Our news stories and editorials can’t do justice to the nature of the debate — and the post-meeting fireworks — that accompanied the City Council’s 3-2 vote Thursday not to require that a material recovery facility be built within city limits.
Tempers ran hot.
Accusations were made.
Decorum broke down.
Confrontations occurred after the split vote. In the hallways, in the parking lot — thankfully, it didn’t get any uglier than the raising of voices and the slinging of profanity.
In the end, in spite of the tension and in spite of two council members’ curious attachment to having a trash sorting facility within the city, your City Council did the right thing.
Three members — Cameron Smyth, Laurene Weste and Bob Kellar — correctly decided that a MRF should not be a requirement of the new city trash contracts that are going to be put out to an open bid process.
Smyth, Kellar and Weste acted in the best interests of Santa Clarita taxpayers, recognizing that a requirement to place a MRF within the city would likely result in higher trash hauling costs by preventing haulers from using MRF’s located at landfills.
The debate on the issue has been heated, and we’re especially gratified to see Kellar stick to his guns and make the right decision, because he has undoubtedly received a great deal of lobbying pressure from local haulers as well as individuals who would gain financially from the construction of a local MRF.
Mayor Frank Ferry and Councilwoman Marsha McLean cast the dissenting votes, and the public should be asking them:
Why are you so passionately attached to the notion of a trash sorting facility within city limits?
The stated reasons — things like better control over recycling — don’t fly. And the advice of the city’s own well-respected consultant indicates that it won’t matter whether a MRF is in the city — and if a MRF is built here, we’d have to import trash from other areas to ensure sufficient volume for the MRF to be worthwhile.
It’s ironic that McLean, a self-professed trash expert who gained notoriety for her efforts to prevent landfills from being developed just outside Santa Clarita’s borders, is now advocating the creation of a trash holding facility that would, in all likelihood, force more trash to be brought into the city.
For Ferry’s part, he is so attached to the notion of a MRF within our city that he called the council majority’s decision “criminal.”
The mayor owes his colleagues an apology.
We suggest that citizens, in evaluating the dissenting votes, follow the money:
Ferry and McLean in April’s election were both the beneficiaries of more than $30,000 in campaign spending by Waste Management Inc., the parent company of two local haulers — Blue Barrel and Santa Clarita Disposal — that wish to bid on the new contracts. Ferry has long conducted himself as an advocate for Waste Management.
Waste Management, unlike some other haulers likely to bid on the new contracts, does not have a landfill nearby. Its nearest dump is in Palmdale.
Two of its likely competitors — Browning-Ferris Industries and the third existing local hauler, Republic Consolidated — have landfills close to town, in Sunshine Canyon and Chiquita Canyon, respectively.
Republic and BFI plan to use MRF’s located at their landfills, which would be more cost-effective — and less disruptive to Santa Claritans — than building a MRF in town. Imagine, if you will, the odor and increased truck traffic, just for starters, that would accompany an in-town MRF.
So why build one here?
There appears to be little compelling reason, unless the goal is to give Waste Management a leg up on the competition. The circumstantial evidence, in the case of Ferry and McLean, is intriguing to say the least.
Fortunately, Santa Clarita has three council members — Weste, Smyth and Kellar — who realized that a MRF should only be required within the city if there is a definite public benefit to it.
They did what they were elected to do: They represented the interests of all Santa Claritans.
