Already, the Santa Clarita Valley hillsides that blazed fiercely last October are starting to recover.
Nourished by rain and by the ash of October, they are transforming — black giving way to a pale carpet of green annuals that will turn to a riot of wildflowers in the spring if rainfall continues; shoots from the bases of blackened stumps that will grow back rapidly to replace the parent plant.
It’s a cycle to which the valley’s native oak woodlands and chaparral habitats are adapted, said Ian Swift, regional park superintendent for Los Angeles County.
But it’s also a cycle that can destroy those habitats.
“Yes, the habitat is adapted to fire, ... but it doesn’t necessarily need fire to rejuvenate,” Swift said in an interview at the Placerita Canyon Nature Center last week.
Since the early 20th century, Swift said, attitudes toward wildfire in Western ecosystems have gone through three phases. The fist, personified by Smokey Bear and his mantra, “Only you can prevent forest fires,” was aimed at suppressing any and all fires.
During the second phase, spawned by the environmental movement of the ’60s and ’70s, it was held that many Western habitats, including those native to the Santa Clarita Valley, actually “beg to burn” — that fire was the climax of a cycle that renewed growth and replenished native environments.
More recently, Swift says, has come recognition that old-growth chaparral is not at all a barren environment, and that wildfire can renew but also destroy — especially if it occurs too frequently and too massively.
‘Too Many Fires’
“We have way too many fires — certainly more than would ‘naturally’ occur,” Swift says.
The California Board of Forestry and Fire Protection agrees.
In a 2004 report, the board raises an alarm about increasing frequency of wildfires since “European settlement,” and it notes the danger fire poses to “ecosystem, air quality, fresh water supplies, private citizens, emergency services personnel, and the overall public health and safety of California.
“Much of the forests and rangelands have fuel and slope conditions that would support high or very high fire behavior when burned under severe weather conditions,” the report notes.
“Fires that burn in these areas under hot, dry, and windy conditions are difficult to control even by the world’s most comprehensive wildland fire protection system.”
Certainly that fire protection system was stretched to its limits in October, when nearly 500,000 acres were burned in Southern California and at least 1,600 homes destroyed, 21 in the Santa Clarita Valley.
In a speech delivered just months before those disastrous fires erupted, Ruben Grijalva, director of the California Department of Forestry and Fire Protection, noted the escalating costs of wildfires in California and outlined the department’s strategy “to keep 95 percent of fires at 10 acres or less.”
Wildfires and Indigenous People
Archeologists and other scientists have recognized that indigenous people in California sometimes set fire to their home territories.
Benefits included reducing thickets where grizzlies or other dangerous animals could lurk; encouraging browsing for deer, antelope and other animals they fed on; and reducing water consumption by deeper-rooted plants.
However, Swift said, those early residents of California certainly wouldn’t have set fires when Santa Ana winds howled through the canyons, potentially turning their foraging areas into what Swift calls “moonscapes.”
The most common non-human cause of fire is lightning strikes, but in California lightning is responsible for “not a lot of fires naturally,” Swift said. “Almost none.”
Further, he said, the combination of Santa Anas and lightning-bearing storms is virtually nil.
So the modern-day combination of Santa Anas and wildfire, coupled with an increase in the number of fires since the early 1900s, could mean destruction of native ecosystems.
“The more fires we have, the more the habitat is not going to recover,” Swift said. “In any environment, if major disruption after major disruption after major disruption occurs, the environment is going to change entirely.”
Already, Swift says, one of early California’s common habitats — areas of perennial bunch grass — has disappeared from the state, the native grasses crowded out by non-native grasses such as wild oats, which turn the hillsides golden in the fall.
A chaparral habitat that burns too frequently will give way to “weak perennials” or grasses that fail to offer the shade, protection, fruit or flowers offered by a healthy chaparral environment. Swift calls such an environment a “functional nothing.”
If fire strikes an area more than once in a 25-year span, the outlook for native plants is grim.
Other Threats to Native Plants
Fire isn’t the only threat to native plants. Non-native imports such as wild oats and mustard plants are taking over all around the state.
“Mustard is a truly, truly awful plant,” Swift said.
“It just crowds out everything.”
Mustard is native to the Mediterranean, and “pretty much any plant that comes from the Mediterranean — those plants are going to have an advantage” because of climate similarities.
Another threat to some native species is smog, Swift said.
Some seed-sprouting plants produce volumes of seeds that lie on the ground year after year, awaiting a mild acid released by mixing wildfire ash and rainwater.
That acid breaks down the seed coat and allows the seed to sprout, Swift said.
But smog mixed with rainwater mimics the same acid released by ash and rainwater, prompting the seeds to sprout under conditions that will not allow them to flourish.
“In some places, the mere presence of pollutants in the atmosphere is causing the seeds of chaparral shrubs to germinate,” Swift said.
But the seedlings don’t encounter the sunshine and enriched soil characteristic of a post-fire situation, and they die.
Ceanothus, a native wild lilac, and some varieties of manzanita are disappearing due to this problem, Swift said.
Value of Native Habitat
Swift acknowledges that some people may not share the naturalist’s enthusiasm for hillsides covered by scrubby growth characterized by muted greens and grays, along with the creatures that share those habitats.
But writing it all off as Darwinism in action misses one of the dangers of lost species, he says.
“Habitats that are the most diverse are the most productive,” Swift says.
“If we need anything from that ecosystem,” such as timber or grazing land, “there’s an economic price we pay, too.”
He compares lost habitat — lost natural resources — to a factory shutting down and taking its jobs to China or Mexico.
“A lot of societies have collapsed from that,” he said. “This will happen to us if we degrade our environment to the point that we cannot use it.”
* * * * *
Stages of Habitat Recovery from Fire
1. Immediately after the fire to about five years:
• Soil is detoxified. Many plants that exist in mature chaparral engage in a kind of “chemical warfare,” says Ian Swift, director of the Placerita Canyon Nature Center. Their roots exude toxins to discourage other plants from growing too close to them. “The heat of the fire cooks the soil to a certain extent and kind of detoxifies it,” Swift said.
• Soil is enriched. Ash from the fire becomes integrated into the soil and provides a “tremendous nutrient,” Swift says.
• Sunlight triggers growth. Soil that was previously shaded by shrubbery is now exposed to sunlight. If combined with adequate rainfall, these three conditions are optimal for quick growth of so-called “annuals,” plants that sprout quickly but usually survive only a season, dropping seeds that become subsequent generations.
• Shrubs begin recovery. Large chaparral shrubs, while reduced to ash and blackened sticks at ground level, usually survive due to extensive root systems, Swift says. If rain follows fire, they will begin “crown sprouting” — putting up new shoots at the base of the root system.
2. Five years to about 20 years after the fire:
Intermediate shrubs take over, including ceanothus (wild lilac), deerweed and Yerba Santa. Often sprouting from seeds that lie dormant until fire frees them, “These are plants that will hold their own amongst larger shrubs,” Swift says. “Up to 20 years or so they can grow in those chaparral habitats.” After that, the competition for sunlight is won by larger shrubs.
3. More than 25 years after the fire:
During the third, or “senescent,” stage, larger crown-sprouting shrubs take over. These include scrub oak, sugar bush and toyon (California holly). Each of these massive plants with huge trunks covers a broad area, offering fruit, flowers and shade to native animals. Some have roots that produce toxic chemicals in the soil to discourage other plants from growing too closely.
