A heated debate arose during a special City Council meeting Tuesday about the need for a trash sorting facility inside city limits.
The council voted 3-2 to proceed with its trash contract drafting process, excluding the requirement to include the facility, known in the trash industry as a materials recovery facility, in the upcoming contract bid process. Mayor Frank Ferry and Councilwoman Marsha McLean cast the dissenting votes.
The consultant hired by the council to assist it in drafting the city’s residential and commercial franchise agreements said it would be better off by holding off in requiring such a facility, also called a MRF (commonly pronounced “MURF”), until the city can conduct a study to find out if such a mechanism is necessary.
Councilman Cameron Smyth said he wasn’t sure if the call to install a “mini landfill” inside the city limits was the best course of action.
“We don’t know if a MRF in the city is the right answer,” Smyth said.
The city should conduct a feasibility study to answer that question, he said.
However, Councilwoman Marsha McLean disagreed with Smyth’s definition of a MRF.
“(A MRF) doesn’t resemble anything like a landfill,” McLean said. “It is not a ‘mini landfill’ and I wish people would stop saying that.”
McLean said the city should move forward with plans to install the trash sorting facility while it is drafting the contract so it can get the best price and conduct negotiations with haulers all at once.
“If we add it in later, we’ll have to raise rates later,” she said. “I hate to see us burying our heads in the sand.”
Smyth said the city doesn’t produce enough trash to own and operate a MRF and it would have to import trash from surrounding cities to make it economically feasible. Smyth heads the council’s trash subcommittee.
Laith Ezzet, the consultant retained by the council, said the city’s waste quantities are too small to maximize the MRF’s efficiency.
Ezzet said the city currently uses MRFs already in the city and in Oxnard.
There are two types of MRFs: “clean MRFs” where commingled recyclables are separated; and “dirty MRFs” where recyclables are separated from trash.
The two neighboring landfills, Sunshine Canyon, owned by Browning Ferris Industries, and Chiquita Canyon, owned by Republic Consolidated, anticipate constructing MRFs within the next few years. Both BFI and Republic, which also holds 15 percent of the residential contract, are expected to bid on the city’s trash contracts.
Current hauler Waste Management, which owns a landfill in Palmdale, is also expected to apply.
Ferry called what Smyth was proposing “criminal.”
“You can’t the genie out of the bottle,” Ferry said.
Ferry said the council should have held off voting until a study was completed. He said the city has been focusing on attaining its 75 percent recycling rate since 1995, and couldn’t understand how the council shifted in that goal.
“Somewhere down the road we took a fork,” he said. “We can still get a rate reduction and a MRF. We are going to take hits if we increase rates down the road.”
Ferry said the city should be cautious about the two nearby landfills closing, and ensure itself with long-haul trash hauling.
The council set the lucrative trash contracts out to competitive bid after a year of haggling over diversion rates. It was discovered that the city failed to meet state mandated recycling standards on the eve the council was set to award current haulers Waste Management and Republic a 10-year hauling contract.
At that time, a MRF was a part of the new “state of the art” contract, although a feasibility study was never conducted. The council tentatively awarded the contract to the two companies, only to withhold final approval in a decision a year later.
Now, the council is starting from scratch and the inclusion of a MRF in the contract has caused friction among council members.
Ferry and McLean benefited from $32,000 spent by Waste Management during April’s City Council election. The nation’s No. 1 trash hauler paid for phone banking and flyers for the two candidates and former Mayor Jan Heidt, who finished fourth in the election.
Smyth, who had originally voted to keep the haulers, changed his verdict earlier this year.
As with the 3-2 vote in March to put the contract out to bid, Councilman Bob Kellar cast the deciding vote Tuesday, saying the city must be prudent in its decision about spending millions on a facility it may not need.
Kellar also disagreed with Ferry’s classification of the council’s vote as criminal.
