Two middle schools have decided to end the uniform dress code for the upcoming school year, citing lack of student participation and too much administration time spent on enforcement.
Students at Sierra Vista Junior High School have been wearing uniforms since 1996, and Castaic Middle School students since 1999. Both schools have had an “opt-out” policy that allows students to wear street clothes if parents sign a waiver.
Officials from both schools say the number of students wanting to opt out has grown every year.
“Last year we tried to encourage families to use uniforms,” said Randy Parker, principal at Sierra Vista. “We initiated casual Fridays. Unfortunately, we did not see the kind of success we hoped to see.”
There were also complaints about a “single-vendor” uniform store, so Parker said the requirement for clothing to bear the school logo was removed — allowing parents to purchase uniforms at larger stores such as Target and K-mart.
At a meeting with supporters of uniforms, Parker explained that any number higher than 50 students whose parents decided to “opt out” would make a uniform policy unenforceable.
More than 450 students chose to opt out this year.
Castaic Superintendent Beverly Silsbee said her middle school experienced the same low student participation, although younger students in grades four, five and six seem to favor the uniforms.
“We have the younger students on campus and a majority of them wore uniforms, but our seventh and eighth-graders did not,” she said.
Silsbee said it was hard to administer a program when a significant number of parents do not support it.
Instead, Castaic has initiated a strict dress code, and Silsbee said it will be enforced. Sierra Vista will institute a voluntary school uniform policy — meaning uniforms are acceptable but not necessary.
Board members from William S. Hart Union High School District were divided on the uniform issue.
Dennis King said the school may be taking away a tool to improve the school, and said he was sorry the policy was being eliminated. Others worried that students who chose to continue with uniforms would be singled out.
Board member Phil Ellis, however, pointed to the recent Blue Ribbon Award given to Arroyo Seco, a junior high without a uniform policy.
“I don’t think there is any supportive (information) that says a school needs uniforms to be good,” he said.
Parker said the school would like to keep the voluntary program because there are parents who like uniforms.
“We were a great school before uniforms, a great school with uniforms and we’ll continue to be a great school,” said Cathy Novean, an English teacher at Sierra Vista.
“I feel the school is a better school because of the program and there is more awareness on the part of the entire student body on what is appropriate,” said Silsbee.
Rob Gapper, principal of Placerita Junior High, said only a handful of students choose to opt out of the uniform policy there. La Mesa Junior High has had a uniform policy since the school opened in 1994.
The new dress codes and voluntary uniform programs will begin in the 2002-03 school year.
