Signal Staff Writers
As Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger unveiled his 2008 State Budget Proposal Thursday, there was criticism about whether the proposed cuts will help get the budget back on track.
Among the biggest issues of the $141 billion budget are slashes of $4 billion in education and $1 billion in Medi-Cal aid, plus an early release of 22,000 state inmates over the next two years.
“I am singularly unimpressed with the governor’s proposal,” said State Sen. Tom McClintock. “First and foremost, the gap is not being closed just with cuts.”
McClintock, R-Thousand Oaks, who represents part of the Santa Clarita Valley, said equal cuts across the board makes a high priority budget item just as important as a low priority budget item.
“The notion of equal spending cuts is the most stupid possible way of making cuts,” he said. “It is a complete abandonment of government responsibility to prioritize need and to live within its budget.”
State Sen. George Runner said the budget cuts do not take into account that some issues have greater priority over others, therefore an across the board cut does not make sense.
“I disagree with the idea that everything has to be 10 percent across the board,” said Runner, R-Santa Clarita. “It just assumes everything is the same. I think we need to find the money in other places.”
Crime was pointed out as one such high-priority budget item.
Schwarzenegger’s proposal would allow for the release of prisoners with fewer than 20 months remaining on their sentences and determined to be “low risk.” Prisoners serving sentences on nonviolent, non-sex offender crimes would be eligible for early release.
By releasing certain prisoners early, the state would save on housing inmates and guards. State officials anticipate that an unknown number of prison guards will be laid off, as well.
“There has to be a better way to achieve the budget correction than an early release of prisoners,” said Assemblyman Cameron Smyth, R-Santa Clarita.
McClintock agreed, saying that Schwarzenegger could have avoided the early release program by cutting certain expenses in the prison budget without releasing inmates. McClintock said inmates in state prison costs Californians $42,000 per inmate per year. Comparatively, he pointed out that Florida spends $18,000 per state prisoner per year, while the federal government spends $26,000 per year on each inmate in its system.
He added that Schwarzenegger could have cut the cost per prisoner to $19,000 per year if he contracted out prison beds to a private company, as done in several other states. If Schwarzenegger had moved forward with the plan, he may have saved taxpayers $23,000 per prisoner per year, or $1 billion in total savings each year.
“He had the opportunity to save money without releasing a single prisoner and he did not do it,” McClintock said.
Runner echoed similar sentiments, stating that protecting California’s communities should be a top priority in the budget.
“If he responded to what we told him over the past two years about overspending, we wouldn’t have to take such draconian measures right now,” Runner said. “It’s hard because we didn’t do what we should’ve done for the past two years.”
Smyth, on the other hand, is a little more optimistic about dealing with the budget crisis.
“It’s the first introduction,” Smyth said. “Now that we have the governor’s proposal, the legislature will work together and I hope we put partisanship aside to come to a resolution.”
Rep. Howard “Buck” McKeon, R-Santa Clarita, was traveling to Washington, D.C., and was not available for comment.
Local educators were disappointed by the governor’s proposal to cut more than $4 billion in education funds, but tried to be optimistic.
“At this point, it’s just the governor’s proposal and it’s got a long way to go before it becomes a reality,” said Marc Winger, superintendent of the Newhall School District. “But the truth is, we have a huge state budget deficit, and K-12 education takes up about half of the state budget. So there’s no way we’re going to escape this, but the cuts the governor proposed are way more than the education community expected to see.”
The governor’s budget proposal provides $68.5 billion for K-12 education priorities, which will preserve all core instructional program funding at a slightly lower level.
While Winger acknowledged that the final state budget has yet to be negotiated, he predicts that the outcome “is not going to be good.
“In the meantime, we have to come up with a balanced district budget by June 30, so we’re going to have to make some cuts,” Winger said.
Saugus High School Principal Bill Bolde was disappointed when he heard about the governor’s proposed cuts.
“It’s always bad news when money is cut from education, because the very basis of our future is our kids,” Bolde said. “California is taking a step backwards as far as providing revenue to support our kids, and I hate to see that.”
Bolde said that the Association of California School Administrators is working with lobbyists in Sacramento to get the voice of school administrators to the governor, with the hope that negotiations to the budget can be made.
Thursday afternoon, the chancellor’s office at College of the Canyons was working to determine how the proposed budget would affect community colleges, and whether the budget actually increased or decreased higher education funding, according to college spokeswoman Sue Bozman.
The governor’s budget proposal provides $21.7 billion for Higher Education priorities, an increase of $1.6 billion above the revised 2007-08 budget, “but we don’t know what they mean by revised,” Bozman said.
