet, be faithful to your spouses and your families, clean up your act, take responsibility for the children you’ve brought into the world and seek some spiritual guidance for your life. Parenting may be the most challenging thing a human being can attempt. It will take everything you have to give and more. You may have to work hard to change yourself. Take heart, though. There is help available for the asking. And the legacy you leave in the lives of your children will be priceless.
Bonnie Traylor is a Canyon Country resident, mother of four and advocate of quality education. Her column reflects her own views, not necessarily that of The Signal.
