Did the City Council make the right choice in hiring Ken Pulskamp as city manager?
Perhaps. But the council so proudly shrouded the hiring process in secrecy that it’s extremely difficult to draw an informed opinion.
The hiring of Pulskamp will certainly be popular with the local mover-and-shaker crowd. He is a smart, likable and witty fellow who has served as interim city manager since the May departure of George Caravalho, the city’s first full-time city manager whose final year here was a tumultuous one. Pulskamp served as Caravalho’s right-hand man for about two decades, joining Caravalho here after the two left Bakersfield.
We suspect — and hope — that Pulskamp will not prove to be Caravalho II. Time will tell.
However, the problems we’ve had with the hiring of a new city manager the past few weeks have had nothing to do with Pulskamp or his ability to do the job. The problem has been the process by which he was hired. That process was flawed, tragically, by factors like these:
— It appears certain that at least two City Council members had their minds made up to give Pulskamp the job long before any other candidates were interviewed. When you make such a choice while wearing blinders, it’s impossible to render a properly informed decision.
— The council secretly decided to appoint a citizens committee to help interview finalists, and secretly chose the committee members before announcing the panel’s formation. The circumstances of the committee selection leads one to believe the panel members were chosen by council members who were seeking a particular result. Secretly.
— The council and the committee interviewed the finalists Oct. 22, and the council did not meet again until Tuesday, when it officially offered the job to Pulskamp. A day before Tuesday’s meeting, city sources accurately leaked information on the eventual outcome, which resulted in a published report of the decision before it was officially made. We wonder how those sources were so certain of the hiring in the absence of a City Council meeting in which the decision could legally be made.
— All five council members rolled along with the process — even a council member or two who privately objected to the way the search was handled — resulting in unanimous votes, sometimes more for the sake of political expediency than anything else. In their complicity, they share responsibility for the flaws in the process.
— Two council members were negotiating with Pulskamp before Tuesday — yet the mayor insists the council didn’t discuss the hiring during the time between the interviews and Tuesday’s meeting.
How, then, could the council’s negotiators have been so certain they were negotiating with the right candidate?
Is the answer telepathy?
At what point did the council actually decide to hire Pulskamp? On whose authority were council members engaged in negotiations with him?
It’s clear that everyone close to the decision knew it was a done deal well before Tuesday’s vote, yet no council action had been reported to the public, and no legally noticed meeting occurred on the matter until Tuesday.
Perhaps this is all smoke and no fire. Perhaps the council followed the letter of the law perfectly. Perhaps no illegal “serial meeting” occurred, where a decision is made by a council majority without benefit of a legal meeting.
But considering our council’s recent propensity to err on the side of secrecy, we can’t help wondering.
Our new city manager has many difficult tasks ahead of him, and we wish him success. As we said, this isn’t about Ken Pulskamp. It’s about the City Council. Hopefully, the council’s handling of the hiring process will not serve as a model for the future conduct of our local government.
The council may have hired the right person, but the process by which the council made its decision was shameful — and one of Pulskamp’s first orders of business ought to be a frank discussion with his bosses regarding the importance of doing the public’s business publicly.
