On Tuesday evening the Santa Clarita City Council, on a unanimous 4-0 vote, approved the designation of a consulting firm to provide the Environmental Impact Report for yet another gigantic project in the upper watershed of the Santa Clara River. One Councilman, Mayor Kellar, had to recuse himself, apparently because he is financially involved in the project.
This 1,200 unit “Vista Canyon” Project, located near Lost Springs Canyon Road and the Santa Clara River, will once again be in the flood plain. Riverpark and Soledad Townhomes, just down the road from this area, filled the flood plain with up to 30 feet of dirt in order to be “out of the flood plain.” Will this project do the same?
It also proposes to build over prime recharge areas that would help restore water to the Santa Clara River Aquifer, one of our drinking water sources. It is in an area the animals use to access the river from the nearby San Gabriel Mountains.
While assigning a consulting firm to prepare an environmental report for a project may seem to be a fairly innocuous first step in the development approval process, it is the first step.
For a Council that never says no, even when a project does not seem to comply with the city’s own Hillside and Ridgeline Ordinance, even when common sense says to stay out of the flood plain or concerns are voiced over protecting habitat and rare animals, or even when no one in Santa Clarita can get anywhere because of the massive traffic problems, the inevitability of the eventual approval seems an unfortunate, but likely, forgone conclusion.
One might ask how a project like this got far enough along in the planning department to warrant hiring a consulting firm to prepare an environmental document.
Do we really need additional housing approvals right now? Wasn’t the city just complaining to the county about how many approvals were taking place just outside their boundaries (some 10,000 proposed units)?
Didn’t the city just approve River Park and Keystone, for another 2,000 units? Didn’t the court just say that the hard-fought 2,500-unit West Creek project can move forward? What about the 600 units for Golden Valley Ranch that are in the grading stage, and the thousands of units in Plum Canyon? Really, isn’t Santa Clarita set for a while?
Or one might also ask how the city will complain about the traffic created by the CEMEX mine, the same mine that the city has spent millions of tax dollars to oppose, when they approve a 1,200-unit project generating thousands of auto trips a day. Vista Canyon is just down Highway 14 a few miles and uses the same traffic corridor. Is the traffic created by cars all right, while that created by mining trucks is not all right? I am not sure I see the difference.
But the question before us is the consulting firm. Impact Sciences is the same firm that prepared all the environmental documents for the Newhall Land projects along the Santa Clara River. Their biological consultants somehow forgot to disclose the spineflower in the Newhall Ranch area where Newhall Land was later fined for destroying this rare plant. Nor did they find several rare bird species and amphibian species in Newhall Ranch that were discovered by others later. Their biologists must sign a confidentiality agreement that they will not disclose to others any of their work for this firm. Why would one need such an agreement if all the surveys and creatures discovered are supposed to be disclosed in the environmental document?
And how about the water supply? Supposedly, it is up to the city to make an informed decision about the availability of water, but this consulting firm has routinely downplayed the problems in the Sacramento Delta brought to its attention. In January, at the order of a federal court judge, the Department of Water Resources cut its initial allotment of state water to the Santa Clarita Valley to just 25 percent.
The Friends and other groups have been submitting data for years showing that state water would have to be cut in order to ensure a functioning and sustainable Delta. Now it is happening.
Will the city approve another 1200 units and cut back the water supply for existing residents? Will Impact Sciences disclose such a possibility?
The purpose of an environmental impact report is to properly disclose the impacts a project will create.
The decision-makers and the public can then decide if the proposal is something that they want for their community. This report is also supposed to mitigate the impacts if possible. So if the impacts are not properly disclosed, the public loses in two ways. First, they will not know what the real problems are. And second, no solutions will be provided to lessen the damage. As Joni Mitchell sang in “Big Yellow Taxi,” “We won’t know what we’ve got ’til it’s gone.”
Lynne Plambeck is president of the Santa Clarita Organization for Planning and the Environment (SCOPE) and a Santa Clarita resident. Her column reflects her own views, and not necessarily those of The Signal.
