A class-action lawsuit has been filed on behalf of more than 400 Saugus residents against the builders, contractors, suppliers and manufactures of the galvanized steel pipes installed in three new-home communities in the 1980s.
The 413 single-family homeowners filed the lawsuit Sept. 23 to seek reimbursement or replacement of their galvanized steel pipes and damage caused by those pipes, after learning of a settlement of class-action lawsuits brought by other Santa Clarita residents with similar problems in the summer of 2000.
Several local water agencies are also named in the new lawsuit.
The 2000 settlement included thousands of area homeowners who shared a $41-million settlement paid by builders, contractors, suppliers and manufacturers for their respective roles in placing defective galvanized steel plumbing systems in 15 new-home communities from 1986 to 1994.
Among the defendants was Shapell Industries Inc., operator of S&S Construction Co.
Now, members of the El Dorado Home Owners Group — whose homes were built by Shapell — have filed a new class action in Los Angeles County Superior Court, seeking an unspecified amount of damages.
The listed defendants are: Shapell, Monteverde Development Co., Newhall Valencia Plumbing, C.I.R. Plumbing, Dongbu Steel Co. Limited, Dongbu USA, Hyundai Pipe of America, Union Steel, Fuji Pipe Manufacturing Co., Pusan Pipe America, Culligan Water Conditioning, M.J. Mang & Sons, Rayne Corp., Castaic Lake Water Agency, Newhall County Water (District), Valencia Water Co. and the Santa Clarita Water Co.
“They kept us in the dark about what was going on,” said Kathleen Thomson, president of the association that represents El Dorado I, El Dorado II and El Dorado Estates in Saugus.
Attorney Ron Hartmann of the Los Angeles law firm Quisenberry & Kabateck LLP, who was credited for recognizing the similarity of the plumbing problems that cropped up in the SCV and for spearheading the 2000 class action lawsuit settlement, said in March he had no comment on why the El Dorado homeowners were not part of the original lawsuit.
Christine L. Herdman, vice president and general counsel for Shapell, could not be reached in the past week for comment, but said in a March interview she also does not know why the El Dorado homeowners were omitted from the 2000 class-action lawsuit.
“We were never advised that we needed to inform them,” Herdman said. “My suspicion is they were outside of the 10-year statute (of limitations).”
Herdman said the issue is, where does the responsibility lie?
“If the home builder constructs the home in good faith, as we did, it is not reasonable to expect that builder to retain responsibility forever of things that could not be predicted,” Herdman said. “We were being advised to switch to galvanized steel piping because of the ‘aggressive’ water in the SCV.
“It’s not as if galvanized was controversial at the time ... and God knows it wasn’t a cost-saving method for us,” Herdman said. “Shapell is very sympathetic to the problem the homeowners say they are having.”
Attorney David Castenholz, who represents the El Dorado Home Owners Group, said his clients want the same restitution that the homeowners in the 2000 class-action settlement received.
“As my clients were among the first to have this (galvanized steel) pipe installed in their homes and as this entire tract has been affected in some way by the cheap pipes used in the construction of their homes, it is outrageous that they were not able to benefit from the (2000) lawsuit,” Castenholz said.
The El Dorado group claims that the galvanized pipes used in the construction of their homes have burst, leaked, brought mold, and even cost some homeowners their insurance coverage.
The lawsuit alleges that Shapell misled the homeowners by informing them that they had one type of plumbing system when they bought their homes, only to learn that another type had been installed.
“The (homeowners manual) states copper and PVC as part of our plumbing,” said Thomson, the group president. “It does not mention galvanized steel anywhere, and none of the original owners have any documentation stating such a substantial change in construction materials in presale or escrow documents.
“It is outrageous that we are left to shoulder the expense of making repairs on what (Shapell has) already essentially admitted to being at fault for (in other cases) by paying into the settlement fund.”
Herdman said in March she had no comment on the homeowners guide.
Castenholz said he believes Shapell misled people into believing they were purchasing homes with copper pipes, when in reality they were purchasing galvanized pipes, which he said were defective.
“Not only do we believe that misrepresentations were made with the sale of the homes, but there were also ongoing misrepresentations and concealments of the galvanized pipes,” Castenholz said. “We believe that certain practices on the part of the builder, which included patchwork on the pipe, further perpetrated the misrepresentation.”
Jim Allen, an El Dorado Home Owners Group member, said he doesn’t believe plumbing and electrical defects should be subject to a 10-year statute of limitations.
“A house can just collapse after 10 years and they aren’t responsible for anything?” he asked.
Repairing defective water pipes “is not preventative maintenance,” he said. “If that were the case, S&S would have installed access panels in my ceiling to fix my plumbing.”
