It was a bright Sunday morning when Joey Mendez stepped up to the plate at Crosley Field.
A full stadium watched from all angles. The old buildings in the distance looked much like they did decades ago when the Cincinnati Reds called the field their home.
Only at a Big League Dreams sports park could the 9-year-old from Saugus play on the replica of such a historic Major League Baseball field.
Joey and his family had to travel to Chino Hills to play on Crosley Field, but if plans continue to progress in the coming years, the city of Santa Clarita could eventually have a Crosley Field or Fenway Park or Yankee Stadium as well.
The Chino Hills sports park is one of seven Big League Dreams sports parks currently operating in the western United States. Two more are set to open within the next 60 days and three, including one in Oxnard, will likely be under construction by the end of 2008.
The parks have an average of six baseball or softball stadiums designed as scaled-down replicas of historic baseball fields with the walls painted to resemble real buildings behind the stadium. The parks have other amenities that include restaurants, indoor soccer fields, batting cages and sand volleyball courts. The restaurants serve alcohol, but the new parks will not be allowed to serve alcohol during youth sporting events.
Each Big League Dreams park is operated through a public-private partnership. Municipal governments build the facilities, while Chino Hills-based Big League Dreams maintains and operates the parks. The two share the revenue.
After initially consulting with Big League Dreams, the cities or counties hire their own design firms, and Big League Dreams provides plans from its existing parks. The municipalities then go to bid and hire a contractor to construct the facility.
Within the next four to six months, the city of Santa Clarita is expected to have the results of two studies currently under way that will help determine both the scope and feasibility of such a project within Santa Clarita.
The City Council in October approved spending up to $90,000 to consult with Big League Dreams Consulting LLC to select a site and conceptualize the size and amenities of the park. The consulting company will also advise the city on the financial forecast that includes five-year and 40-year income and expense estimates, according to the contract.
The city also recently selected an independent consultant to look at the demand for sports fields in Santa Clarita and will determine whether the project makes sense economically for Santa Clarita, said Rick Gould, the city's director of Parks, Recreation and Community Services.
In its 2007-08 budget, the city set aside $850,000 to move forward on building a Big League Dreams park. While the majority of that money has not yet been allocated for anything specific, a portion of it will go toward paying the third-party consultant, according to Elena Galvez, management analyst with the city.
If Santa Clarita moves forward with building the park, the facility would be similar to the six-stadium Chino Hills park, Gould said.
The park would help the city lessen its parkland deficit of 600 acres, city documents show.
Some of the cities that have built Big League Dreams sports parks, however, have encountered significant cost overruns throughout the construction process.
A $40 million Big League Dreams sports park is set to open on Jan. 12 in Gilbert, Ariz., and while the eight-stadium park is already booked through 2008, the town is suffering from a price tag that totaled about $17 million more than originally planned.
The town had put out a number of requests for proposals for a public-private partnership for a sports park and requested budgets from each company, including Big League Dreams.
Big League Dreams had estimated that the project would cost the town about $23 million, according to Greg Svelund, spokesman for the town of Gilbert. Throughout the construction process, the town made a number of changes to the project, including extra work on adjacent roadways and additional connections to nearby trails. Those upgrades totaled about $5 million, Svelund said.
As for the remaining $12 million in unexpected costs, Svelund said, "There's no doubt that ... this is millions and millions of dollars higher than what we expected."
"There were some pretty significant cost increases in the construction industry that happened from the time we initially got the estimate and two and a half years later when the price actually had to come together to build it."
The original estimate also did not include taxes and the cost of bonds.
"There was no bonding and taxes included in the original estimate, and when you're talking about that much money, that's a couple million just in the bonds and taxes," he said.
Other details were left out of the original budget, including furniture and other equipment necessary to run the on-site restaurants, he said.
Other cities, including West Covina and Chino Hills, also went over what was originally budgeted in building their Big League Dreams parks.
By the time its park opened in 2002, the city of Chino Hills had paid a total of $16.5 million, about $3 million more than was originally planned to build a six-stadium park.
City Manager Doug LaBelle said Friday he attributed the cost overruns to problems the city encountered with the contractor and design firms, factors not connected with Big League Dreams, he said.
Pat Kight, a consultant for Big League Dreams who works with cities in developing their parks, attributed the high price tags to rising construction costs. He said that whether or not Santa Clarita experiences cost overruns depends on the city's ability to bring a project in on time and under budget.
"Santa Clarita has done a really good job at managing their projects so I would expect they'll be pretty darn close," Kight said.
Gould said the city of Santa Clarita typically bids on whole projects, as opposed to the process in Gilbert, Ariz., that allowed the town to keep upgrading the project along the way.
He said there is also a possibility the city could come in under budget.
"Anything can happen," he said. "Predicting the future is very, very difficult. ... Our goal is to design a project, know the cost up front before we go to bid and we'll bid that project and build that project."
Kight said the revenue Santa Clarita would get from the park depends on the size of the park and a variety of other factors that have yet to be decided.
Much of the revenue comes from restaurants, admission fees and advertising banners throughout the stadiums. In 2006, cities were getting an average of $500,000 in revenue a year, he said. During the first two years, Kight said, Big League Dreams usually has a negative cash flow.
Chino Hills receives about $1 million a year from its 30-acre park, and LaBelle said the park has met all of the city's expectations.
"We built it hoping it would be the success that it is," LaBelle said, adding that the park has boosted the local economy.
When there's a tournament, kids travel to Chino Hills from out of state, said Chris Simonson, general manager of the Chino Hills Big League Dreams park.
About 380 adult softball teams play at the park each week. The park runs local youth leagues from February through June and has "a pretty extensive waiting list" for a spot on a youth league, Simonson said.
"This is pretty much the premier park in Southern California to play at. No one else is really doing what we're doing in regards to the replica fields," he said. "Kids can say, 'I hit a home run at Wrigley Field.'"
Parents of the youth baseball players at the Chino Hills park agreed.
"The lights are good, outfields are good, there's open space in between fields and there are places for the kids to warm up," said Laguna Niguel resident Doug Thompson as his 12-year-old son, Andrew, played on the Fenway Park field.
"We've played all over the place and these are the best parks," said Mike Zill of San Clemente, whose 12-year-old son has been playing on Big League Dreams fields for three years with his traveling baseball team. "Kids love to play here because it's perfectly maintained. They have good umpires here and it's just a good venue all the way around."
He said the public-private partnership allows cities to build parks that surpass the quality of any municipal park.
"Everybody in government thinks they can do it just as good without the profit," he said. "But the profit motive keeps the things nice."
Santa Clarita City Councilman TimBen Boydston was the lone dissenter when the council voted to allow the city to begin conceptualizing a park.
Boydston said Thursday that he thinks Santa Clarita should avoid a partnership with a private company.
He criticized the city for not conducting the independent analysis prior to paying Big League Dreams to conceptualize the park.
"They committed that money without having any kind of feasibility study," Boydston said of his colleagues. "For something of this magnitude, it is very surprising to me that they did not do their due diligence before they started spending the taxpayers' money and giving it to this company."
He suggested the city build its own regional sports park.
"My ideal alternative is if the city wants to build a park, well, let's just do it ourselves where we have control," he said. "We're a good city, we're a tight ship, we know how to build parks and I think that we could build our own complex."
Gould said, however, that the critics should take a closer look at what the partnership could bring to the city and understand the private operator is operating a public park and returning revenue.
"They're more efficient than we are," he said.
