Seven propositions will appear on the Feb. 5 ballot. Among the most controversial are four propositions dealing with Indian casinos.
The four measures, Propositions 94, 95, 96 and 97, ask voters to approve four gaming compacts with Indian tribes in Southern California — the Pechanga, Morongo, Agua Caliente and Sycuan.
If these measures are approved, the magnitude of the expansion in California gambling operations would be astounding: 17,000 more slot machines in just four casinos that now have around 2,000 slot machines each.
As of Jan. 18, more than $100 million had been spent on these initiatives (Propositions 94-97) making the gambling initiative battle the costliest in California’s history, according to an article from the Copley News Service.
The four tribes advocating the ballot measures have collectively spent an estimated $82.7 million. The opposition to the measures, which comes largely from two other casino-operating tribes (the Pala Band of Mission Indians and the United Auburn Indian Community), a casino workers union, and the owners of the Hollywood Park and Bay Meadows race tracks, have spent an estimated $25.9 million.
Fueling the propositions’ controversy is the fact that the voters’ decision on the Indian Casino gambling compacts may not even matter because of action taken by Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger.
Gov. Schwarzenegger supports the four Indian gambling compacts on the February ballot. He negotiated the deals with these four gambling tribes (the richest tribes in the state) and appears in campaign ads urging voters to vote Yes on Propositions 94, 95, 96 and 97 to ratify them.
But, as disclosed recently by the editorial board members of the Sacramento Bee newspaper, the governor also played a key role in a questionable series of events that may make next month’s vote on the compacts contestable if voters reject the propositions.
After the four compacts were ratified by the Legislature last year, they were sent to Washington, where the U.S. Secretary of the Interior is supposed to review and either accept or reject them. But after they arrived at Interior in Washington, the compacts were lost for 80 days.
Under federal law, the secretary has 45 days to take action or Indian state gambling compacts become law automatically.
The disappearance forced the federal agency to approve the agreements automatically without any review, even though they still face a statewide vote on California’s Feb. 5 ballot.
However, the compacts are not officially in effect until they are published in the Federal Register. Given the pending vote in California and the mysterious disappearance and reappearance of the California compacts, Interior Department officials initially said they would not publish them until after the California vote. But 16 days later Interior reversed their decision, and the compacts were published in the Federal Register on Dec. 19.
According to the Sacramento Bee, Gov. Schwarzenegger was interviewed about the casino compacts during an editorial board meeting when he was asked directly if he had asked Interior Secretary Dirk Kempthorne to publish the propositions in the Federal Register. According to the newspaper, the governor hedged, merely saying he asked Kempthorne to give “some attention” to the matter to make sure that “everything go through procedures.” Later, according to the same article, a spokesman for the governor said that Schwarzenegger had asked the secretary to publish the compacts.
The new gaming compacts are now officially part of federal law — even though the voters have not gone to the polls yet to cast their vote on the compacts.
If voters reject the compacts on Feb. 5, the premature federal approval could become the subject of a long legal fight. The question will be, “Does federal action supersede the California vote?”
In spite of this unraveling situation, voters must stay focused on the issue at hand and go ahead and cast their votes on Feb. 5.
Supporters of Propositions 94-97 believe that passage of the compacts will provide a significant amount of new money to California during a period of economic crisis. They claim that the new agreements provide new environmental standards and additional state oversight of tribal gaming. Supporters also claim that $198 million of the new revenues will go into a fund which will benefit non-gaming tribes around the state.
Critics claim that the compact amendments additional slot machines would give financial advantage to four powerful tribes with smaller gaming tribes unable to compete. They state that the agreements do not provide for a comment period for community members to voice environmental concerns. They claim casino workers are not given appropriate benefits or protection under the compacts. Opponents also claim that the agreements do not provide the level of revenues promised by backers of the plans. Many different labor groups and education organizations oppose the propositions along with several California tribes.
Critics also claim that gambling doesn’t create new economic activity. It simply substitutes one form of entertainment spending for another. More money spent gambling means less money spent on other recreational activities (activities which are taxed). Casinos on Indian reservations are exempt from taxes and instead pay the state through compacts.
In addition, many of these other recreational activities (going to the movies, eating out, and playing golf) don’t create gambling addiction or prey on the poor.
The growing political influence of wealthy gambling tribes who are not accountable to the wider public also worries many individuals. In a few years, gambling tribes have become the biggest political contributors in the state.
Already, regulators lack casino financial reports prepared by independent accountants; they are unable to conduct interim walk-through audits (as Nevada regulators do); they can’t station audit personnel at each casino 24 hours a day, seven days a week (as in New Jersey).
According to critics, the Big 4 tribes would make billions in profits, but their deals do not ensure basic health care, safety, and anti-discrimination protections for their employees. That’s why California labor unions are opposed. The Big 4 tribes have a history of suppressing worker rights, at great cost to California taxpayers.
Vote no on Indian Gaming Propositions 94, 95, 96 and 97 even though the compacts have already been printed in the Federal Register. Do not throw away your votes.
Cal Planakis is a resident of Santa Clarita. Democratic Voices rotates among SCV Democrats. Her column represents her own views and not necessarily those of The Signal.
