In my moonlighting gig as a part-time instructor for the journalism department at Cal State Northridge, we’ve been talking quite a bit the past couple of semesters about the issue of plagiarism, and the importance of making sure students know the difference between right and wrong when it comes to appropriating the work of others.
Most people seem to know what plagiarism means when asked.
But when it comes to practical applications, a lot of people — even journalists and those who aspire to be journalists — don’t seem to really get it.
We’re a society where music is “sampled” and songs are downloaded off the Internet so people can burn CD compilations of their favorite tunes.
Their favorite stolen tunes.
The same is true when it comes to the written words of others. A couple of months ago, when one of our staffers wrote a controversial column, she was widely criticized on Internet sites frequented by journalists.
And you know what some of those journalists did?
They stole her column.
They copied the column off of our web site, and posted it on other web sites without prior approval from The Signal.
Call it what you want. I guess it wasn’t technically plagiarism, because it still carried our writer’s byline.
But it was still stealing, which I found to be especially ironic because some of the same people who stole that column and posted it on their own web sites were the very same people who were on their journalistic high horses, criticizing our staffer for writing the piece in the first place.
And just this week, I became aware of another example of a piece of writing being stolen from our newspaper.
As a matter of personal policy, I don’t normally write about other local publications. But when they publish material that was stolen from The Mighty Signal, I make an exception.
There’s a little monthly publication in town called the “Sports Reporter.” It comes out just 12 times per year, but still claims to be the “premier sports publication serving the Santa Clarita Valley.” Whatever.
In its most recent issue, the Sports Reporter published a stolen story. It was a sports story, written on deadline late at night on Oct. 4 by our sports editor, Grant Gordon, and published in The Signal just a few hours later.
Here’s the lead paragraph of Grant’s story on the Oct. 4 football game between Canyon and Highland:
“Highland High made its second foray into the Foothill League Friday night, but after the flags ceased flying and host Canyon ticked off the final seconds, the Cowboys came away with a 4-0 start, there first since 1986.”
And here’s the lead paragraph of the Sports Reporter’s story on the same game:
“Highland High made its second foray into the Foothill League Friday night, but after the flags ceased flying and host Canyon ticked off the final seconds, the Cowboys came away with a 4-0 start, their first since 1986.”
Well. I’ve got to hand it to them: The editors over at the Sports Reporter managed to fix Grant’s typo in the lead (“there” instead of “their”), but Grant had to write the story on a tight, daily-paper deadline. They had a great deal more time to think about what they were going to do with the stolen story.
The plagiarism didn’t end there, either. The rest of the Sports Reporter’s story is lifted word-for-word from The Signal’s story. It’s blatant.
There is no byline on the Sports Reporter’s piece, nor is there any acknowledgment of the original source of the material. No permission was sought from The Signal, and it’s statistically impossible that two writers wrote the exact same story, with the exact same quotes.
In all fairness to the Sports Reporter, I guess it’s possible that the story thief was not a member of their staff. I suppose someone outside their organization could have submitted it to them, and it’s conceivable that they published the stolen story unwittingly.
Like us, they publish a great deal of material that is submitted by local sports teams and organizations — hence, a lot of their material bears similarity to the material we’ve already published in previous weeks. That’s harmless enough, because the information submitted by local coaches and team moms can essentially be classified as press releases. Grant’s story, though, was no press release.
Regardless of how this happened, it means someone thought it was just fine to lift the story from The Signal and republish it without credit or permission.
It’s a concept that we’re trying to drill home to the journalism students, and in the age of free-flowing information via e-mail and the Internet, it’s a lesson everyone needs to learn:
We may be a cut-and-paste society, but stealing is stealing. And it’s wrong.
Tim Whyte is The Signal’s managing editor. His column appears Sundays.
