It’s been amusing to read the complaints from opponents of Newhall Ranch about the lack of public hearings and opportunities for public participation. Not only do they personally dislike the future new community, but they find great fault with the process in which Los Angeles County undertakes public review of new developments.
To read Lynne Plambeck’s comments in her editorial in The Signal (Friday, Jan. 11, 2008), one would think that Newhall Ranch itself, as well as its first neighborhood of Landmark Village, had little public involvement and that she and others were somehow prevented from advocating their point of view.
Since I attended a few of the countless public hearings on both Newhall Ranch and Landmark Village that have been taking place for more that a decade, I know this is not the truth.
For example, in the case of Landmark Village the Draft Environmental Impact Report (EIR) was released for public review in November 2006.
The Los Angeles County Regional Planning Commission at its first public hearing on Landmark in January 2007 granted additional time for the public to review the EIR until Feb. 20, 2007. This additional time was granted at the request of the no-growth activists who indicated to the commission that they needed more time to review the EIR.
At its January 2007 meeting, the Regional Planning group took extensive public testimony from Lynne and this group and continued the public hearing to its Feb. 28, 2007 meeting.
The commission directed staff and the applicant to respond to the issues raised by them at the January meeting.
Both staff and the applicant responded to all of the issues raised by this group in writing as part of the staff report for the commissions Feb. 28, 2007 meeting.
The commission again took testimony from the public (primarily from Lynne and her friends) and again heard many of the same issues raised at the commission’s January meeting. The commission then closed the public hearing and directed Newhall Land to revise the project (partly to address issues cited by Lynne) and staff to prepare the final EIR for the commission’s consideration. The project was revised and a final EIR was prepared and forwarded to all of the commenters (again, primarily this small group of activists) and scheduled for the commission meeting of Dec. 22, 2007.
Remember the commission closed the hearing at its meeting in February (the activists were aware of that). County Supervisor Mike Antonovich, based upon a request from Lynne, then moved the item to the commission’s meeting of Jan. 9, 2008.
Even though the public hearing before the commission was closed, the commission elected to hear testimony from the activist group.
The commission asked county planners whether this testimony was new and significant as to delay the commission taking action on Landmark Village. County planners responded that this information was not new and had been addressed by the final EIR.
Now Landmark Village, the first phase of a fully reviewed, litigated and settled (by Lynne Plambeck’s SCOPE and others) Specific Plan, will go before the Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors for even more public review and commentary. I suspect this group and others will write letters, attend and speak.
Lynne Plambeck has been to more public hearing on Newhall Ranch than any other single person in the entire Santa Clarita Valley. She has spoken dozens of times. She has written hundreds of letters. She has pored over thousands of pages of environmental reports from Newhall Land. She has penned numerous editorials.
So, the next time we hear Lynne Plambeck speak out about not being heard, let us all remember that she is the most outspoken opponent of development in our valley and she is well-informed about how the system works and has worked for years to take full advantage of it to move her own personal agenda forward.
Lynne Plambeck might not agree with the results of this public process, but she can’t say it doesn’t allow her or anyone else to fully participate and be heard. The county of Los Angeles has bent over backwards to allow full and complete participation in this planning process.
Larry Mankin is president and CEO of the Santa Clarita Valley Chamber of Commerce. His views represent his own, not necessarily those of The Signal.
