Tuesday’s Castaic Lake Water Agency board election offers voters a choice between incumbents and some fresh faces in three races. A total of 11 candidates are campaigning for three regional seats and one at-large position.
Water systems engineer Tom Campbell is challenged by manufacturing engineer Gundy G. Tollefson and John B. Steffen, a retired biologist, for the at large seat.
In Division 1, incumbent Ed Dunn faces local teacher and retired military officer Edward Colley.
In Division 2, water resources manager Peter Kavounas is defending his board seat against the Sierra Club’s local chairman, Henry Schultz. It is Schultz’s second bid for the position.
The Division 3 seat will be filled by a newcomer — either water policy advisor Jacquelyn H. McMillan or Brian K. Roney, a park manager.
Each candidate was asked the same questions about issues pertinent to the agency — the cleanup of perchlorate contamination in area groundwater; water quantity and quality; growth; state legislation of water reliability; planning and procurement; as well as their personal goals.
AT-LARGE
TOM CAMPBELL
At-large candidate Tom Campbell is a civil engineer who has worked for the Metropolitan Water District as project manager for 13 years. Tom and his wife Chris have lived in the Santa Clarita Valley for 10 years and they have two daughters, Andie, 3, and Katie, 1.
Perchlorate
Campbell said it is a foregone conclusion that the Bermite property needs to be cleaned up; he favors legal action against the property owners who contaminated the land.
“The residents should not bear the cost,” he said.
He said CLWA is working with the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers to remove the water, treat it and return it to the system or use it to recharge the alluvial aquifer.
“The agency is taking the lead to look at actual treatment methods. We want to get started now rather than wait for the site to be treated.”
Water Estimates
There are two main sources of water for the SCV, said Campbell. The imported supply purchased through the State Water Project is less in question than local groundwater.
“Reliability of state water is open to interpretation,” he said. “We are fairly close in figures with the environmentalists and well within the safe yield.”
“Generally, we have decent water quality in the valley,” he said. “We reduce the hardness of the water by blending ground water with the state water.”
Growth
Campbell said the agency’s role is to be growth-neutral. However, state laws have made it necessary for water agencies to be more involved in the planning process for growth. The agency takes its cues from planners who are looking at water supplies 20 years or more in the future.
“We can’t afford to be caught sleeping,” he said. “I don’t think we should artificially contain the supply. It can lead to shortages.”
State legislation
The two bills require land-use planners to increase communication between the local government and water agencies. He cited the Monterey Agreement as a tool to buy additional water when needed.
“The historical agreement increased the flexibility to operate and facilitated transfers among the agencies,” he said.
Goals
Campbell said his goal is to arrange an agreement to bank water from an underground aquifer in the Central Valley.
“We can draw upon it in the dry years,” he said. “It is one example of how we can better manage what we have.”
He also wants the subject of water supply to be an afterthought for the public.
“When you turn on your water, it’s there,” he said. “People don’t have to worry.”
GUNDY G. TOLLEFSON
At-large candidate Gundy G. Tollefson has worked in precision aerospace for 35 years. He is employed as a manufacturing engineer for Avibank Manufacturing. Gundy and his wife, Katherine, have five children and have been married for 11 years.
Perchlorate
Tollefson is concerned about future residents, should the Porta Bella project be built on top of contaminated soil.
“The area is peppered with contamination and I am concerned about our ability to clean it up,” he said. “Future residents don’t know what used to be there. I hold the polluters responsible for the cleanup and want them to guarantee the land is safe before building on the land.”
Water estimates
Tollefson sees a need to monitor waste discharges from industrial centers in Hasley Canyon and Valencia.
“This affects the whole valley and we have to be careful,” he said. “We don’t want to price our water out of sight.”
Growth
Planned growth and smart planning are the keys to success for the SCV, said Tollefson.
“I’ve lived here since 1965 and I’ve seen a lot of change,” he said. “Haphazard, out-of-control growth is not good.”
State legislation
Tollefson said there is a need to make sure there is enough water for the community, and he supports state legislation to direct local government.
“If it takes the state to mandate common sense, then it makes sense to me,” he said. “If you are going to make promises, you have a fiduciary duty to provide adequate water supplies.”
Goals
Tollefson said he grew up in the SCV and has been active in many of the valley’s projects.
“I love this valley,” he said. “It is a wonderful place to live. I can provide common sense and reasoning to the issues of growth and the future of the Santa Clarita Valley.”
JOHN STEFFEN
At-large candidate John Steffen is a retired licensed lab technologist who has spent his life’s work in medicine and science. He has four children and six grandchildren.
Perchlorate
Steffen believes the contamination of the Saugus aquifer is the most serious problem facing CLWA. He believes it is ethical and bona fide to study the extent of the contamination. However, Steffen said the problem continues to exist because the Bermite property is passed from owner to owner every two or three years.
“It’s like musical chairs,” he said. “New owners bring their experts who have a certain naïveté on the subject. Then six months later, this great expert is let go and nothing is done. The problem is still there no matter who owns it.”
Water estimates
Steffen is concerned about CLWA’s estimates of the water supply in the event of another major earthquake or other natural disaster. He said there has been a 33 percent population increase since the 1994 earthquake, and he worries that the Newhall Ranch project will bring more residents in the near future.
“What happens if the water can’t be delivered during an earthquake?” he asked. “No one knows how much water is underground. The litigation could be horrendous.”
Growth
The building industry must have water for development projects, and CLWA is purchasing water for the Newhall Ranch property, said Steffen. He said the board is a closed club that needs more diversity.
“They are all water professionals except three,” he said. “The administration is tainted or biased and the party line is to get more water for developers.”
State legislature
Steffen said the SCV’s water supply is important because everyone needs water.
“Each day, the cost of the supply increases, and the water (supply) is dwindling because the population is expanding. It’s almost to the point of no return.”
Goals
Steffen wants to lend his science background to the board because he sees it as a “closed shop” with special interests.
“I am running because there is no diversity on the board,” he said. “I have no financial backing and I am not controlled by (The) Newhall Land and Farming Co.”
DIVISION 1
ED DUNN
Division 1 incumbent Ed Dunn is a retired aerospace engineer. He and his wife Joan are 33-year residents of the Pinetree community in Canyon Country. The Dunns have been married for 44 years and have three children and 10 grandchildren. Joan serves on the Newhall County Water District board of directors. Ed has spent 15 years attending water board meetings and the past four years as a CLWA director.
Perchlorate
Dunn wants to see the contamination in the Saugus aquifer cleaned up as soon as possible. He feels the state Department of Toxic Substances Control and the Army Corps of Engineers are slowing down the progress of the cleanup.
“The capability is there (to clean the groundwater),” he said. “We are better off if the retailers pursue contractors for the cleanup.”
Water estimates
Dunn said water quality in the SCV is compromised by the purchase of state water because chlorine is added to state water to maintain its purity after processing — which adds a carcinogen called trihalomethane, he said.
“The problem with state water is they misstate water quality,” Dunn said. “The state water boys say they have good-quality water, but the state water has to be treated. Pure water is from wells.”
Growth
Dunn believes in responsible growth for the SCV. He wants to see CLWA work for the entire SCV, not just developers.
“The agency has a history to overstate water supplies and understate demand so they can justify more development,” he said.
State legislation
State legislation regarding water has been put into law because the economy is driven by development, Dunn said.
“The agency’s most favored developer is developing everywhere,” he said. “They want the water supply for Newhall Ranch. They use consultants to lend legitimacy to the documents they put out and make it look like we have plenty of water.”
Goals
Changes in CLWA can be driven by the public and grassroots projects, said Dunn. He would like to see more of the public step up and get on the board. Personally, he said CLWA needs to be run more efficiently and that he could cut the budget in half if he could control the board.
“We need to run it like a business and they are not running it like a business,” he said. “There are too many lawsuits. The money wasted on the lawsuits should go to the public.”
ED COLLEY
Division 1 candidate Ed Colley is a retired captain in the U.S. Air Force, where he was a space systems engineer and intelligence analyst. He has been the junior ROTC instructor at Valencia High School for seven years. His wife of 25 years, Kathy, is a nursing student at College of the Canyons. The Colleys have lived in Canyon Country for seven years and they have six children and one grandchild.
Perchlorate
Colley agrees with the CLWA board’s lawsuit against the Bermite property owners. He said he is optimistic about the cleanup moving forward because it is a subject that has been ignored for too long. It is clear to Colley it will cost millions to clean the perchlorate from the groundwater.
“We should get the landowners, past and present, along with the federal government, to pay,” he said. “In this case, they took the right course of action. Leaning on the developers was a good idea.”
Water estimates
Looking forward to learning more about the water supply in the SCV, Colley applauds the “imaginative and aggressive efforts” by the CLWA to bring in water.
He said the CLWA needs to continue to update technology and have the best treatment plants. He is interested in finding alternate sources of water in the event of severe drought and proposes a groundwater management plan for future use.
“We can’t leave the wells shut down permanently,” he said.
Growth
Colley said CLWA does not control development in the valley, and its role is to provide water for people who already live here.
“In my view, the opposite camp wants to work against future development,” he said. “Intentionally not having water doesn’t make any sense.”
State legislation
Colley is in favor of logical and responsible legislation to protect water for current residents.
“This is the major issue of the people I talk to,” he said. “I pledge to represent those voters.”
Goals
Colley said he is running for his region’s seat because the incumbent Ed Dunn has done a poor job in representing the community.
“I want to be of service to my community,” he said. “Somebody needs to represent the folks in the SCV without a special agenda.”
DIVISION 2
PETER KAVOUNAS
Division 2 candidate Peter Kavounas has worked for the Los Angeles Department of Water and Power for 15 years and is currently the water resources manager. He and his wife, Danielle, have lived in Valencia for 14 years. They have two daughters, Gabrielle, 10, and Athena, 7.
Perchlorate
When CLWA sued Bermite, Kavounas said that was the right thing to do because of contamination within the top soil and toxins leaked to the groundwater.
“We are all being impacted,” he said. “The groundwater is treatable and I want it taken care of. It is 100 percent (the landowner’s) responsibility to clean it up. It is right to be proactive.”
Water estimates
Kavounas said there is only so much that can be done to alter the amount of water allocated to the Santa Clarita Valley. It is an issue that is driven by standards and regulations, he said.
“It is challenging to continuously upgrade our facility,” he said. “But we have no difficulty in meeting the standards. Water quantity is not black and white. We can never say we have enough.”
Kavounas said using reclaimed water makes good sense, and he wants to see more developers incorporate it in their plans. He also favors low-flush toilets and other water-saving methods to help meet the demand of consumers.
Growth
There is a vast difference between growth and development, Kavounas said. He describes development as homes being built on open land, and growth as when a new family moves into the area.
“The city and county care for the overall well-being of the community,” he said. “CLWA’s role is to provide all of the water services needed, and to work with the developers to determine the community’s needs and costs.”
Kavounas said Santa Clarita is a well-planned community.
“There’s a vocal minority that would like to see less growth,” he said. “But people have a right to own a piece of land, and it’s their right to develop on it.”
State legislation
Senate Bill 221 and SB 610 are state laws that require developers to prove there is enough water to support new development projects, Kavounas said.
“It (means) we have to do what we are already doing,” he said. “The law should go beyond to extend to other agencies.”
Goals
Kavounas would like the voters to make their decision on the issue of water quantity, and not development.
“I believe the role of the agency is clear,” he said. “It is not political. Its role is not to play a part in a debate over development.”
HENRY SCHULTZ
Division 2 candidate Henry Schultz is an engineer at Amgen in Thousand Oaks. His wife, Louise, is an English teacher at Canyon High School. The Schultzes have lived in Saugus for 22 years and have two grown children, Alex and Aaron. Henry Schultz is the current chairman of the Sierra Club’s Santa Clarita Valley chapter.
Perchlorate
Schultz said cleaning up the Bermite site will cost millions of dollars and the funding is difficult to get. He recommends more monitoring of the wells because some have shown signs of high contamination levels, he said.
“The insurance companies have begged out of it and no one wants to pay for it,” he said. “There’s no cheap way out. We need positive action and to be pretty firm about it,” he said.
Water estimates
Schultz said CLWA’s major issue is a water management plan. He said the agency’s estimates have been bad and wrong; the agency overspends and does not protect the land.
He claimed the agency overstates its state water supply when it cites its 95,000-acre-foot annual entitlement, rather than the lesser allocation it actually receives from the State Water Project.
“They don’t have 95,000 acre-feet and the courts have said they don’t have 95,000 acre-feet,” he said.
Growth
Schultz advocates smart growth for the SCV and he dislikes the sprawl created by “leapfrog” development.
“If you are going to grow, do it smartly,” he said.
State legislation
Schultz said CLWA has acted illegally in operating the Santa Clarita Water Co., and supports new state laws to increase accountability.
Goals
It is Schultz’s second bid for the board’s Division 2 seat. He said he learned from the last election and has garnered more support to go up against his “well-financed” opponent.
“I’m for low rates and high quality; what else can you say about water?” he said. “My slogan is, ‘Get rid of the water cronies and the developer toadies.’”
DIVISION 3
JACQUELYN McMILLAN
Division 3 candidate Jacquelyn McMillan has worked for the Metropolitan Water District for 12 years as a water policy advisor. She and her husband of 13 years have lived in the SCV for 15 years, including 12 in Castaic.
Perchlorate
McMillan said there is no doubt perchlorate is responsible for cancer and thyroid problems in people exposed to the contamination.
“We need to complete the studies,” she said. “We need to remediate (the land) and remove it (the perchlorate) from the water source.”
She said Bermite should be held responsible and forced to restore the land.
“We’re just going to have to buckle down, pull out the stops and go after them,” she said.
Water estimates
McMillan said the water quality coming from the tap is excellent and there is sufficient water to supply the SCV for the next 20 years. However, she wants to look at the groundwater system and make improvements.
“There are bills in place for funding to improve water treatment facilities and for additional studies on MTBE, perchlorate, chromium 6, (and) perchlorethyline, which is used in dry cleaning,” she said.
Growth
McMillan said there is a misconception that CLWA is using growth to control water.
“The environmentalists are looking for any reason to stop development,” she said. “(CLWA) doesn’t do things to help growth or hamper growth. They provide water.”
State legislation
McMillan thinks it is good to link development with current water availability because it forces the two industries to sit down and find solutions.
“Everyone realizes this state is suffering a housing crisis,” she said. “There needs to be a housing boom, and to make sure the needed water supply is there.”
Goals
McMillan wants to bring her professional experience to CLWA as a way to become more active in the community. She said the engineers on the board have a strict way of viewing the issues before them, and she can bring another viewpoint to the board.
“I want the agency to be more politically involved in the local lens,” she said. “If you don’t look at the bigger picture, you miss an opportunity. They need a larger voice in the greater picture of things. I can be a political voice reminding the agency of the larger scheme of things.”
DIVISION 3
BRIAN RONEY
Division 3 candidate Brian Roney is the park manager for the Casitas Water District and was general manager of Castaic Boat and Marine for five years. His 15 years of community service include Friends of Castaic Lake, the Castaic Area Town Council and the SCV Tourism Bureau. He and his wife, Jenny, have been married for 16 years and have two children, Heather, 14, and Spencer, 10.
Perchlorate
Roney said it was wrong to sue the owners of the Bermite property because CLWA spends too much money on litigation.
“I think it is right to seek solutions to decontaminate the wells,” he said. “More of the onus should have been put on the well owners rather than the agency.”
Water estimates
Roney does not see water quality as a serious issue for the valley because the state water is balanced with the groundwater.
“The aquifers sufficiently recharge themselves,” he said. “The agency erred in spending $42 million to purchase additional water. There is no need for it as far as the current development is concerned.”
Growth
Roney said he is not anti-development because new infrastructure can be good for the community. He said CLWA stimulates development by seeking out new projects like Newhall Ranch and Westridge.
“The water agency is not a growth-control agency,” he said. “They don’t encourage or discourage development. They should be neutral.”
State legislation
Roney said any new development in the SCV should have a definable and secure water source and noted that SB 221 applies only to developments over 500 units.
“With the exception of Newhall Ranch, most of the new development falls under the 500 limit and won’t (be affected by) the new laws,” he said.
Goals
Roney said he wants to bring common sense to the CLWA board. He is interested in practical conservation methods like low-flow toilets, instead of wasting millions of dollars on a conservation garden no one can access, he said.
The garden, located next to the SCV’s primary water treatment facility, was closed to the public after Sept. 11, 2001, as a security precaution.
“They spend too much money on lawsuits and their headquarters,” he said. “Their fiscal policies are lacking.”
